Cody Christian/Theo Raeken Imagines

"Please never leave me again..." -Theo Raeken

A/N-This was a scenario request from @megantimsxx. I really hope it lived up to your expectations!

All I knew was that Theo was gone and something supernatural related was going on in Beacon Hills. My best friends, Liam and Hayden, didn't want me to get too involved. I obviously knew about Liam and Hayden and everyone else, plus the battles almost lost and those won. But they didn't want me getting hurt, so they would send Theo over to my house to watch me to make sure that I didn't leave and that no one came to hurt me. Theo was sweet to me and that caused me to catch feelings for him. The others knew and they weren't happy, especially Stiles, but they excepted it because they knew they couldn't stop it.

*Flashback to 6 months ago*

One night, I was sitting on my couch at home when my phone rang and Theo's name popped uo on the screen. "Hello?"I said. "Y/N, I'm sorry." He said right before the line went dead. "Theo?" I asked. I furrowed my eyebrows hanging up the phone and called Liam. "Y/N, what's wrong?" he asked as soon as he picked up. "Nothing. Theo just called me and I know you're supposed to be with him. He apologized to me on the phone and then the line went dead. Is everything okay?" I asked. "He left Beacon Hills Y/N. Theo is gone." Liam said. "What do you mean? He just picked up and left?" I asked. "Yeah, we can't find him anywhere. I'm sorry Y/N, I gotta go." Liam said, hanging up.

*end flashback*

For the last 6 months, I've been crying, wondering why Theo wouldn't tell me more and just apologize. Liam has been by to see if I am okay. Hayden and the rest of the pack have too. I was starting to convince myself that I'd never see him again. Until one day when I heard a knock on my door. I stood to open the door, revealing the pack on the other side, smiling. "Hey guys, I'm fine." I said, assuming that they were here to check on me. "We have someone that's been dying to see you." Lydia smiled before stepping to the side. Following Lydia's lead, everyone stepped aside to reveal Theo, smiling and crying. "Theo?!" I yelled, rushing outside and jumping into his arms. "Y/N!" He said, wrapping his arms around me as tightly as possible without crushing me. "God I missed you." I said. "I missed you too. I am so sorry. I should've told you this a while ago, but I am in love with you. I am so sorry that I didn't tell you I was leaving. I am sorry about everything." He said, sobbing into my shoulder. "Shh, it's okay." I said, kissing his lips. He was surprised at first but then melted into the kiss afterwards. "I-I'm so so-sorry. Pl-please forgive m-me." he begged. "Theo, it's okay. I forgive you." I said, crying my own happy tears.

From that day on, Theo hasn't left my side. He's still apologizing about everything because he still feels guilty. The pack has excepted him and our relationship.

Theo has no idea how much happier I am now that he is back. Having him back is all I could ever ask for.