The Girl Next Door || Olivia Rodrigo

tease

Olivia's pov (June 1st, 2018)

I was getting ready for my date with Madison tonight when I glanced outside my bedroom window and saw Madison in her front yard, tossing a football with her brother. I watched as she threw the ball, doing a perfect spiral. 

She's been starting to practice a lot more because she has tryouts in the beginning of August. She never lets me watch her though because she thinks she is bad. She's not.

I watched her for around ten minutes before she said something to Liam and then went inside.

Madison and I were walking down the street to the ice cream place after we finished up dinner, our fingers laced together. I started to lightly swing our conjoined hands back and forth as we walked and talked.

"So, I saw you playing football in the front yard today." I told her.

"You were stalking me?" Madison teased.

"Maybe. But only because you told me I couldn't watch you play and I wanted to watch you. You're really good." I told her.

Madison gave me a small shrug.

"You are." I said. "I think you'll make the team. Just think of all the stuff we could do together. Celebrate wins, make out under the bleachers during halftime, make out in the locker room before and after the game."

"Is all you want to do make out?" Madi chuckled. "Cause I don't have to be on the football team for that."

I smiled. "It's not all I want to do. Just a plus side."

Madison playfully rolled her eyes at me. "Whatever you say, Liv.

Madison noticed a man walking towards on the sidewalk, specifically in front of me. She let go of my hand and moved me to the other side of her, away from the street and the man, before she wrapped her arm tightly around my waist.

"Why'd you do that?" I asked her after the man walked passed us.

"To protect you. I wasn't sure if he was gonna try something or not. He looked a little sketchy and I didn't want him touching you." Madison replied.

"Oh, thank you but you don't have to protect me. I'm sure he wasn't gonna try anything though." I said.

"You never know. I said it once before and I'll  say it again, if anyone hurts you I'm going to prison for life." Madison told me, keeping her eyes in front of her.

I bit my lip as I looked at her. I know I can protect myself but when she does it for me, it's hot as hell.

"I think I'd even send you love letters in jail." I replied causing her to look at me and give me a small smile. "Hey, can we go into that CVS? I need to get some more deodorant."

"Sure."

Madison's pov

I walked over to the section where they sold the condoms while Liv went over to the deodorant. Liv and I aren't having sex yet but we've been dating for almost 6 months so it's bound to happen soon and when it does, I want to be prepared.

I looked at the different sizes, picking up the large ones. I flipped the box over reading the back of it. 6.5 to 8 inches. I nodded to myself before going to pay. I used the self check out because I didn't feel like being judged.

After Liv and I both got our items, we went to get ice cream and then went back to my house. I secretly hid the box of condoms in my bedside table since Olivia didn't know I bought them.

"So, I have a question." I told Olivia as I sat down on my bed.

"I maybe have an answer." Olivia said as she laid down on her stomach next to me on my bed.

"Are you a virgin?" I asked.

"I am." She told me. "Why?"

"I just wanted to know if you and Louis ever did it. I wanted to know if I have to compete with him when we have our first time." I said.

"Oh. Well, we never did it so you don't have to worry about that. You'll be my first time." Olivia assured me. "I've actually never had an orgasm."

I raised my eyebrows. "You haven't? You've never, like, fingered yourself when you're alone?"

"Nope."

"Why not?"

Olivia shrugged. "I don't know. I want the first time I experience a real orgasm to be with the person I love the most. You."

"I'm honoured." I told her.

"Have you jerked off?" Liv wondered.

"Of course I have" I said.

"Really? Did it feel good?" Olivia asked.

"Yeah, it felt really good." I nodded.

"When was the last time you did it?" She asked.

"You're full of questions aren't you?" I chuckled.

"Just answer it." She ordered.

"Alright, jeez. I did it this morning." I admitted.

Liv smirked at me. "Were you thinking of me?"

"Who else I would I be thinking of?" I asked.

"I don't know." Liv trailed her finger up and down my thigh. "So you want to have sex with me?"

"I mean, yeah." I told her as I watched her finger get closer to my crotch. "But... When you're ready for it, I'll be ready for it. I don't want to rush you into things."

"Hm. Good to know." She said.

I tried to control myself and not let myself get too turned on by her at the moment but the second she started tracing light circles over my already semi-hard bulge, it was game over.

"Anyways, I better get going. Finals start tomorrow and we've got a big test in Math." Olivia told me.

She winked at me before she stood up from my bed, swaying her hips as she walked to my bedroom door. I looked down at her ass. Fucking tease.