The Phantomhive Cafe (Sebastian Michaelis x GN!reader)

The Truth Revealed

"I- you what?!" You exclaimed, staring at him in shock.

"I'm sure you heard me the first time, (Name)." he placed a hand on your shoulder and leaned down to your ear, "I'm a demon."

You said nothing for the longest time. Then you pointed at him, "I knew it!"

Sebastian seemed a bit surprised before smirking, "Yes, you are much more perceptive than I originally thought."

You furrowed your brows, "Should I take that as I compliment or...?"

Sebastian chuckled, "Take it however you'd like." He tilted his head, his eyes narrowing a bit, "I feel the need to ask how you found out."

"Well, you weren't exactly doing the best at hiding it." You said, crossing your arms.

Sebastian raised a brow, "Elaborate."

"First of all, that whole 'one hell of a butler' catchphrase." You said matter-of-factly. "I mean, really? Your catchphrase is a fucking pun?" Before Sebastian could speak, you continued, "Second, the damn Demon Hound in our backyard. You're the only one he listens to. Also, you keep showing off things that are pretty impossible for humans to do." You point at him, "Not to mention your eyes are fucking red, dude. And I swear I've seen them glow before, which I thought was just creepy as hell, by the way."

Sebastian stared down at you, clearly a bit surprised by your rant. You had just basically read him to filth, but you didn't expect it to actually startle him. Suddenly he broke down into laughter, covering his mouth. He leaned back on the counter while you stared dumbfounded. It was odd seeing the calm and collected man laughing. You've seen him smile before, but none of them ever seemed genuine. They were never joyful smiles, more like little sinister grins.

Finally he stopped with a sigh, "I must say, that was quite the read you had on me." He smiled down at you, "You really are quite perceptive, hm?"

You shrugged, "That or you suck at keeping secrets."

"I suppose I might be." The tall man said with a grin, "But now I have to wonder..." He leaned down towards you, his eyes glinting, "What should I do with you now that you know?"

You looked a bit startled, but managed to keep your composure, "Well killing me would be stupid." You said with a deadpan expression, which made Sebastian pause.

"You're correct." He said, leaning back and curling a finger around his chin to think, "Well then, it seems I've found myself a bit stumped."

You furrowed your brows, "Honestly?" You said, looking up at him. "I don't think I expected those words to ever come from your mouth."

"Am I not allowed to be confused?" He asked with a teasing grin.

"I mean, you're incredible at pretty much everything you do, so..."

"Awe, how kind!" He leaned down towards you with a flattered smile.

You rolled your eyes, "Don't start."

●●●●

"So, they figured it out." Ciel stated, resting his chin on his palm as he looked between you and Sebastian.

"Unfortunately, yes." Sebastian sighed, a small smile gracing his lips. He was obviously a bit entertained by the whole ordeal, if a bit impressed. "It seems our newest employee here is quite perceptive."

Ciel sighed, standing up, "Yes, it seems they are." He narrowed his eyes at you, "Mx. (Name), you are aware of how... inconvenient this is to Sebastian and I?"

You rubbed your neck, "I... guess that means I'm fired?"

Ciel hummed, crossing his arms, "Well yes, I suppose I could fire you... but you do know a bit too much."

And then... holy shit, he smiled. You couldn't help but tense a bit. You had only seen him smile once before, but this time it was kinda scary.

"What... do you mean?" You asked, sounding a bit more worried than you had wanted to.

Ciel seemed a bit amused, "Well calm down, we're not going to kill you." He said matter-of-factly. "I'm simply going to make you go run erands with Sebastian."

You furrowed your brows. That sounded way more tame than you expected. "Oh like... getting groceries and stuff?"

Ciel smirked, "Sure." He said simply before sitting back down at his desk, "Now, from now on, you're not longer just a waiter. You're going to be Sebastian's little helper."

●●●●

Notes:

Sorry for not posting for a bit, my mom is actually my dog. Anywaaays, hope you all enjoy the new chapter! I've been pretty busy so updates might slow down.