Nightmare x Killer x Cross

1.8K 42 14
                                    

(I'm so bad at getting requests done in a decent amount of time. Requested by @woaterbend )

Killer's POV

Nightmare and Cross started dating a few months ago. I'm happy for them, I really am. They're a good couple, but I have crushes on both of them. I was very confused at first, but I talked to some people and found out that I'm polyamorous. I really want to date both of them but it would be weird.

Cross walks into the room and just sits next to me without a word. "Umm, Cross, what are you doing?" I ask.

"Nightmare and I got into an argument."

"About what?"

"You." What? Did I do something? Am I going to die now? "Don't worry, you didn't do anything"

"Then, why are you-" He cuts me off.

"Nightmare thinks I'm flirting with you." What? Cross has never done anything even remotely flirty towards me.

"Why would he think that?"

"He's just jealous but we never get to hang out anymore. Do you want to go out with me?"

"What? Aren't you dating Nightmare?"

"We agreed to have an open relationship because he's apparently got a crush on someone. So, would you go on a date with me?"

"Umm, ok." Cross then walks off and Nightmare comes over to me a few minutes later. "Hi, Nightmare."

"I'm assuming Cross already told you about our relationship already so I'm just going to ask. Will you go out with me?"

My brain just stop working and all that I was able to get out of my mouth was "Yes."

"Great, I'll see you later." What? Did I just get asked out by both of my crushes, who are dating?! AHHHHHHHHHHHHH

(Time skip: later that night) {This time skip was brought to you by, Killer in a gay panic}

I was in the living room again when both Cross and Nightmare come up to me. "Hi, guys."

"Hey, Kills. You ready to go?" Nightmare turns to Cross.

"What?"

"I asked Killer out and he said yes."

"I asked Killer out."

"Technically, you both asked me out."

"And you said yes to both of us?"

"Yeah"

"Ahh, screw it, let's just be a threesome."

"I'm cool with that"

"Fine by me"

------------------------------------
At least I didn't forget about it too much. See ya, imaginary people

Sanscest One-shots (no lemons) (Requests Closed)Where stories live. Discover now