'Teen Wolf' Imagines

My Best Friend and My Sister - Scott McCall Imagine (Feat. Stiles Stilinski)

Scott stepped out of the building and walked towards the courtyard. From a distance, he saw his little sister and his best friend sitting on a picnic table together. Stiles had made a joke that had Y/N laughing with tears in her eyes. Scott saw Stiles watching his sister and he could tell his best friend was in love with her. Stiles had a genuine smile on his face as he watched Y/N's head roll back while laughing hard.

It didn't surprise Scott. Y/N had always gone to the lacrosse games to support her brother, but Scott knew she was also going to support Stiles. Stiles would tag along with Scott to her volleyball games, because as Stiles said, 'best friends always do everything together', but deep down Scott knew it was an excuse to see Y/N and show her the same support she shows him at his games.

However, lately, the pair have been hanging out more often. They always manage to pair up when anything supernatural related happens. Like her brother, Y/N was a werewolf and was a part of his pack. Although, she knew Stiles could defend himself with his trusty baseball bat, she always felt more at ease with him by her side.

Besides the supernatural stuff and the games, Scott knew they'd been hanging outside of school as well. There have been a couple of times where Stiles has offered to pick up Y/N from her volleyball practices when Scott was stuck at work with Deaton or taking his mom lunch at the hospital. Which sometimes led to grabbing a quick bite at the local diner or grabbing some ice cream on the way home. Scott didn't mind the two of them together, but he was very protective when it came to his sister and her heart. She was his little sister. Even though he loves Stiles like a brother, he wouldn't hesitate to kill him if Stiles broke his baby sister's heart.

The only problem was Scott has been suspicious about the pair for a while and even asked them separately if they liked each other several times before. They both denied it, but Scott knew they were lying. However, today he was going to get to the bottom of it with them.

"What's so funny?" Scott asked when he reached their picnic table and sat down in front of the pair.

"Just a joke Stiles told me," Y/N said wiping the tears from her eyes.

"It was pretty funny," Stiles smiled.

"It was hilarious," Y/N chuckled.

"What's the joke?" Scott asked.

"Why do bananas have to put on sunscreen before they go to the beach?" Stiles asked as Y/N bit her lip from giggling.

"I don't know. Why?" Scott asked.

"Because they might peel!" Stiles answered. As if hearing it for the first time, Y/N bursting into a fit of laughter again before placing her hand on her stomach, trying to gasp for air.

Scott chuckled, thinking how crazy his sister was. He thought the joke was funny but not hysterical like Y/N did. In that moment, Scott believed these two couldn't be more perfect for each other.

"Y/N, do you still like Stiles?"

Y/N's laughter died as her eyes went wide with Scott's blunt question. She wasn't expecting him to ask her that in front of Stiles. She felt her cheeks and the back of her neck heat up as she felt Stiles staring at her with his jaw open, completely shocked Scott revealed she liked him.

"How could you?" She glared angrily at her brother. Her blood was starting to boil and Scott could sense how upset she was because he knew she could never trust him again.

Scott held up his finger to her, signaling her to wait a second before ripping his head off. He looked at his best friend and asked, "Do you still like Y/N?"

"Dude!" Stiles snapped.

"You like me?" Y/N asked Stiles.

Scott tried not to roll his eyes before he spoke. "Yes. He likes you. You like him. I can see how he might not know it, but how do you not notice it with your werewolf senses?"

"I don't know..." she trailed, "I mean I noticed it a couple of times, but I just didn't think he would actually like me that way. I always thought he saw me as a sister like he sees you as a brother."

"Believe me, I do not think of you as a sister," Stiles answered.

"So... then what's the problem? Why don't you two admit and act on your feelings?" Scott asked.

"Honestly?" Y/N asked carefully. Scott nodded before she continued, "I didn't think you would be okay with it."

"What? Why?" Scott asked confused.

"Well, I don't know if we have the same reasons, but for me it's because you're my best friend and she's your little sister. I don't exactly know how you would feel if I dated your sister," Stiles answered. Y/N nodded her head, signaling she had the same reasons.

"I didn't know if you would be okay with it," Y/N added. "Plus, we never really talked about it," she pointed a finger between her and Stiles. "So, it's a lot to take in now that we're laying everything out on the table."

Scott sighed. "I'm sorry if I gave you the impression I wouldn't be okay with you two dating. I know I can be very protective of Y/N, but, Stiles, are you serious about her?"

"Yeah," Stiles looked Scott in the eye and said it with pure honesty. "She's not just some girl to me. I really like her."

Y/N couldn't help but smile big. Although she knew he was terrified being put on the spot and being vulnerable, she knew Stiles meant every word.

"Then I trust you, bro. I know you'll be good to her, but just know," Scott pointed his finger at his best friend with a serious look on his face, "you hurt her, I will hurt you. I love you, bro, I do, but she's my baby sister."

Stiles put his hands up in defense. "I won't hurt her. I don't plan on it."

"Okay then, we good?" Scott asked. Stiles and Y/N nodded with smiles on their faces before they looked at one another and then back at Scott. They all stayed quiet and just looked at each other. "Well? Ask her out already!" Scott said eagerly.

Y/N couldn't help but laugh as Stiles' cheeks turned into a light shade of pink. Stiles scratched the back of his neck before looking back at Y/N. "Would you like to go out Friday night?"

"I'd love to," Y/N smiled at Stiles.

"She'll be ready by 7 but I want you there by 6:50 and not a minute later," Scott butted in. "Because you better believe I'll be hounding you with questions about your intentions with my sister."

"Scott!" Y/N whined but before he or Stiles could say anything else, Lydia and Liam walked up to their table.

"Hey guys," Lydia smiled as she sat next to Scott. "What's up?"

"Stiles just asked Y/N out," Liam said as he sat next to Y/N, proving to everyone he was using his werewolf senses.

"It's about time!" Lydia cheered.

"I know," Liam said as he pulled out his phone. "I was going to give Stiles one more week before I would put a love note in Y/N's locker from Stiles."

"What are you? 12?" Stiles asked Liam. Liam rolled his eyes at Stiles and ignored the question.

"Wait, a minute, you two know?" Y/N asked Lydia and Liam.

"Of course we knew," Lydia said. "We were just waiting on it to finally happen."

"And it's about damn time too," Liam said before everyone chuckled as Y/N and Stiles' cheeks turned pink.

"And you're okay with it?" Lydia asked.

Scott smiled as he looked at Stiles and Y/N. "Why wouldn't I be? It's my best friend and my sister."

At Scott's blessing, Stiles reached in for Y/N's hand and gave it a squeeze, reassuring her everything would be okay. She looked up at Stiles', who gave her a genuine smile. She smiled back, wishing Friday would get there already.