HER SISTER (18+) (GXG)

Ball Drops & Secrets

"Before you say anything, take a closer look at the picture," Mya said.

And I found myself looking even deeper into the picture, mostly because I didn't want to turn around and face her, but also because disobeying her wishes seemed like the last thing I should do right now.

However, upon looking at it deeper, I realized that my tattoo was showing.

"You see the tattoo?" Mya questioned rhetorically, "You know, the ones we got together?" she suddenly said, clearly addressing me.

I suddenly turned around speechlessly, "Mya I—"

"How long?" Mya questioned as Mili turned back around as well.

I pursed my lips into a straight line, hating how this response was about to sound.

Mya hummed sharply to herself, "It's been that long?" she said, and I couldn't miss the brokenness in her tone.

It made me want to cry until I physically couldn't anymore.

"It wasn't set up to be a lie Mya—I swear I didn't know she was your sister when we kissed at that bar," I said, trying my best to explain how it all led to this.

"What bar?" Mya questioned.

And I couldn't help but briefly look over to Mili, knowing that this was about to sound so fucking bad.

"That uh... bar across from Ollie's," I forced out.

Mya's brows raised in disbelief, "You kissed her at that bar? The night that we all met there?" she asked, clearly taken aback by the new information.

I reluctantly nodded, "Yeah, but it was before you introduced us—"

"Let me get this straight," Mya suddenly cut me short before she said, "You kissed my sister and then sat down with me at that bar and pretended to have never met her?"

I blinked a few times, "Yeah... sort of?" I whispered, feeling like I could one hundred percent pass out right now, "But it wasn't like that, I really didn't know her name and I didn't plan to ever kiss her again—"

"But now you're fucking her so how does that even make sense?" Mya suddenly cut me short yet again.

And almost as if on queue, Mili straightened her posture, "Watch it now," she suddenly warned her sister, clearly not happy with her choice of words.

Mya suddenly looked over to Mili, "Watch what? The fact that you both have lied to me for months straight?" she questioned, clearly upset by all of this.

I only took a step toward her, "I'm sorry we—"

"We? Oh, so you guys are a we now?" Mya questioned, suddenly amused by this entire situation.

Mili let out an irritated sigh, "Mya don't even take it there right now."

Mya only shook her head, "Take it where? I mean, this is all just so surprising to me—is she actually more than just someone to fuck, Milan?" she said, and I could tell by the use of her full name that this was getting even more serious by the second.

Mili narrowed her eyes at Mya, "Of course she's more than that," she didn't hesitate to say.

Mya only hummed, clearly not amused by her answer, "And what happened to Cam? You made it seem like you were so interested in her," she sarcastically said, suddenly looking over to me.

I shook my head, "I wanted her to be the right choice for you. I didn't want to complicate any of this, but I just... it's only ever going to be Mili, Mya. I'm so sorry for—"