Previously titled Her Secret (Choni) Toni Topaz is a fledgling on the run from her ex-boyfriend Jesse who wants her to go full vampire but that requires her to taste human blood and Toni doesn't want to turn anybody. Once in Riverdale the town's very own Sharpay Evans, Cheryl Blossom develops a crush on the vamp and her crush advances into feelings will Cheryl act upon and will Toni tell her what she really is? Or will Cheryl have to find out her secret?