Assorted Riverdale Imagines

Dilemma- Reggie x Sweet Pea x reader

You were had trouble making decisions. Deciding on what you wanted to eat. Getting a drink. And, surprisingly enough guys. You were currently talking to Reggie Mantle, a Riverdale Bulldog and big time Northsider. And, you were also talking to Sweet Pea, a Southside Serpent and a big time Southsider. They also happened to hate each other, more than anything. You liked both of them equally. They were both so sweet and caring. They were protective of you and they always wanted to make sure they were around. No matter, if the other was there or not. They got along, a little, when they were around you. Sure there was the incredible amount of testosterone that filled the room with them together.
"Guy," You sigh sitting in a shiny red booth at Pop's. "I can't do this."
"Do what?" Betty laughed.
"Choose!" You almost snap at the blonde. "I can't choose between Reggie and Sweets. I know, you like Sweets because he's your friend and he's an amazing guy. And you like Reggie, because he's your friend and an amazing guy. They both are so, amazing. I don't want to say love, but really, I think I am in love with them both."
"Oh," Toni pushes her lips together as Veronica rubs her neck. "Well, maybe they can come with a compromise. There are things called poly- relationships. You can go out with both of them."
"But, they don't like each other," you look at her. "They can't stand each other."
"Then, make them," Veronica says. "Use your femininity."
"I think that, maybe, T and I can definitely talk to them," Cheryl nods.
"I can get them together," Betty nods. "And, if it doesn't work out. We will also be here for comfort." She puts a reassuring hand on your shoulder. "We love you."
"Thanks guys," you sigh and pull your phone out to text the two.
Heya, meet me at Pop's. Need to talk to the two of you. Much love.
You place your phone down and your hand was shaking. You hadn't been this nervous in a long time. It wasn't about your feelings or how they react towards you. It's how they were going to react towards each other. You see Reggie's car pull into the parking lot at the same time Sweets pulled in on his bike.
"Alright," Cheryl nods. "T and I will escort them to the other table and start the conversation. It will be fine."
"Boys," Toni smiles. "This way first."
"What is going on?" You can some annoyance in Reggie's voice as they place him at another booth. "We are here to see Y/N."
"We know," Cheryl says and there is definitely cockiness in her voice. "That's why you are here. We want to start it off."
"Then start it off," Sweets sighs and his leather rubs against the seat.
"Look, Guys, Y/N likes the both of you. She really does and she doesn't want to choose between the two of you," Toni explains. "She is so happy with the both of you."
"Both of us?" Reggie asks confused.
"Yes," Cheryl says. "Both. As in the two of you guys. She loves the both of you equally."
"She wants to be with both of us? How?" Sweet Pea clarifies the question.
"There is a thing called polyamory," Toni says. "You can both date her. No picking sides. No hierarchy. Equality. But, the two of you.."
"You don't get along and obviously it wouldn't work out. So you need to start getting along if you want it to work out," Cheryl said.
"Polyamory?" They both say.
"Here," Toni says and you hear something slide against the table. "It's the only way for you to get her. If not, she can't be with either of you. Obviously, she doesn't want that."
"Can we just have a minute?" Reggie says slowly and you feel your heart begin to race. You here Toni and Cheryl get up and they come to your table. Betty gives you a reassuring smile and Veronica places a hand over yours.
"Y/N," Reggie calls over to you. "Can we talk?" You take a deep breath and slide from the booth. The walk seemed like it was forever, but it was only three tables down. "Sweet Pea and I were talking."
"Okay," you nod slowly. "Look, I understand if this is too weird for you both. I do, it's just... I really like the both of you and I don't want to lose you."
"Sh," Sweet Pea says holding up a slender finger. "We talked. We fight, a lot. And we are totally different people. Come from the opposite sides of the world practically." You nod unable to figure out what they were saying.
"We like you," Reggie said. "That doesn't change. So, we think that we can do it."
"What?"
"We think that we can do the poly thing," Sweets smiled. "We don't want to lose you. We want to do it."
"Really?" You smile now and they nod with smiles on their faces. "Oh, guys!" You jump up and hug them both. "This is so great!" They hug you back.
At first it was weird, they were both dominating types. So, they fought over where their arms went when you all watched a movie or who got to cuddle you. But, it all fell into place after a month and a few weeks. They didn't argue over anything anymore. Of course they still bickered, but it was mostly playful.
"Hey," Reggie smiled coming up to the two of you at your lockers. "Coming to the game tonight?" He looks at the two of you expectantly.
"Of course I am," You laugh. "Haven't missed one yet."
"I am too," Sweets nods. "Wouldn't miss it."
"Great," you could see a light behind his eyes and he seemed a lot happier. "What are you doing before?"
"Probably just hanging out," Sweets shrugs. "But, we can celebrate your victory at Pop's. I'll get you a chocolate milkshake."
"My victory?" Reg laughed a little, but his cockiness showed. "It's more than a victory, it's going to be a triumphant moment of all time. I am making my return tonight."
"You are so weird," you laugh. "You wouldn't have had to sit out if, you didn't fight that guy Trevor."
"He had it coming," they both argue.
"Doesn't matter," you sigh. "You do it after school. Now, I have to get to class. I'll see you later." You kiss Reggie first then Sweet Pea. "Don't get to anymore fights."
"I won't," they both deadpan.
"Did you just kiss both of them?" A blonde runs up to you. "Reggie Mantle and the Serpent..."
"Sweet Pea," you correct.
"Yeah him," she nods. "Did you?" You nod. "I thought they were dating each other... How did you get both of them? And they aren't fighting?"
"Magic," you shrug. "Or luck. I'm not entirely sure, but I am dating both of them."
"So, you are all dating each other?" She questions. "That sex has to be so hot." Your eyes widen at the comment. "No sex?"
"It's not exactly that far into the relationship," you shake your head.
"Oh," she nods. "It's cool you are like a three person couple. Everyone kinda thinks Reggie and Sweet Pea have been going out. Like just them." You nod. "Do they ever kiss?" You furrow your eyebrows. "Sorry, it's weird."
"I really gotta pay attention," you say ending the conversation. She nods and goes to her desk and you bury your face in your arms. You meet the two at lunch and they are in conversation when you sit.
"Andrews is so fucked right now," Sweet Pea nods. "He hasn't really been himself, hey princess."
"Yeah. I don't think he's really gonna be able to do football anymore," Reggie says. "He's been through too much. Hey, gorgeous."
"So," You say. "I gotta a little gossip about the two of you." They raise their eyebrows. "Everyone thinks that the two of you are dating. Just the two of you."
"Really?" Sweet Pea chuckles.
"We do spend more time together," Reggie shrugs taking a sip of his drink.
"And, we kinda are dating," Sweets adds. "We all are."
"True," Reg says as he takes one of Sweet Peas fries. "Who said that?"
"Some blonde in my sociology class," you shrug. "I just wanted to tell you before you heard from someone else and things got weird."
"It's not weird," they both reassure. "Are you jealous?"
"Of what?" You laugh.
"That you don't get to be part of the gossip," Reggie chuckled. "What else?"
"No," you shake your head. "Why would I be jealous? I'm glad you two have a relationship. All that matters is that we know what we are." They nod.
"She's jealous," Sweet Pea chuckled. "Don't worry princess, you are still part of the equation."
"Yeah," Reggie says and kissed your forehead. "What else was said?"
"She asked if the two of you kiss each other, and if the sex was hot," You say taking Sweets Pepsi. "And how I managed to get the both of you."
"Nice," Sweet Pea nods. "What did you say?"
"We don't have sex, no comment on the kissing, and I told her luck on how I got the two of you," you count off.
"Our sex would be hot," Reggie agreed. "We are three hot people."
"True," Sweets nods. "And, I think I'm the lucky one to have the both of you."
"Please, I was an ass before you guys," Reggie shook his head. "Like over the top."
"True," you and Sweets laugh.
"I was hoping for something a little more reassuring," Reggie shook his head.
"We still love you," You say. "Don't worry."
"Yeah," Sweets nods again. "We still love you, somehow." Reggie throws a grape in the raven haired boy's direction who quickly dodged it.
"You guys are too cute," Toni smiles sitting at the table. "Right Fangs?"
"Yeah," the tan boy nods. "Sometimes too cute. I am so tired of hearing about you guys at home."
"Awe, you talk about us?" Reggie teases with a chuckle. "Don't worry, Y/N does too."
"So does Reginald," you shake your head. "To his mom at least. For known reasons."
Later, you sit on the closest bench to Reggie as possible with Sweet Pea. You cheer the team on as loudly as the two of you can. When Reggie makes a shot, you both scream his name and he winks at you. When the game ends the Bulldogs win by like fifteen points. You run to him and jump into his arms. He laughs catching you before you both fell. You kiss him briefly before he sets you down. He gives Sweets a hug. You guys go to Pop's and they sit next to each other and you across.
"That was an epic game," you say. "You were so great!"
"I had my two charms," he shrugs. "And, I'm awesome."
"Calm down, narcissism," Sweets shakes his head. The sound of the doorbell draws your attention and you see a few other bulldogs come in.
"Yo, Mantle," one shouts. "You played like a beast today, bro!"
"Yeah, you must've had your good luck charm," another says. "Which one?"
"Does it matter?" He asks not even turning in his spot. "We are tryin' to have a quiet dinner."
"Sorry man," the first one says. "Didn't mean to intrude on your date." They seemed to waiting for him to argue that it wasn't a date, but Reggie kept quiet and sipped his chocolate milkshake. You watched them find their seats.
"Is this a date?" You ask, with a laugh. "Have we actually had one of those?"
They both look at each other and shrug, "if you count the time Sweets asked us to the fire."
"It was a party," he corrects.
"Oh yeah," you laugh.
"Movie nights," Sweets adds.
"We come here all the time," Reggie says.
"Okay," you laugh. "I get it."
"So," Reggie's voice loses its teasing tone and becomes serious. "I was thinking, and It may be a little soon. But, I think we should go to Greendale together. I mean, I have to go for Basketball and my parents aren't going. They are paying for my room though."
"You want to go on a trip?" You confirm and he nods. "I think that sounds fun."
"Me too," Sweets nods. "We can have a lot of fun over there." He gives a smirk to show he was being dirty. You roll your eyes.
"Where are we staying?" You ask. "Tonight I mean."
"We can stay at my place," Reggie shrugs. "It doesn't matter to me."
"Me either," you and Sweets say in unison then laugh.
"Sweets, we never stay at your place," you point out. "Why?" You see his smile fall into a straight line and creases form on his forehead. "Babe, what is it?"
"Nothing," he shakes his head and Reggie nudges him. "My place isn't as nice as the two of yours. And, it's obviously not in the greatest of places."
"We don't care about that," Reggie chuckled and Sweets rolls his eyes. "Really, Sweets, we don't. As long as it has you. You could live in a box and we wouldn't mind. Of course, if you did, I would insist on you staying with Y/N." They both laugh. "Joking... But, just because your house isn't the same doesn't mean we don't want to be there. We aren't posh kids."
"Most of the time," you correct. "He can be a little, eh." You make a gesture with your hands. "But, he is right. How about we stay at your place tonight? I'll grab a bag at home and Reg can too. It will be fine." You grab one of his hands and run your thumb over the top of it. In comparison to his, yours was much smaller. He and Reg on the other hand had very similar sized hands. He directs Reg to his trailer and tells him to lock his car when you all get out.
"This is my place," Sweets sighs as in slight distress.
"It's great," you reassure him with a smile and kiss. "Really." He gives you a small smile.
"You live here alone?" Reg asks looking around and Sweets nods. "And, we haven't been here why?"
"Let's play a game," you suggest. "Let's play truth or dare!" They give you confused looks. "It will be fun. I don't turn down a dare. Sweets go first."
"Fine," He shakes his head. "Truth Or dare, Princess?"
"Dare," you shrug.
"I dare you to... Take off that hideous spider man shirt," he says. "It looks old as hell."
"It is," you argue. "What do you suppose I wear?"
"Whatever you have under," he smirks and Reg nods in agreement. You raise an eyebrow, but lift the old shirt and pull it over your head. They both whistle and you shake your head.
"Reg, truth or dare," you ask.
"Let's go with truth," he shrugs and you make a chicken noise. "Shut up, you start easy."
"Fine. Tell us what you thought about this relationship when it started," you say. "After Pop's."
"I thought that I really wanted it to work," he says. "I did not think that, I would be so close to him though. Or have so much in common." You both nod. "Truth or dare, Sweets?"
"I'll go with dare," he says.
"Okay... I dare you to lick her leg," he says with a shrug. "I did not think." You laugh as Sweets wiggles his eyebrows at you then runs his tongue down your leg.
"Truth or dare, Reg," Sweets says.
"Dare."
"I dare you to call Fangs and tell him you want to ask us to elope," Sweet Pea said.
"Both of you? Like to me?" Reggie laughed and he nods. Reggie pulls out his phone and dials the number.
"Hello?" You can hear how confused he was for Reggie to be calling.
"Fangs," Reggie says with a bouncy voice. "So, I know you are like Sweet Pea's best friend and like brother. You are also pretty close with Y/N, so I wanted to talk to you about something."
"Yeah?" Fangs asks still confused. You hear Sweets phone buzz and he chuckled lowly before showing you the message.
Fangs: Dude, Why is Reggie calling me? I hat doe he want to talk about this late? Did you guys fuck?
You laugh shaking your head and Reggie gives you a look before continuing, "I was thinking that I wanted to ask them to marry me."
"Marry you?" He sounds more interested. Sweets phone buzzes again.
Fangs: Dude message me back! Right now! Reggie wants to get married. This is weird wtf did he call me???
"Yeah, man, they are like super important to me and I honestly can't imagine myself with anyone else," Reggie keeps playing. "They are so great, you know?" You start to feel a little tired sitting there.
Sweets: He must be drunk, he went out with friends to celebrate his win.
Fangs: well he's pretty trashed then! He said he can't think of anyone else he wants to spend his life with other than you and Y/N
"Yeah, they are pretty great," Fangs says slowly. "Hey, are you drunk?"
"Uhm," Reggie looks at the two of you. "No?"
"Okay... Well have you talked to them?" Fangs asked. "Because, it's also kinda illegal."
"Yeah," Reggie says with a sigh. "But, not if I elope one and the other is just a spiritual marriage. Not technically a legal marriage. And, it's usually overlooked unless we are hurting people. And, we don't have children."
"Sure," Fangs sighed. "But, do you want to risk that?"
"I love them," Reggie says. "I should marry Sweets legally. And, the three of us can be spiritually united."
"Okay..." the phone buzzes again.
Fangs: he wants to marry you man! Like legally!
Sweets: everyone wants to marry me. Your point?
Fangs: he wants to marry you soon and I don't know what to say bc he is talking about spiritual crap is he with the farm?
"You should really talk to them," Fangs says again. "It is kinda new in the relationship."
"Alright, I will get back to you," Reggie said then hung up. "That was awful."
"Funny though," Sweets chuckled. "It's your turn."
"Y/N?"
"Dare."
"Kiss me," he said and you roll your eyes and crawl over to him and connect your lips. His hands run down your bare back. "It's hotter without your shirt." You go to sit in your spot.
"Sweetsss."
"Dare," He said.
"Kiss Reg," You say, you've been thinking about since the blonde brought it up. What would it be like? Hot? Passionate? Slow?
"Really?" He chuckled. "I gotta take my shirt off too?"
"If you want," you laugh. "Your body."
"I think I'll keep it on," he says and Reggie looks at him for a second. "How long?"
"Does it matter?" Reggie obviously becoming impatient grabs the other boys face with both of his hands and connects his lips with his. You grab your phone to snap a picture of the moment. You can literally see the surprise on both of their faces and then as they fall into it. You see them relax against each other and it was kinda hot. You couldn't lie to yourself. As they break apart you have a smirk on your face. "That was hot."
"You say I'm weird," Reggie rolls his eyes.
"You guys are so much closer now," You point out. "You know that right?"
"Yeah. It means we are one step closer to making millions from an extremely hot porno," Reggie chuckled. "You can film." He smirks at you.
"I'd honestly love that," you play his game. "'Specially since the two of you would take half an hour arguing over who is more dominant."
"It can be equal," Sweets shrugs. "Truth or dare?"
"Truth," you say yawning as exhaustion washes over you.
"What's your goal for this relationship? Being that marriage is illegal," he asks.
"Erm... I really just want us to be happy," you say. "I want us to be able to still have that kind of life together. You two being close like how I am with you two. Maybe a kid or two. I don't know." They nod along. "What do you want?"
"The same things," they say.
"I'm so tired," you yawn. "We should get to bed." Reg chuckles and pulls you into him. His big arms wrapping protectively around you as he kisses your forehead. "I need to change." Another yawn escapes your lips. Sweets grabs your bag and your sleep clothes out. He helps you pull the oversized shirt on and then you pull your jeans on. He hands you your pants but you just shoo him away.
"You sure?" He asks and you nod. "Alright... Come on." He grabs your hand pulls you up to your feet. "We're gonna go to my bed." You nod again as he ushers you to the back and lays you in the bed. He lays on one side of you running his fingers through your hair to help soothe you to sleep and you feel Reggie climb in behind you. He rubs your back and they both do that until you fall sleep. You wake up with both of them snuggled into you and their hands touching each other's.

I might actually do a part 2 for this like maybe the Ghoulies come when they are at Sweets place or someone makes fun of the reader comment your ideas or requests ❤️