LOST ( Peter Pan x Reader)

World's Most Famous Crook

It's been a while since the bonfire incident. James has been avoiding me, Peter keeps giving me googly eyes, and Wendy won't leave me alone.

"Y/N, do you think Peter likes me?" she asked for the hundredth time. Can she not take a hint. All those lies Peter told her were to get her to leave him alone and back off. It's like she's obsessed with him, wait... actually she is. She never shuts up about him.

I see James talking and laughing with Felix. I get up to go talk to him before Wendy makes me wish I was deaf. "I don't think Peter would ever fall in love with a ruthless pirate." She continues.  I stop walking. Okay, hearing her gush over Peter was slightly tolerable but now she's gone too far.

"You chav!" I say turning around to look her in the eye. She looks offended which is what I was hopping for.

"That's coming from a girl who went from being royalty to a run-of-the-mill." she says with an innocent face. Peter, having watched the whole thing, walks up.

"What's going on?" he asks looking upset and confused. I open my mouth to speak but Wendy beats me to it.

" Peter, this... this slag was harassing me! I was talking to her when she suddenly started insulting me.  Everyone knows that she thinks she's better than everyone else. Tell her she's not!" she demands. She  then clings to his arm. He looks at me and I look into his green eyes. I look back to Wendy and realize that the action of her getting so close to him made my blood boil. 

He smirks before saying. "You know, Wendy, Y/N doesn't look like a ruthless pirate to me." he says. Her jaw drops because she was not expecting to be caught in a lie. She looks at Peter and he says, "She looks more like a princess." He looks to me and smiles. It wasn't his usual smirk but a genuine smile. I smile back feeling happy that he didn't believe her. Something about Peter's smile makes me feel all warm and loved inside. Wait, that can't be right. I look at James and he gives me this look that screams 'I know what you're feeling'.

Thomas bursts out laughing. "In you're face!" he points at Wendy who turns a deep shade of red. She storms off. 

"Can I have a word with you, love." James asks. I nod my head in approval. We walk to our tent in silence. 

"Y/N, remember all those times we almost kissed?" he asks seriously. His face shows no emotion.

"Yeah" I don't know why but now every single need  or want to be with James has been drowned and I have a feeling we both know why.

"Peter loves you. I can see it every time he looks at you or stands near you. He's bloody in love with you and you're in love with him. Deny it all you want but I can see it. Thomas and Bailey can too." he says. I don't know what to say.  "I think we should just be friends. Don't worry Y/N, there are no hard feeling. I want to see my friends happy." he smiles at me. It does not have the same effect Peter's smile has on me but it's full of excitement. I give a small smile. He pats my back before walking towards the others. 

Bailey walks towards me. "What did he say?" she asks. 

"He wants to be just friends. He says that Peter, I mean Pan, is in love with me." I laugh a bit. I could never have imagined that Peter would ever love me but the thought of him feeling so makes me smile a bit.

"He is." she says. "It's obvious. He can't look away when he sees you. Hell, Thomas says that he swears he saw Peter's heart jump out of his chest when he saved you from falling." She chuckled "There's no way that boy doesn't love you." We looks at Peter but suddenly he looks as though he saw a ghost.

"Felix!" he yells. "We have some visitors" he says showing his infamous smirk. They walk int the jungle. Curious as to who was here, Bailey and I follow them. Its almost night so everything is slowly beginning to become darker. 

"Are you sure the shadow came from here?" a familiar voice asks. An equally familiar voice responds.

 "Pan is the only one I know who's detached from his shadow." I hear the voices stop talking. I hear someone clear their throat behind me. I turn around and see the last people I would have ever expected to see.

"Starfish, I expected that Pan would be keeping you in one of the cages." he says.

"Don't you 'starfish' me!" I say. Realizing I'm still hurt by the fact he didn't stick around before I was taken away, I quickly turn back to get back to camp. I then realize that Bailey's not with me. I turn back around and see Smeagol (Mr. Smee) with his hand covering Bailey's mouth. 

"Sorry Y/N" my dad says before blowing a strange powder in my face. Everything becomes blurry and my eyes begin to close before everything becomes black.

I wake up with a terrible headache. I hear arguing and try to get up but I can't. I realize that that my hands and ankles are tied to a chair.

"Captain, she wasn't ours to take!" I hear. The voice belongs to Daniel. I bet Bailey wasn't too happy to see him. "When Pan finds out she's missing he'll kill..."

"He won't."

"Too late." I hear. It's Peter.

""Get off my bloody ship!" I hear my dad yell.

"Peter!" I yell. I hope he hears me. If not, I'm probably going to go nuts. I can't stand sitting in this chair much longer. 

"Y/N, you're going to have to do as I say." I hear. The voice is Peter's but it's not coming from behind the door.  "close you're eyes." I do as I'm told and wait for his next instructions.  "Imagine that you can teleport to where I am. Believe you can and try to make it happen." I do as I'm told. Suddenly I feel warmth and the sun. I open my eyes to see my dad tied to a railing. 

"That was easier than I thought." I said.

"That was you're first lesson. Your second is to stay at camp when I'm not around." he says. He's not smiling, in face he looks furious.

"Sorry, I was just curious." I say. His expression softens but only a little bit. 

"Just please be more careful." He says.

"Since when do you care?" I say already knowing the answer. He looks even more angry before he opens his mouth.

"What do you mean 'since when do I care'! I've cared since the moment I fell in love..." he quickly closes his mouth and turns bright red but I've already heard all I wanted to know. "I fell in love it you and I want it to stop. "Here're some words of advice, princess. Be careful of love. It'll twist your brain around and leave you thinking up is down and right is wrong."

He teleport us back to camp before saying, " Your father may be the world's most famous crook but you've stolen something nobody else could before." he said.

"And what is that?" I ask amused. He looks me straight in the eye with pure admiration. 

"My heart."  he says before leaving again. What will I ever do about him?

this chapter was brought to you by: