Tolkien Elven Imagines and Headcanons Volume 1

135. Tumblr Asks - Makeup Feanorians and Gondolindrim

Q/A: The order of which the Gondolin and Feanorian elves would allow/enjoy make up being put on them. Pleeeeaaase!!!!

Of course I can!!! ☺️ Elves usually aren't very big on make up as far as we know BUT if the circumstances were right or if it was widely available like it for us I'm sure they'd indulge! Let it be noted that this whole answer took on a life of its own lol

Fëanorians

Fëanor -  Fëanor, being who he is, is extremely confident in his appearance and his beauty and feels that it needs no enhancing what so ever. I think he would've absolutely experimented with it first though before deciding he didn't need to wear it. Content with you applying a couple of different things, like eyeliner and mascara and even some highlighter. He understands the appeal but again he is confident he doesn't need it. In turn Fëanor would absolutely apply make up to you instead, expect for subtle feature enhancing application until it comes to lipstick. Expect bold and rich colors as well as shiny and glossy gloss, he loves to smear your lipstick at the end of the day with a heated and passionate kiss.

Maedhros - Maedhros especially pre Angband wouldn't bother with any, if you wore any of course he wouldn't say anything. In fact he'd like the way mascara makes your lashes longer and giving the illusion your eyes are bigger. Post Angband that would change specifically in the name of concealer and foundation. Wanting to hide any scars that he could, he wouldn't allow for anyone but himself to apply it. And he'd have no interest in anything else but concealer in foundation when the times could allow for it in the midst of his oath and war.

Maglor - Pre flight, Maglor would love highlighter and possibly even mascara! He's a preformer, so anything that would enhance his beauty subtly would be accepted. Though he'd be averse to lipsticks and eyeliner and bright blushes. Concealer and foundation wouldn't be necessary considering his skin is flawless. He loved it when you'd put highlighter on him and how gentle you worked with him. Post flight he wouldn't worry about it, there's too much happening and not enough time to indulge in such luxuries.

Celegorm - Celegorm's version of make up would be extremely different as opposed to more classic wear and use. I think for him it would be more like face paint for the sake of hunting and blending in more effectively with the terrain. He's completely opposed to wearing any make up other than that, and will allow you to apply his face paint. You wearing make up on the other hand is completely okay and encouraged, especially encouraging you to wear bright red lipstick.

Caranthir - Caranthir I feel like would possibly like eyeliner, not anything heavy of course. Just a subtle line around his lash lines, and he's an expert at keeping it from running and smudging. Caranthir isn't big on letting you apply it onto him considering it's his eyes and is mildly fearful you'll stab him on accident. He hates concealers and foundations and especially blushes. If you're in a relationship and wear blush he'd find it somewhat endearing that you'd want your face to look similar to his. But if you're big on wearing foundation and concealer anticipate him to be cold about you wearing it. Especially if you are constantly telling him how much you love his rosy face as is, he finds it completely and totally hypocritical that you tell him not to alter his complexion while you do it in turn.

Curufin - Curufin, like Caranthir, would like wearing eyeliner! Rather than wearing around his whole eye like Cara would, he'd wear it just on his bottom lashline. He'd not be up for you putting it on him at all, not so much because you might stab him, it's just because he's stubborn. I feel like Curufin would also get creative with his liner, wanting to possibly make his appearance look more regal and intimidating. Like Celegorm and Caranthir, he'd be opposed to anything else. As opposed to you putting any make up on him, Curufin I think would enjoy dolling you up instead.