Messed up in all the right ways {proxies X reader}

-Chapter 9-

-Recap-
-Eventually everyone had gone, but you and Toby-

You stood up from the couch, deciding to take your turn.

You turned on Sober up by AJR.

-Start song-

"Hello, Hello"

"I'm not where I'm supposed to be
I hope that you're missing me
'Cause it makes me feel young"

"Hello, Hello"

"Last time that I saw your face Was recess in second grade"

"And it made me feel young"

"Won't you help me sober up?"

Growing up it made me numb
And I want to feel something again 

Won't you help me sober up?

All the big kids they got drunk

And I want to feel something again
Won't you help me feel something again?
How's it go again? 

Goodbye, Goodbye, I said to my bestest buds

We said that we'd keep in touch
And we did our best
All my new friends
We smile at party time
But soon we forget to smile

At anything else

Won't you help me sober up?

Growing up it made me numb
And I want to feel something again
Won't you help me sober up?
All the big kids they got drunk
And I want to feel something again
Won't you help me feel something again?

How's it go again? 

How's it go again? 

My favorite color is you
You're vibrating out my frequency
My favorite color is you

You keep me young, and that's how I wanna be
My favorite color is you
You're vibrating out my frequency
My favorite color is you

You keep me young and that's how I wanna be

Hello, Hello

I'm not where I'm supposed to be
I hope that you're missing me
'Cause it makes feel young

Hello, Hello

Last time that I saw your face
Was recess in second grade
And it made me feel young
And I want to feel something again
I just wanna feel something again
How's it go again?

Won't you help me sober up?

Growing up it made me numb
And I wanna feel something again
(My favorite color is you)
Won't you help me sober up?
All the big kids they got drunk
And I want to feel something again
(My favorite color is you)
Won't you help me feel something again?
(My favorite color is you)
Can I finally feel something again?
How's it go again?

-End song-

You smiled, as everyone clapped (because that's what you do, okay?)

You returned to your seat on the couch, It was Toby's turn.

He turned on Natural, by imagine dragons. 

"That sneaky bastard, he's playing one of my favorites!" you thought.

He started singing, you were shocked (I'm too lazy to insert his ticking, so please, imagine it)

-Start song-

Will you hold the line?
When every one of them is giving up or giving in, tell me
In this house of mine?
Nothing ever comes without a consequence or cost, tell me
Will the stars align?
Will heaven step in? Will it save us from our sin? Will it?
'Cause this house of mine stands strongThat's the price you pay
Leave behind your heartache, cast away
Just another product of today
Rather be the hunter than the prey
And you're standing on the edge, face up 'cause you're aNatural
A beating heart of stone
You gotta be so cold
To make it in this world
Yeah, you're a natural
Living your life cutthroat
You gotta be so cold
Yeah, you're a naturalWill somebody
Let me see the light within the dark trees' shadows and
What's happenin'?
Lookin' through the glass find the wrong within the past knowin'
We are the youth
Cut until it bleeds, inside a world without the peace facing
A bit of the truth, the truthThat's the price you pay
Leave behind your heartache, cast away
Just another product of today
Rather be the hunter than the prey
And you're standing on the edge, face up 'cause you're aNatural
A beating heart of stone
You gotta be so cold
To make it in this world
Yeah, you're a natural
Living your life cutthroat
You gotta be so cold
Yeah, you're a naturalDeep inside me, I'm fading to black, I'm fading
Took an oath by the blood of my hand, won't break it
I can taste it, the end is upon us, I swear
Gonna make it
I'm gonna make itNatural
A beating heart of stone
You gotta be so cold
To make it in this world
Yeah, you're a natural
Living your life cutthroat
You gotta be so cold
Yeah, you're a naturalNatural
Yeah, you're a natural

-End here-

Everyone clapped, including you. You can't hold a grudge against Toby, especially because you missed his jokes, and his sad puppy look when he dropped waffles. After the incident, he wasn't acting the same, you hurt him, you hate seeing Toby like that, you really liked Toby, you admit it to yourself.

-End of chapter 9-

sorry for it being less story, but at least you've forgiven Toby.

Hope you enjoyed! Don't forget to leave a vote!

Derpy out~