Ticci Toby x Reader .:LEMON:.

The Gift

SUP PEOPLE
LEMON WARNING
MORE LIKE SMUT
FUCK THIS SHIT MAN
AVIE IS OUTIE

Your POV:

No matter how many people I talked to, none of them could link the strange cult with Isabella. She had to be connected to them right? There was no way she wasn't! I hit the end call button on my phone and screamed my anger out. I had to protect Toby. He had saved my sorry ass more than once, it was my turn to do the saving.

After picturing Toby in a princess dress locked up in some tower, I found it hard to concentrate. I kept having to stifle a laugh as I imagined him screaming "OH SAVE ME MY DARING PRINCE" out a tower window. It had only been a month and a half since our last encounter with the cult. Their plan made no sense but it would have drawn Toby out... This was dangerous.

I decided to look through Slender's office. He had to have something on them. I waited until everyone was asleep and picked the lock. After an hour of looking through papers that were basically blank, I heard someone walk up to the door. I hid under the desk as the door opened, biting my lip and hoping to whatever Gods are out there that it wasn't Slender. "(Y/n)...?" A tiny voice called out, I peeked over the desk and smiled when I saw Sally.

"Hey there!" I stood up and walked over to her, picking her up and shifting her to my right hip, "What're you doin' up so late."

"Why are you in Slendy's office...?" She asked groggily as she rubbed her eyes, "Wasn't it locked?"

"I heard a noise coming from inside, I wanted to make sure everything was alright."

"Oh... Okay... Can you take me back to bed please? I'm so tired..."

"Sure thing, love." I carried her to her room and tucked her in bed. Making sure she was holding that creepy ass teddy bear shes always carrying. As I was walking back to Slender's office I felt a pair of arms snake around my waist as a suspected person bit my earlobe. "Not now, Toby." I smiled. He didn't answer. "Did you hear me?" He moved to my neck as he grabbed my wrists. "Toby, stop. I'm serious." He chuckled darkly into my neck sending shivers down my spine.

"I'm not taking no for an answer tonight. You need a break from... Whatever the hell you've been doing for the past month. I've got a gift for you." He whispered huskily into my ear as he spun me around and pinned me to the wall. "Be a good girl and you'll get the gift."

"What if I'm bad?" I raised an eyebrow. His smirk only grew wider and darker.

"Bad girls get punished." He slipped a hand under my pj bottoms and slowly rubbed my core through my panties.

"T-Toby I really shouldn't..." I stuttered as I tried to get his hand to stop by closing my legs as tight as i could. "I have a lot of research to do and..."

"You've been avoiding me, (Y/n). I don't appreciate being ignored." Danger tipped the edge of his voice like a razor blade. He was pissed. He wasn't drunk though, at least the situation wasn't totally fucked. "Since you've been ignoring me, you must be punished. Therefore, I'm taking what's mine."

"What if I fight you?" I raised an eyebrow. I wanted him. I wanted him so fucking bad. His voice alone already had me wet.

"I won't be gentle."

"When are you ever gentle?" I scoffed.

"Constantly. I'm always afraid I'll break you."

"And if I don't want you to be gentle?" He paused for a moment then chuckled darkly. Something about him was different, had he ever been pissed at me before? I recall us fighting but never having angry sex...

"Think about your next move carefully, love." He warned as he slowly started moving his hand again. My hands grabbed his shoulders as tight as I could, gripping fistfuls of his hoodie. I had to find info on the cult, but I didn't exactly have a way out of this situation. I closed my eyes as a quiet moan escaped my lips. Suddenly I found myself trying to push him away.

"Deciding to be bad, are we?" He pinned my hands above my head with one of his own as I felt his free hand move under my panties.

"Toby, no... I have to..." Before I could finish he pushed three digits into my core, I bit my lip to suppress a moan.

"If you stay quiet I'll only get rougher."

"Fuck off."

"Can't do that." He started pumping agonizingly slowly making me bite my lip harder. "I have control here, I can torture you all night, (Y/n). I love watching you squirm." He slowly kissed my neck, avoiding a certain spot on purpose. I gave in. I needed him. I wanted to challenge him.

"You ain't' gonna do shit, Tobias." I smirked as he froze. "You're all talk. If you were going to do something you would have done it by now."

"What did you call me?"

"What's wrong, Tobias? Don't like me saying your full name?"

"You smug little shit." He smirked as he thought for a second, I felt him pump his fingers even slower. I bucked my hips to try and get him to move faster. "Beg."

"I could easily do this myself."

"You sure?" He pulled his fingers out and licked them clean, his eyes never leaving mine. "You forget who is in charge, love. You pissed me off."

"Do something then!" I moved and got in his face as much as I could. "Fuck me or don't. I'm tired of waiting." Something changed in his eyes. I gasped when he picked me up and threw me over his shoulder, he carried me to our room and locked the door behind him. I tried to sit up.

He flipped me over and roughly pulled my pj bottoms and panties down, lifting my hips so my ass was in the air. He leaned over me as he ran a hand down my back to my ass and whispered, "I'm going to fuck you so hard you're going to wish you hadn't even thought about saying that." He rammed into me as hard as he could. I buried my face in the blankets to muffle my screams as he rammed me as hard and fast as he could. A knot started to form in my abdomen as I gripped the sheets so tight that my hands were turning white.

He seemed to be getting tired of my muffled screams, he pulled me up so my back was against his chest as he bit and sucked on my ear. I was so close. "I'm gonna-" he stuck his fingers in my mouth before I could finish. My screams filled the room as I dug my nails into his arm, finally the knot unraveled. I had never felt such intense pleasure before... A few thrusts later Toby moaned as he climaxed as well. I felt my body go limp as he let me fall forward onto the bed. He fell next to me as he tried to regain control on his breathing. "I should ignore you more often..." I laughed weakly.

"I don't recommend it..." Toby chuckled as he rolled me over and kissed me. It wasn't a hungry or lust filled kiss, it felt like an apology... I deepened the kiss then pulled away and smiled up at him.

"That was the most amazing sex I've ever had."

"Ouch."

"Don't get me wrong! All the other times were great! But this time..." I whistled to emphasize my point. He chuckled and pulled the blankets over us.

We laid there and talked for the next few hours. I told him everything. Everything I had been doing over the past month and a half. Everything I knew about the cult. Finally I kissed his nose, "Thanks for the gift."