Why do you hate me?

Chapter 31

MEANWHILE

Casey was gulping down another cup of punch when Donnie walked over to him, more stumbled over to him because of how drunk he was.

"Hi Jones~" Donnie slurred and Casey couldn't help but laugh.

"Hey, you good there Don?" He asked and Donnie grinned sloppily.

"I'm gREat, hAve yoU trIeD the pUnch?"

"I see you have." 

Donnie leaned over to the human's ear. "It's so good." He whispered with a drunk giggle, making Casey chuckle with him.

"Okay, I think I should take that cup away from you." Casey said, doing exactly that.

"Noooo, I like my cup." Donnie pouted as Casey laughed at his whine. "You're no fun."

"Honestly Don, you're adorable when you're drunk." Casey then noticed his neck and smirked. "But as cute as it is, you better find your necklace so you don't freak about it tomorrow."

"Necklace? What necklace?"

"Your engagement necklace." Casey snorted. "Are you that drunk that you forgot that Mikey proposed to you yesterday?"

Donnie froze. "He what?"

"Proposed to you yesterday. Did you really forget?" He frowned as he saw tears well up in Donnie's eyes. "Don, what's-whoa, why are you crying?"

"He didn't propose to me yesterday!" Donnie cried and Casey's eyes widened.

"Oh shit." He cursed under his breath while Donnie sobbed into his hands as Mikey walked over to them.

"Dee, there yo- Donnie? Donnie!?" Mikey quickly pulled Donnie into his arms. "Dee, Baby, what's wrong? Why are you crying?" He turned to Casey. "Did you do this? What the hell did you do?"

"I...I uh.."

"He told me!" Donnie cried. "He told me, Mikey!"

"He told you what?" Mikey asked.

"He told me you..." Donnie trailed off into a sob and Mikey, not seeing another reason for Donnie to cry,  assumed Casey told him about him cheating and his eyes widened in panic before he turned to Casey with a glower.

"What the fuck Casey, how did you even know about that?!"

Casey held his hands up. "April told me, I thought you already-!"

"April?!" Mikey yelled, getting her attention as she came from the bathroom.

"What's going on over here?" She asked before noticing how Donnie was crying. Just like Mikey, she assumed the worst. "You told him?"

"No, Casey told him!" April looked at Casey.

"What!?"

"I thought he already knew!" Casey said in his defense. "How was I supposed to know he didn't?"

"April, how could you tell Casey?! I thought you said we shouldn't tell anyone and you tell Casey?!" Mikey yelled April.

"I didn't! I didn't!" April denied.

"I knew it, I knew that shit came out of nowhere! That's why you wanted me to tell Donnie! You had already told Casey!"

"I swear, I didn't tell him anything!"

"Stop lying!"

"I'm not! He must have figured it out!"

"Michelangelo." Mikey turned to Donnie as he had sniffled out his name and Mikey took his hands.