Theo had tried. He tried really hard to not fall for her. The girl with the charismatic smile, the contagious laugh, the beautiful soul, piercing eyes, straight A's, and a heat of gold, a girl who seemed to have everything he ever wanted. He didn't come here to fall in love. That wasn't apart of the plan. But he couldn't help himself.
After he had fell for her he did his best to avoid her not wanting to get her involved in the screwed up mess of his life. He didn't make it far avoiding her because there was like a gravitational pull between the two. The feelings were mutual. Theo couldn't give that up because it something he wanted. Something he craved. Something he knew he didn't deserve but took the chance.
When he finally had the guts to ask her out and she said yes he figured that he could just keep her a secret from the doctors. That since she wasn't apart of the pact that it wouldn't matter. And he was right, for about four months he had kept her a secret. They had went on countless dates, they had movie night Fridays that specializes in cuddling, they had study dates, where one went you would usually get the other. They were stuck like glue. Everyone agreed that they were the cutest couple in school, always doing cute romantic things together not caring where they were.
They were what everyone wanted until one night, the doctors had found out. They had threatened Theo that if he didn't stay away from her they would kill the girl. That was his worst nightmare. He made his way to her house already in tears. This is the first time Theo had cried in years.
"Theo? Babe what's wrong?" y/n asked when she opened the door.
y/n had previously known about the supernatural world seeing as her cousins were born werewolves, but even so Theo had kept her up to date with everything crawling in the night down Beacon Hills streets.
"I-I-I'm sorry." he shook his head and sniffled, a lot.
"Come here." she pulled him into a bone crushing hug and he held on tight. After a minutes in that position she pulled back and led him inside. They ended up on her bed with her rubbing his back as he continued to have quick unsteady breaths trying to calm down.
"Theo, you can tell me what happened." he looked over at her and shook his head again.
"I am so sorry." his breaths making the words sound like he was hiccuping.
"Can you tell me what your sorry for?" she asked softly.
"They they told me t-that I had to-to stay away from you, or-or else..." he trialed off crying harder.
"Or else what baby?"
"They-they would k-k-kill you." He cried into her shoulder as she held him.
"I am so sorry." he mumbled into her shoulder. She shushed him calmingly.
"Hey, it's okay."
"No it's not. y/n I have to break up with you." he sniffled multiple times.
"Hey it's going to be okay. I promise. One day when all of this is over you can come back to me okay?" he nodded as she ran her hands through his disheveled hair.
"I love you so much." his breath hitched.
"I love you too Theo." she kissed his forehead since he was leaning on her.
"I don't know what I'm going to do with out you." he started wiping his tears.
"You are going to do whatever you have to do then if you still love me you can come back, I'll wait."
"You will?" he asked shocked.
"Of course I will Theo, what we have is special and I'm not giving it up that easily. Besides you make the happiest I've been in my entire life. No one else would ever come close to that." she said and for the first time that night he smiled.
"You're really perfect, you know that?"
"No I'm not Theo." she giggled.
"You're perfect for me." he said truly meaning it.
After about another hour of talking Theo finally left. Giving her one last kiss for now. He walked out of her house feeling nothing but sorrow but the moment he entered his house it had all turned to rage. He had broken practically broken everything in his room before collapsing and crying himself to sleep.
