His Favorite Student | Levi Ackerman x Reader

24

Levi sat in his bed, whiskey in hand not sure what to do. He loved you so much and trusted you implicitly, but one fact was certain. He did have a vasectomy. He simply couldn't fathom that you would cheat on him. 

Was the time together not real? Were you that good of an actor? He didn't know and he wasn't sure if he wanted to find out. He'd foolishly given love a chance only to get hurt more than ever. The pain in his chest was unbearable. It felt like a million knives were stabbing through his chest simultaneously. He just wanted the pain to go away. 

Levi didn't know what to believe anymore. His perception of you was shattered, but it hurt so much because the only thing that could make him feel better was the very thing that broke him. He stared at his phone screen part of him wishing you'd call, the other wanting to block you completely out of his life so he doesn't have to be reminded of your betrayal. This dichotomy of emotions was driving him crazy. He loved you and worst of all, he missed you. 

He called Erwin and asked him to come by. He needed to vent. Erwin showed up not much later.

"You sounded upset so I brought a bottle of whiskey?" Erwin says as he walks through the door.

"Thanks man" Levi says. "You're right. I am upset."

"What on earth happened?" Erwin asks popping the lid off the bottle and pouring himself and Levi a glass.

"Y/n and I broke up."

"What? But things were so good a few days ago" Erwin says. "I thought you were happy for sure."

"She's pregnant."

Erwin did a near spit take on the whiskey he was sipping. "Woah, what? Wait, don't tell me you dumped her cause of that?"

"She's pregnant Erwin. And, I had a vasectomy."

"You did? When?"

"3 years ago. About when I decided I was probably gonna end up alone."

"So you think she cheated?" 

"Yeah. I mean, what else could have happened" Levi says sighing. "It's messing me up man. I never expected that from her."

"Did she admit it?"

"No, she insists she was loyal."

"Huh" Erwin says contemplating. "Yeah, that doesn't seem like her to cheat. That's the last thing I was expecting you to say honestly."

"Yeah" Levi says scratching the back of his head. "So I uh..sorta called her a whore and threw her out."

"She's homeless??"

"She can just move back in with her old roommates" Levi says not knowing Annie already took your place. 

As far as Sasha and Mikasa knew, you were living alone having found a cheaper place to live. Only Annie, Armin, and Jean knew you left to be with Levi. 

"She played me so bad man. I've never felt this hurt."

"Not even when you were shot?"

"Not even then."

Erwin chuckles. Only Levi could be so nonchalant about being shot when he was in the army. 

"I gotta say again, I did not see this coming. I hope you'll find some closure" Erwin says patting Levi on the back.

"Me too" Levi breathes. "Though I'm not sure how."

"Ooh I just thought..class is gonna be awkward isn't it?"

"Ah fuck I never even thought about that" Levi groans. "Fuck me honestly."

"I would but I have a girlfriend."