Prank Night Fall Out

46. First Time

Pairing: Elijah/Hayley (M/F) hand coal shuttle

Mikaelson Estate

That Night

"You want me to spank you with that?" Elijah gasped incredulously.

Hayley bit her lip and looked intently at the attractive dark-haired vampire that she had come to love.

"Yes, Elijah. I'm a wolf. You know I heal fast, maybe not as fast as you, but decently," Hayley started.

"But dear, that is a coal shovel! Where did you even find that?" Elijah asked taking it out of her long fingers carefully.

"It was in a box in the basement with some other old stuff. Look, Elijah. can we just get this over with please?" Hayley snapped in exasperation. "I want to be punished and then...forgiven."

She was a little embarrassed at the way he was looking at her.

"I'm sorry. I can't strike you with this," Elijah admitted. He smiled at the sassy werewolf's bravado.

Hayley growled, "You are the noble brother. Now, keep your word and do it. Where do you want me?"

Elijah's eyes widened to see that she was serious. He stiffly sat on her bed and opened his mouth, and then paused.
"Okay, if you insist, but I'm going to spank you just like I would punish one of my younger siblings. Unfortunately, I've had plenty of experience," Elijah informed her.

"Fine. I can take it. I know the coal thingy seems like a weird choice but the belt reminds me of Jude and so does the wooden spoon. This is at least new," Hayley muttered.

Elijah swallowed and put the small coal shovel on the bed. He pulled her over his lap so Hayley's upper body rested on her bed and her feet were on the floor.

"Once I start, it will be too late to back out. I will spank you until I think you have learned your lesson," Elijah stated.

"I know. I knew I should have called you....I don't know why I didn't honestly," Hayley confessed as she chewed her bottom lip. She had folded her arms under her head and braced herself for the brutal onslaught of cracks. Instead she felt Elijah's hand resting on her behind, then patting it.

"I would like to know why you defied me and wouldn't open the door when I asked. I did just want to speak to you. I know you feel badly," Elijah said softly as he tapped her jeans covered rear with his hand. Tap. tap. tap. tap.

"I'm not good at obeying. Sometimes I do stupid shit just because I can. I just I don't know why," Hayley said quickly. She wished her jeans weren't so tight. Was he staring at her behind? Hayley's face flushed red and she was relieved Elijah couldn't see it.

"Relax, a little. Are you ready?" Elijah asked gently.

Hayley turned to try to look at him, "Jesus Christ, could you do it already?"

Elijah cracked a smiled and said, "If the lady insists." He lifted his hand and brought it down on her left butt cheek with a crack. He swatted down five more times in the same spot.

Whack. Whack. Whack. Whack. Whack Whack.

Hayley gasped as the Original was not holding back. The area smarted even through her pants and underwear. Elijah switched to the left side and pepper it too with six loud smacks.

Whack. Whack. Whack. Whack. Whack Whack.

Elijah then targeted the area a bit lower and popped her another six times in the same fashion.

Whack. Whack. Whack. Whack. Whack Whack.

Whack. Whack. Whack. Whack. Whack Whack.

Hayley's eyes widened and she tried to stop the 'ahs' and 'owws' from escaping with no success. The last spanks left her kicking up her legs and wiggling more than she had expected to.