Guess I'll Be The One (Before You Exit & Toby McDonough Fanfic)

Truth or Dare

Riley's POV

"I choose... Dare," I said trying to be confident.

"Ok... I dare you to kiss Malia," Eli smirked.

"Well this got very interesting," Connor laughed.

"Fine," I accepted the dare and kissed Malia on the cheek. "You didn't specify where," I smirked as Eli rolled her eyes.

"Malia Truth or Dare," I asked.

"Dare."

"I dare you to drink a cup of ketchup."

"Ok fine," Mali said calmly and headed to the kitchen and poured herself a cup of ketchup.

"Did you know that Mali loves ketchup?" I stared at Eli and shook my head. Then Mali gulped down the ketchup and came back and look normal.

"Ugh that was a waste of a dare."

"Anyways, Connor truth or dare," Mali asked.

"Uh dare."

"I dare you to allow me to put make up on your face and then you have to take a picture and post it on Twitter," Mali smirked as Connor's face turned from happy to horrified.

"Uh how much make up do you have to put on me?"

"Until I am satisfied with my work," She replied.

Then Mali dragged Connor upstairs we could hear Connor yelling, "Ugh" the whole time.

"While we wait for those two to finish, Toby you go," I said as I lied down onto the floor.

"Alright, Eli, Truth or Dare?"

Eli's POV

"Um truth."

"Chicken!" I heard Riley yell as he was lying on the floor with his eyes covered by his hands and his mouth was open. So I got up from my seat, went to the kitchen opened the fridge and got my whipped cream. I looked over at Toby and he got what I was doing so he got out his phone and started videoing.

I walked over to Riley and sprayed whipped cream in his mouth which caused him to shoot up from his lying position with whip cream in his mouth. Me and Toby started laughing hard because what Riley doesn't know is that I put whipped cream in his hair also. So he looked like a cupcake.

Then Connor came down with pink eyeshadow, mascara, pink lip gloss, and foundation on his face. I took a picture of that and posted it on my Twitter with the caption "Love your makeup it really suits u @ConnorMcDononugh! And I love your style @RileyMcDonough!#PlayingTruthorDare w/ @TobyMcDonough and @Maliagirl" Then I attached both pictures of Connor and Riley to the tweet. Everybody looked at their phones and laughed as they favorited and retweeted it.

"Now that's done let's finish the game. Eli Truth or Dare?" Toby asked.

"Truth."

"Okay what was inside the brown box that I saw when I helped you move into this house?" Instead if answering I ran upstairs, to my room, and grabbed the brown box that was hidden under my bed. I walked downstairs to the everyone else. I sat down between Toby and Malia and opened my box.

Inside the box was photos of me and the McDonough brothers when we were younger; all of the jewelry I got when I was younger, from the McDonough's; and then I rushed upstairs because I realized I forgot something. Behind all of the pillows in bed was the one thing that resembles Toby's and mine friendship the most.

I put it in a box and carried it downstairs. I gave it to Toby and he opened it. Once he saw it he had a wide expression and a huge smile on his face. Just imagine a five-year old getting the present he dreamed of for Christmas.

"You still have this?" Toby shockingly said. I don't know why he would be shocked, I mean come on I have been best friends with you since kindergarden and we got that bread stuffed animal in the 6th grade.

"Uh duh. Remember how we were so alike that some people thought we were one person that some split into two?" I laughed at that memory.

"Yeah of course, so eventually my parents gave both of this bread to resemble us being one, at least until Tank and Captain chewed up mine. Then we had to share this one. I was the winking face and you were the happy face." Toby then started to laugh.

"Awww you two are so adorable together. So hurry up and date each other!" I hear Mali sarcastically yell, I rilled my eyes and just kept looking through the box.

"Toby!" Connor yelled. Toby looked up at Connor and then Connor said, "Truth or Dare?"

"Dare I guess," Toby shrugged and then looked back at the photos.

"I dare you to ask Eli out on a date," Connor smirked as Toby and I looked at him with wide eyes.

"Alright fine. Eli will you go out with me?" Toby asked me.

"Yes Toby I will." I giggled a little and then went back to looking at pictures with Toby.

<~><~><~><~><~><~><~>
Sorry it took me so long to update, I got busy.