Cody Christian/Theo Raeken Imagines

"Did you ever really care about me?" -Theo Raeken

I don't know when I knew Theo was lying to me-about everything. All I know is that one day I woke up and something felt different. I went to school and Theo avoided me all day. I would try to talk to him-but he just ignored me. So when I saw Scott in the hallway with him, I walked over. "Hey Scott-what's up?" I asked. "Hey Y/N, nothing much." He said. I smiled and acted like Theo wasn't standing right there. "So how's you and Theo?" Scott asked, looking at Theo. "We're good I guess. He's been acting strange lately-so I can't say for sure." I said, looking at him after glaring at Theo.
"Look I am not the one who did anything wrong here." He finally spoke up. I rolled my eyes and walked away. 'I'll just deal with him later' I thought to my self.
When I went by Theo's after school, I heard voices coming from inside-yelling. I walked in and heard the voices carry on up stairs. "Theo?" I said, closing the door. The yelling continued until I spoke again, "Theo?!" I yelled, a bit more loudly that time. I heard whispering voices then thumping on the stairs. "Babe-what are you doing here?" He asked, standing in front of me. "I came to see if you were okay and to talk to you. Something doesn't feel right between us." I said. "Can we talk later? I'm kinda in the middle of something import-" "Theo, are you coming back or not?" Another females voice spoke. I looked to the top of the stairs to see a girl (I have no idea who she is) in Theo's t-shirt and jean shorts. "So that is why everything felt so wrong.." I said, looking at Theo with tears in my eyes. "Let me explain-" "What is there to explain Theo?! You cheated on me!" I yelled, the girl brushing shoulders with me as she left, without Theo's shirt. "Can we just talk abut tho-" "No Theo! You didn't wanna talk before because you were in the middle of having sex with someone else! You do not get to talk to me about this! I thought something was bothering you and you weren't telling me? I mean-did you ever care about me? Or was I just an opportunity for you to try and gain your way into Scott's pack?" I said, backing away from him. "I do care about you, more than anything!" He yelled. "Obviously not if you're fucking someone else! Fuck you Theo! I'm done! I hope you're happy." I said, and left.
I cried all the way to Scott's house. When he opened the door, he immediately hugged me. "Y/N, what happened?" He asked, taking me inside. "I caught Theo cheating on me. I went into the house cause I wanted to talk to him about me and him because something hasn't felt right for the last week or so. So when I went in, he came down stairs and said that we couldn't talk at the moment because he was in the middle of something important and then a girl came down stairs wearing his t-shirt and I lost it." I said, sobbing into his chest. "Shhh, it's okay." He said, rubbing my back.
"I can't believe I ever trusted him with my heart. I'm so stupid." I said. "No you're not." Scott said.
~3 days later~
It's been 3 days since I left Theo. I have no tears left and I am just numb. I can't feel anything and all I do is sit and watch TV all day. Scott, Stiles, and Lydia have all been talking turns to check on me and make sure I'm eating. I heard the light knock on my door and expected Lydia to walk in-but I was wrong.
Theo walked in holding bags from the store. "Go away Theo." I said.
"I am not leaving until you let me explain." He said. "Fine, you've got 5 minutes." I said. "Y/N, I am sorry. I know I hurt you bad and I never meant to. All I wanted to do was get her opinion on something and then it just went from there. She kissed me and I didn't stop her. I know I should've but I didn't. We've barely been talking and I didn't know what else to do." He said. "We didn't talk because you were the one that wasn't talking to me." I said. "I know-and I'm sorry. I just-I can't lose you babe, please." He begged. Theo Raeken doesn't beg-ever. But his pleading eyes and cracking voice said other wise. "No Theo-I can't. You broke me." I said. "Goodbye Theo." I said. With that-he nodded and walked out of my bedroom-leaving me alone with my thoughts.