Harry: “Peanut butter and jelly,” you repeat monotonously, staring at Harry to see if he was joking or not. “You want to go to Niall’s Halloween party dressed as pieces of bread.” “Not just bread!” Harry argues. “That’s boring then. No, we’re pieces of bread with peanut butter and jelly!” “That’s the most idiotic thing I’ve ever heard,” you dismiss, going back to searching for good costume ideas. “It’s cute!” he protests, trying to get your attention back on him. “We’re guaranteed to win best couple that night.” “Probably because Niall pitied us since our costume was so lame.”
Liam: “Prince Charming?” Louis laughs when Liam walks up to him and Zayn during the party. “How romantic, Liam.” “You should see (Y/N), she looks beautiful,” Liam remarks, ignoring Louis’s comments on his costume. “What were you saying about me?” you ask, popping up behind them. Your ballgown didn’t take up much space which was good since there were so many people at the party, but you still looked like a Disney princess. “I’d make a much better princess,” Louis rolls his eyes, Zayn shoving him lightly as he takes your hand in his and kisses the top of it. “You look amazing.” “Hands off my girl, Malik,” Liam warns him, pulling you closer to him. “Just trying to play the part, Liam.”
Louis: ”I think dressing as a king and queen makes sense,” Louis agrees after showing him your costume idea. “We’re the hosts and we are better than them…” “Louis!” you scold him, biting back a smile as you go back to scrolling through the website. “Well it’s true,” he mumbles, leaning his head on your shoulder. “And I think you’d look really good in purple.” “Obviously, I was meant for royalty,” you smirk. “Besides, a king without a queen is nothing.” “Excuse me?” he asks. “Oh please, Lou. Without me, you wouldn’t even be able to function.”
Niall: ”Are you- are you the pope?” Harry asks when he opens the door to let the two of you in. “Are you Jesus?” you retort, gesturing towards his long hair. “Long hair, don’t care,” he says, leading the two of you inside. Immediately, you both run towards the dance floor, getting in between the couples and screaming out, “You need Jesus!” or “Oh Holy Father, please help them!” Niall pulled a Bible out of his robe, waving it around while you held up a rosary. “Best costume idea ever,” Niall laughs as you take a break and drink some punch. “I hope that’s holy water,” you joke. “The pope isn’t supposed to drink.”
Zayn: ”Who are you guys supposed to be?” Liam asks as he leads you and Zayn to where the drinks are. “Morticia and Gomez,” you answer, Liam still confused as ever. “From the Addams Family,” Zayn explains, knowing that Liam had never watched the show. “Oh, that one with the creepy little girl who liked killing people?” Liam questions, trying to figure it out. “She didn’t kill people,” you reply defensively. “Looks like we’re going to have to watch it.” You add that to your mental list of movies you need to watch with the boys, taking a sip of the punch. “Do you like it?” Zayn asks, gesturing towards the drink. “They used real blood.” “Wonderful.” “Wow, you guys are really in character.”
