He Cheats On You With Your Sister. (Request) (Part 2)

3.3K 27 4
                                    

Michael - . You slammed the door, turning around and seeing Michael standing there, tears in his eyes too. “Michael get your shit and go, or I will call the police.” “Y/N,” You held your hand up as he sighed, walking upstairs. You felt like crying again, the thoughts creeping back up on you as you watched Michael go towards the bedroom. But you stopped yourself, there is no need in crying over a situation that’s already handled. You rolled your eyes as you heard sobbing upstairs but this was all Michael’s fault and now he was going to deal with the consequences, even if that did mean he had to deal with them on his own. You sat on the back of the couch, as you saw Michael with all of his bags in his hands. His face was flustered and wet and you knew he didn’t even properly pack, probably throwing his clothes all in so he could get out of your way. He sauntered down the stairs, looking up at you one last time as you got up to open the door for him. “Y/N i’m sorry, just please don’t make me leave.” You shook your head, holding the door knob as you stared at him. “Michael you cheated. And not only that, with my sister. I can never forgive you so just please, go.” You opened the door as he dropped to his knees. “Y/N please!” You swatted at his hands as you held back a few tears of your own. “Michael please get the fuck out before I seriously call the police!” He sniffled, wiping his nose as he grabbed his bags. “Okay. I’ll go.” And with that he left, leaving you alone so he could wallow in his guilt and so you could wallow in your sadness and also your hatred for the both of them.

Luke - “We’re over Luke, go have fun with that skank.” With that you left, Luke angrily looking at your sister as she sighed. “See what you did?” And with that he slammed the door behind him, leaving your sister outside alone. Once you arrived to your moms, you began to cry again, resting your head against the steering wheel as you unbuckled yourself. You promised yourself you wouldn’t cry, but you knew something like this would happen one day. Your sister had stolen one of your boyfriends from you before but she’s never went this far so you were kind of stunned. “Y/N, baby what’s wrong?” Your mom asked, opening the door as she tugged on your arm. “Luke cheated on me with her.” You said, hiding in your mom’s shoulder as she rubbed your back. “Who is her?” “Y/S/N.” She shook her head, hugging you tighter before bringing you in the house to talk. Midways into the talk your phone buzzed, it was Luke. “Hello?” “Y/N, I don’t want you to leave me. Please come home so we can talk.” “The worst thing you could EVER do to me is cheat on me with my sister. Please just have your stuff packed when I get back to MY house.” And as you arrived back home, his stuff was gone and you knew that it was really happening, you let him go and surprisingly, you were quite happy with that.

Ashton - You looked at him as he handed you the flowers. You took them and sighed, “Ashton you still cheated on me and that doesn’t change a damn thing.” Shaking your head you sat the flowers down. “I need time to think.” And with that you shut the door, beginning to cry again. You laid in bed that night, looking at the flowers on your dresser as you held tight to Ashton’s pillow. A few of his bandannas were tied all around the bedroom, his t-shirt on your body as his pillow smelled faintly of the wood on his drums. You couldn’t help yourself, beginning to sob again as you dug your head into his pillow. “Why did you do this to me?” You cried, bawling up your fists as you felt the need to punch something to relieve your anger. You sat up, punching the headboard before lying back down, your sobs of pain slowly lulling you to sleep. “Y/N, wake up.” You opened your puffy eyes, seeing Ashton standing there as he shook you gently, the sun burning your sensitive eyes. “How’d you get in?” He held up the small key, smiling. “I missed you.” He began to crawl into the bed as you shook your head. “No Ashton, I can’t take you back.” You sniffled as his face dropped. “Why? I told you it was a mistake.” “No it wasn’t a mistake. You were going to fuck my sister and I don’t want to even look at you knowing you touched her.” You turned your head as he sighed. “So we’re over?” You nodded as he grabbed a bag and began throwing clothes in it. “Maybe one day you’ll realize how much you need me.” You rolled your eyes, getting up and going to the bathroom until he left, crying softly as he angrily threw his clothes into his bags.

Calum - “Y/N it doesn’t have to be like this.” You chuckled and pushed them down the stairs and towards the front door. “Oh yes it does. Good riddance.” With that you slammed the door but noticed Calum’s clothes on the floor. You picked them up and opened the door, throwing them at his face before slamming it again. You sunk to the floor, pulling at your hair as you began crying for the second time in the span of 10 minutes. You were sure to be cried out by now, but the tears just kept coming. The worst part about the whole situation was that you had no idea that this was going on for weeks. The nerve of those two. A knock on the door made you jump as you stood, seeing Calum, now fully clothed. “Please go away.” You whined, putting your hand out in front of him as he tried to grab you. “Y/N, baby we never wanted you to find out.” You snorted as you rolled your eyes. “Bloody hell! But now look at me! I found out on my own and you’re a dick Calum. I’m glad we’re breaking up.” “I’m not! I don’t want to live without you.” You shook your head as his eyes began to get watery. “Well game over Calum, thanks for playing.” You slammed the door, going upstairs to try and wash away all the pain you were feelings. 

5SOS preferencesWhere stories live. Discover now