Mario Characters X Reader One Shots

Rivals and Romance Luigi X Shy Reader X Waluigi

Disclaimer: I don't own anything except the story idea!!

Author's Note: This request is for NinTenDo WeiRdo who wanted a love triangle story. Don't worry the reader will end up with someone in the end while the other one will fall in love with someone else. Of course this will be a romance story and takes place in a Alternate Universe where the Mario Characters are in High School. Please enjoy and I hope I fulfill the requesters requirements. Thoughts Italics

~Third Person Point of View~

As we see many students enter the cafeteria a lone (Hair Color)ed young woman is eating her lunch on a table far away from the crowds. Why you ask? She's shy and not much of a social butterfly especially around the opposite gender aka boys. Despite her shyness (Your Name) is a average student getting C's and B's in her report cards, not to mention great in agriculture and Cooking Class [If not just pretend]. While the (Eye Color)ed woman continued to eat she was unaware that two pairs of eyes are watching her dreamily. 

~Luigi's Point of View~

I let out a small  dreamy sigh as I continued to stare at (Your Name). A beautiful, kind and quiet young woman despite her shy personality I'm falling in love with her. I have her in some of my classes like English, Science and my favorite Cooking class. The first time we partnered up for a project in Science I got to know her a little bit and we became friends. Though I wanted to tell her my feelings there's one person or should I say rival that stands in my way, his name Waluigi. I then looked a few feet away from me to see the purple wearing 'Plumber' also staring at (Your Name) dreamily. 

~Waluigi's Point of View~

Oh (Your Name) I love you very much!! I thought as I let out another dreamy sigh. I have her in Agriculture, Math and Social Studies. [Your schedule is English, Agriculture, Recess, Science, Math, Lunch, Cooking Class, then finally Social Studies]. We would often work together in Agriculture and Social Studies, taking care of plants and working together in projects respectively. As the school year progresses we slowly became friends but as usual there's someone preventing me from confessing my feelings to (Your Name) The Green Bean (Luigi). I then sense that someone is watching me, I looked around to see Green Bean glaring at me with his stupid big blue eyes filled with anger. 

~Third Person Point of View~

While Luigi and Waluigi continue to glare at each other (Your Name) threw away her empty plate into the trash can and left the cafeteria. The two men got up to confront each other never letting the other out of their sight while Mario and Wario carefully watched their younger brothers. After a few minutes of silence and glaring Waluigi spoke first "Why are you staring at my girl Green Bean!?!".  "Your girl? Why would she love you? I'm perfect for (Your Name)!!" Luigi responded. "Perfect? You? You're nothing but a coward!! She needs a brave and handsome guy like me!!" Waluigi said as he grinned. "I'm brave, handsome, and I know how to treat a woman!!" Luigi retorted but was shoved harshly by Waluigi. They both continued to argue and shove each other but before they could trade blows Mario and Wario broke up the conflict. Waluigi was struggling trying to escape his brother's grip, but as he was being dragged away he proposed a challenge to the green capped plumber. "We have one month to impress and flirt with (Your Name) at the end of the month we'll let her choose which one of us will be her boyfriend. Do you accept Green Bean?" Waluigi smirked with confidence thinking he'll win. Luigi also smirked and responded "I accept."

~Third Person Point of View~ During The Month Challenge

We see Luigi put his love letter in (Your Name)'s locker then leave with a blush on his face. A few minutes later Waluigi also inserts a love letter in her locker and walks away. (Your Name) opened her locker and finds two letters and reads both of them which leads her to blush and put them away. During lunch Waluigi and Luigi joined (Your Name) by sitting at her left and right side. They started complimenting, talking, flirting, giving animal plushies, and giving her some chocolates while sometimes glaring at the other. As the days go by (Your Name) recieved so many flowers, candies, love letters, and compliments from Luigi and waluigi. Each of these gifts and sweet words left her a blushing mess making her red as a tomato and very shy. [Don't worry Mario told you about the challenge]

~Your Point of View~ The Day Before The Last Day

I lay down on my bed in my room surrounded by plushies, bouquets of (Favorite Flower)s, many love letters, and some small boxes of jewelry. I sighed and started to think about Luigi and Waluigi. I started to think of their pros and cons. Luigi is a kind, sweet, handsome, friendly, and strong but is timid, a bit cowardly, and afraid of many things I thought. Then I listed the pros and cons of Waluigi He's tall, handsome, brave, not afraid to say what's on his mind, and pretty strong but can be a bully, troublemaker, and has a short fuse I thought. I continued to think and made my decision but then I thought of something. No matter what my decision  his heart will be broken. I hope that we can still be friends. I thought and became depressed as I tried to fall asleep.

~Third Person Point of View~ The Next Day After School

Luigi and Waluigi are waiting for (Your name) by the big oak tree very anxious and nervous. She then arrived and stood in front of them while carefully staring at her friends. She took a deep breath and started to speak to each of them thanking for the gifts, compliments, and love they showered her. (Your Name) looked at the green clad wearing man "Luigi you're a wonderful guy who showed me kindness and makes me smile." Luigi blushed and smiled from her sweet words. She then looked at the purple capped male "Waluigi you're a very unique guy who showed me determination and bravery with your personality which I admired." Waluigi grinned and winked at (Your Name). "Now is the hard part." Spoke (Your Name) she took a few deep breaths and said "Can you promise me that no matter what my decision is will we still be friends?" Luigi and Waluigi looked at each other then at her "We promise." They both declared knowing that (Your Name)'s happiness and well being is more important. 

~Your Point of View~

I smiled at their answer knowing that they always speak the truth to me. Now the moment of truth has come "The person I choose is.... Waluigi" I revealed to them. Waluigi was very happy while Luigi became very depressed while Waluigi was doing his victory dance I went to Luigi and hugged him as he cried. "Luigi I'm sorry but I love Waluigi, we're still friends right?" I spoke and was responded by his nodding. "Yeah we're still friends" He spoke. I then gave him a kiss on the cheek as he blushed "Don't worry Luigi you'll find someone who'll love you." I told him as I walked to my new boyfriend and kissed him. Luigi smiled and whispered to Waluigi "If you break her heart I'll break every bone in your body." He whispered and got a reply "I won't I promise Green Bean." Waluigi whispered back. 

~Third Person Point of View~ Two Weeks Later

We find ourselves in the Cafeteria watching Waluigi and (Your Name) eating at the same table enjoying their meal. Then Luigi joined the couple with his new girlfriend Daisy [You helped Luigi hook up with her] as they started to talk, chat and continue to eat. Luigi and Waluigi started to slowly become friends and enjoy each others company so no fights but are still rivals when it comes to sports and competitions. In the end friendship can created love and everlasting bonds. 

Author's Note: DONE!!!! Finally!!!! Took me six hours to finish it. Anyway I hope you like this story and sorry if the ending is junk. Please Follow, Favorite, Comment, Vote and Review this story. If you want to request a story please follow the rules and comment. See you next time!!