Supernatural Preferences & Imagines

Human!Castiel Imagine

It's peanut butter jelly time!

"I'm on the high way to hell," you rocked your head to the beat and also said it. "Dun dun dun, highway to hell!" You waved your silver knife in the air, peanut butter on it. "Mmmm, and I know you're gonna be there too,"

Cas walked in then, rubbing sleep from his eyes. He took a two hour nap, since he chose to not get much sleep the other night due to being in shock of not being an angel anymore. "Hey, Cassie!" You grinned at him in your tank top and pajama shorts. You and Cas were living together, since you lived separate from the Winchesters and Dean kicked Cas out. You were still pissed at him for that so you ignored them both for the time being. "My mouth taste funny," Cas complained as he spoke loudly over the music. With a quick swipe of your hand, you turned the music down low.

"Did you brush your teeth?" It was currently 9 at night and Cas shook his head before heading off to the bathroom to do so. "Blue toothbrush—remember that!" "They both look blue, I don't see the difference." You dropped the knife and ran out of the kitchen, hollering. You were not about to let Cas use your toothbrush. "Yes there is! You have the blue one—that one is mine, put it in you mouth and your dead!"

"But...this is blue..."

"That is indigo, this is the blue."

"But...both are blue...and I used this last time."

"You colorblind motherfucker."

_

Back after the Great Toothbrush Fiasco, you looked up at Cas. He was seated on the bar stool across from you. "What's the matter?" He jerked his head up, his eyebrows furrowed. "Did I do something wrong?" You stopped, frozen in place. "Why would you think that?" You asked softly, wanting nothing more than to hug him and tell him he did nothing wrong.

That sad look pained you.

"Dean didn't want me anymore, did I do something wrong?" Scratch that, you wanted nothing more than to hug and comfort him while kicking Dean's ass straight back to hell.

"No," you put back down the knife, going over to him and giving him a hug. "Cas, you didn't do anything wrong. Dean just needed some space, you know?" The ex-angel nodded numbly, and you felt him shake. "[Y/N], what's wrong with me?" "Nothing! Cas, you are perfect just the way you are without anybody telling you that you aren't—" "No, my face."

You pulled away from him and let out a giggle but that quickly turned into a sad smile.

He didn't know why his face was wet. Cas didn't know why he was crying.

Cas wiped at his face and sniffled. "It hurts," he murmured after a minute if you cradling him, giving him the best hug you ever gave. "It'll get better, everything gets better." You sniffled this time, closing your eyes. "[Y/N]?" "Hmm?" "Thank you, for being here for me." "No problem, Cassie. Just call me and I'll be there for you."

The sandwich, that you finally managed to finish making, was delicious. Cas watched, interested. "Is that good?" You nodded and smiled at him before turning the food towards him. "Try it." He stared at it hesitantly before taking a bite. His eyes lit up and you giggled at him. Only around Cas, you trusted him more than anything.

"Where can I get one?!" He jumped down from the bar stool, grinning. You remembered the faint music playing from your phone in the background and you smiled. "Why, right here in this kitchen!" You got out some more bread and talked with Cas about anything while you made the sandwich.

Awhile later, you and Cas were on the couch, full from the sandwiches. "One more!" Cas begged and you shook your head. "No more! We ate, like, twenty of them!" You and Cas laughed and you turned on the tv before tossing him a wii remote.

"What is this?" "Wii, and I'm going to beat you, newbie." "How does one play the Wii?" "With the controller, now let's play!" You shouted as the game loaded and you clicked to go on.

It must've been Cas' lucky day, for he won all of the rounds.

__

Heyo! Sorry for the waittt :( also, I've been OBSESSED with a new show, which I don't know if any of you know of but I'll give you a hint:

Kaneki.

;) also, this chapter was suppose to be all sad and depressing but I didn't make it like that :) I decided to make a happy—but still adding in the sad—imagine!

Ps: I wrote this in like 10 minutes. Heh heh, yeah...