A/n - As promised, here's the next part!
Trender had finally finished your makeup and hair. He sat back and admired his work.
" Man I am good. " He breathed out happily. " You look even prettier than usual! And that's pretty hard to beat! " He threw his arms in the air and lay down on your bed. Trender had always been rather childish when he was just with you. You and him had been really close before you left. Well, to be honest, you had been pretty close to all of the CreepyPastas before you left. He had curled your hair in a way that made it bounce on your shoulders every time you moved. He had put on you a bit of a lightish red lipstick, adding some lip gloss to make them shine, some eyeliner, mascara and silver eyeshadow. You looked in the mirror and smiled a little. You actually looked nice. Not that you didn't before but nice so that even you noticed it. You heard him get off your bed, but you weren't really bothered with where he could be going. You were just astounded that Trender was so could that he could actually do your hair and makeup so well! Suddenly you were turned around and pushed back on the chair. You looked down shocked and confused to be met with Trender looking up at you from his kneeling position. ( Man he better not be proposing. ) You looked at him worried to which he only smiled before picking up a pair of elegant, small black heels. You looked at them confused, which seemed to be the only thing you ever did, as he lift your foot and slipped the shoe onto your right foot.
" It fits perfectly.. " He mumbled. He looked up and you both looked at each other before his faceless face crumpled into what resembled a frown. You frowned yourself and cocked your head to the side in question.
" I hope you don't think this means I'm your prince because that is not what I was going for. " You couldn't hold your laughter in at that and burst out laughing. He looked at you, seemingly confused, before shaking his head and getting up.
" People are waiting for you downstairs. You're ready. Let's go. " He looked at you and nodded happily. You bit your lip worriedly and looked at him, pleading with your eyes.
" Come on Trender! I'm sure there's something you missed out! " You were pleading and begging for him to not make you go when he grabbed you, threw you over his shoulder and walked out of the room with you. You started punching his back, not too hard, but hard enough.
" I swear, if you don't put me down, I will end our friendship right here. " He simply ignored you and soon enough he was walking down the stairs. He took you off from his shoulder and held you in front of him.
" Now (Y/n), you have a choice. Either you go in there by yourself, have a good time and talk to people, or I bring you in there, on my shoulder and throw you onto someone. " He finished and looked at you. You bit your lip and grinned slightly.
" You sure there isn't a third option? " He seemingly glared at you, or would have if he had a face, before putting you down and pushing you into the large living room where the party was being held. All eyes turned to look at you as you tripped up and caught yourself on the wall. You looked around with an awkward smile before waving a little.
" Uh, hi. " You managed out. BEN soon found his way over to you and smiled.
" Hey (Y/n)! " He practically screamed in your face. You raised your eyebrows a little.
" You know 11 year olds aren't supposed to drink alcohol? " You asked, grinning at him. He frowned.
" See? This is why it sucks dying when you're 11. You can't do anything. " He mumbled, pouting. You giggled slightly and put your hand on his shoulder in comfort.
" Come on, let's go play video games. " You smiled as his pout turned into an excited smile.
" Okay but I must warn you, I am good. " He grabbed your hand and made his way through the crowd, to the enormous tv they somehow had.
You managed to finish one race, where you had come second and him first, when someone interrupted your game.
" Can I join you both? " The voice asked, making you turn around to see who it was. You saw a guy wearing a white, feminine mask standing at the end of the couch. ( His name was... Masky, right? ) BEN nodded and handed the guy an extra remote before he sat on your left side. Now you were in between BEN and Masky. Masky picked Dry Bones, BEN picked Mario, for some unknown reason and you picked your usual, Toad. BEN groaned next to you.
" Really (Y/n)? Toad? Again? " He asked, shaking his head in shame. You pouted still looking at the tv before answering.
" But look at how cute he is! He's a little mushroom with arms and feet! " You exclaimed, throwing your arms in the air. BEN rolled his eyes before picking the road. He picked rainbow road and you groaned. BEN smirked next to you before looking at you innocently.
" What's wrong (Y/n)? " His smirk got wider as you glared at him.
" Nothing. Let's continue. " You cast him one last glare before returning your eyes to the screen as the race commenced.
As you crossed the finish line you smiled slightly, having not come last. You had come into 4th with Masky in 3rd. ( Damn it. Well at least BEN didn't come first either. ) You smirked and turned to look at BEN who was squished into the couch with a frown/pout on his face.
" What's wrong BEN? " You asked innocently. He glared at you and his pout got deeper.
" You guys cheated. " He muttered. Masky chuckled next to you and you grinned at him.
" Hey! We only pushed you off the edge once. You're the one that fell off the other three times. " Masky commented, causing you to laugh. Masky got up off the couch and turned to look at you and BEN.
" Well I've got to go eat some cheese cake. I'll catch you some other time (Y/n). " He nodded in your direction before leaving. You turned to look at BEN who was busy looking at someone else. You frowned slightly, before looking past to see who he was looking at so intently. Jeff was leaning against a wall on the far side of the room glaring at you. BEN smirked and turned to look at you.
" Who has succeeded into making Jeffy Weffy mad? " He smirked at his own brilliant, or so he thought, nickname for Jeff. One side of your mouth turned up in amusement at BEN before you shrugged.
" Don't know. I want punch.... " You mumbled the last part and quickly BEN got off the couch and smiled at you.
" I'll get you some. But only because you're the guest of honour. Otherwise you'd have nothing. " He walked off as you giggled. You felt the couch go down next to you, making you turn to look at the person.
" Hey (Y/n). " Jane waved a little with her free hand, the other being occupied by a knife. You looked at the knife a little, confused as to why she had it in her hand inside the mansion. ( Meh. Must be a killer thing. )
" Hi " You answered back smiling. BEN brought you your punch before getting engrossed back into his games. You smiled at the little guy. (Why do I call him little? He's taller than me.. ) You frowned at your thoughts as you took a sip of your drink.
" So... What's up with you and Jeff Huh? " She brought him up so quickly you didn't fully comprehend what she said until she tapped your shoulder with her knife.
" Hey. You okay? " She asked. You shook your head slightly to yourself before looking up from your lap and smiling.
" Yeah sorry. Didn't understand. Anyway, so me and Jeff Huh? " You asked her, wanting to make sure you had heard her correctly.
" Yeah. He's been looking at you all evening. Are you guys together again? " You choked on your punch and looked at her.
" One : We've never been together. Two : I'm pretty sure he hates me right now. And Three : No he hasn't. " You looked over at Jeff to prove your point, but only succeeded into proving Janes point as he was looking at you. She smirked at you and you pulled a bitch face. " That doesn't mean anything. " You finished. She shook her head at your stubbornness.
" Anyway, what I came here to ask, well was forced to ask by Jeff, was are you and Trender a thing? " She finished and waited for your answer. You looked at her, shocked and eyes wide.
" Do you think I'm going out with everyone or something? " You managed to ask, trying to calm yourself. ( Why the hell would Jeff think that? ) She just looked at you waiting for the answer to her- Jeffs question. You rolled your eyes and sighed exasperatedly. " No we're not. Why would he think that? " You asked, your tone a little angrier than you had meant for it to be.
" Woah calm down (Y/n), don't kill the messenger. " She grinned under her mask before answering your question. " He said he walked into you too about to kiss or something? Him holding your chin and you looking into each others eyes? " She finished, her words laced with confusion. You looked at her for a moment before your mouth slowly turned into a little smile and before you knew it, you were laughing and practically dying on the couch. Jane moved away from you a little, probably afraid that you'd hit her during your laughing fit. You wiped a tear from your eye before coughing and giggling a little. You looked towards Jeff because, well you kinda wanted to, to find him looking at you confused and shaking his head slightly. You turned around awkwardly before smiling at Jane.
" Sorry 'bout that. " You mumbled out, tucking some hair behind your ear. " Right anyway, we weren't about to kiss. He was comforting me and we just happened to look up at the same time. Good times really. " You chuckled a little and shook your head. ( I can't believe Jeff thought that I was dating Trender. Haha never gonna let that die. ) You proceeded in breathing in and out to make sure you wouldn't lose it again. Jane laughed a little before getting up.
" Well that's something Jeffs going to be happy to hear. " She smiled at you and you cocked your head to the side and looked up at her in confusion.
" What? " You asked. She stopped moving and just looked at you.
" Uh... Nothing? I don't remember saying anything. Um.. I have to go. Bye talk to you later! " She practically shouted the last bit before walking away quickly.
( What on earth could she mean by that? )A/n - What did Jane mean? Well you'll find out in the next chapter! Hope you have as much fun reading it as I had writing it. Sorry for the longer chapter. Hope you don't mind its length! As usual comment any feedback and vote if you have time and liked this part. Have a good day/night!
~ Abyss
Twitter: SuperNaturalAbyss @SPNAbyss

YOU ARE READING
Jeff The Killer X Reader - I'll love you for all eternity
Fanfiction(Y/n) is what people qualify as an average teenager. Going to school, meeting friends and hanging out with her boyfriend. But what makes (Y/n) different is her past. She hasn't told anyone, and everything that happened in the first 13 years of her l...