Prank Night Fall Out

45. Choices

Pairing; Jenna/Elena (F/f) paddle

Ric/Stefan (M/m) hairbrush (mild)

Finn-Elijah-Klaus-Damon/Stefan (MMMM/m) belt

Collaboration with Jazmine Ferguson. Thank you.

Note: Had some issues with this chapter, re-wrote twice due to it getting deleted so it is a bit shorter and some of the conversations are truncated.

Gilbert Residence

Stefan tapped on Elena's window softly. He could see her and Bonnie on the bed talking about something. They didn't look happy, but they didn't look injured or in trouble either. Stefan suddenly felt silly for overacting.

Elena started and then relaxed when she saw her vampire boyfriend beyond the glass.

"Stefan, hey, is everything okay?" Elena hissed in a whisper, opening the window.

Bonnie stood up behind Elena in alarm.

"Yeah, I'm sorry to scare you! I tried calling and there was no answer. You left so suddenly... I was freaking out," Stefan admitted with a shade of embarrassment.

Elena frowned, "I got into it with Damon. I slapped him. I think he was drunk and feeling sorry for himself. I feel bad Stefan. You know, everything with your mom has messed him up."

Stefan nodded, "I know. Hi, Bonnie. What are you guys doing up this late?" Stefan looked at Bonnie and still wondered what they had been talking about.

Bonnie kept her voice low, "Elena got in a big fight with Jenna and got her phone taken away."

"Oh, is that why you didn't answer the phone. I feel foolish" Stefan asked. Jenna and Elena had rarely to never fought. "What was the fight about?"

"I was supposed to set the table and let her know where I was....," Elena confessed. "And I got a speeding ticket on the way home."

"Ric was about to bust out the trusty family paddle, but Elena begged for another chance. Hey, I'm going to bed. You kids have fun," Bonnie smirked. "Don't do anything I wouldn't do."

Stefan said, "Hey Bonnie, thanks again for helping my mom and all that. Kol wanted to ask if you knew any like anti-pain spells or a dark object for him. He's getting it on Monday again for getting in trouble in school. He said he'd trade you his blood or he'd steal some of Klaus'."

"An anti-pain spell? If there is such a thing, we'd use it on ourselves. Doesn't exist, my friend. And if I needed vampire blood, I would just ask you," Bonnie pointed out. "Tell Kol to behave himself and get his ass to class on time like the rest of us."

"True. Well, I told him I would ask," Stefan finished. He shut the door after Bonnie and locked it. Elena took off her pajama tank and hopped on her bed and beckoned Stefan.

"Hurry up," Elena begged.

Stefan smiled, "I should get back home. I lied to Elijah and told him I was going back up to bed...If I get caught, I'm not going to sit for a week and Kol won't be the only one facing an angry Mikaelson."

"Then, I'll kiss it and make it all better," Elena promised. She took off her sleep shorts and tossed them at Stefan.

"Stop. You are making it hard to resist you....," Stefan gasped. He let her tiny sleep short fall to the floor. She knew what those did to him. He took a step toward the bed.

Elena teased Stefan, "I'm wearing those red lace panties you like so much with the see through butt. But you have to come under the covers to see them..." She tossed the covers over her head and Stefan took the bait and joined her under the bedsheet. They frolicked for a few minutes and were just about to get a little more intimate when the door to the bathroom flung open.