Cody Christian/Theo Raeken Imagines

"How do I know I can trust you..."- Theo Raeken

Requested by: @ayyessiremissmaria I hope you enjoy this! I'm sorry it took forever. School's been kicking my ass this semester. Thank you for waiting! :)

Don't get me wrong, Theo and I were best friends, before he moved away. I was very sad and I can remember that day like it was yesterday. Of course I'd prefer not to talk about it, but I well tell you about what happened when he moved back to Beacon Hills. Hint: It doesn't end like you'd think.

*Flashback*

"Hey, y/n have you seen the new guy? He's super hot." Malia said. "No what's his name?" I asked. "I'm not sure but he's coming our way." she nodded and I turned around and looked up and there stood a very handsome, and very muscular, Theo Raeken.

"Theo?!" I yelled. He looked at me and smiled. "Wait, you know this guy?" Malia asked. "Yeah, we used to be best friends before he moved away." I said and he met me at my locker.

"Hey sunshine, how are you?" he asked. That was Theo's nickname for me, sunshine. No, it wasn't because he had a crush on me. Although I wish it was, I had the biggest crush on him.

"I'm good. What are you doing here? I thought you moved." I said.

"I did, but my parents and I just moved back to Beacon Hills and I knew that first thing I had to do was find you first." he smiled.

I smiled at his words, "Well it's good to see you T," my nickname for him was T. He liked it and so did I. "come meet my friends. This is Malia." I said.

"Hi" Theo smiled and then looked back to me.

We walked around until I found Lydia, Stiles, Scott, and Liam all gathered around in a circle and walked over there.

"Hey guys, this is Theo." I smiled.

"You already know him? That didn't take long." Stiles laughed.

"Actually we used to be best friends before I met you guys and before he moved away. So yes I already know him." I said to Stiles.

"Well, Theo, this is (from left to right) Lydia, Stiles, Scott, and Liam. You already met Malia. You'll meet the other's later." I smiled.

"Y/n, can I talk to you?" Scott asked.

Scott and I walked a little down the hall and stopped. "Does he know?" he asked. "What do you mean does he know? About the whole supernatural business and such?" I asked.

Scott nodded., "Yeah, because if he does that could mean he's trying to get to me using you." he said. "Scott, Theo isn't like that. He's a good guy." I said.

*time skip in flashback*

I was running through the tunnels and trying to find my way out when I heard yelling.

"She has no idea why I'm even here! I told her it was because my parents wanted me back here. I just need a little more time to get him alone. Once that happens, Scott won't even know what hit him." he said.

'what the hell' I thought.

"y/n, is that you?" Theo asked. I knew I was screwed and I had to get out of there as quick as I could.

I began running in the other direction and eventually found my way out. However, Theo caught me just as I climbed out of the grate.

"Y/n, it's not what it looks like." he began.

"You lied to me Theo. You never came back here for me. You came back to try and destroy my friends." I said.

"No, just listen to me please."