The First "I Love You"

5.9K 173 284
                                        

A/N This is where you need to pretend the other one is dating your best friend because the stories are connected! Enjoy!

Dan:

You and Dan were at a fair that you dragged Phil and his girlfriend to.  Everyone decided to split up for the day. The first half of the day, you spent with Phil's girlfriend and you soon became besties!

"So, Y/N," Phil's girlfriend started while aiming to knock down the bottles. You looked at her.

"Yes?"

"Has Dan ever said he loved you?"

You thought about it, and found nothing. "No, I guess not."

"Same here." She knocked down only two of the bottles and sighed. She crossed her arms. "Maybe they don't love us?"

You bit your lip at the thought. "Or they just haven't said it yet?"

She shrugged. "Come on. We should be meeting them right now."

**************

"Y/N!" Dan grinned and hugged you. You hugged back, smiling a fake smile. "Hey Dan. How was your day?"

"Splendid! And yours?"

"It was...great." You replied nonchalantly. For a second, he was confused, but he shrugged it off.

"Shall we split up again?" Phil suggested. You looked at his girlfriend, who mouthed to just go along with it.

You and Dan agreed. When you walked away from Phil and his girlfriend, Dan decided to take you on the Ferris Wheel. You went along with it.

When on the Ferris Wheel, you were quiet. Dan was getting concerned.

The Ferris Wheel continued to rise up until you were about 50  feet off the ground. The setting sun looked beautiful and romantic.

"Y/N, there is something-"

"Dan, do you love me?" You interrupted him. His eyes widened in surprise.

"Y/N, of course I love you. I love you more than commoner's coffee!" If you don't get that reference go sit in a corner and rethink your life.

You smiled at brightly and you surprised him with a kiss. He kissed back and you two ended up making out. You loved him too.

Phil

You and Dan's girlfriend were hanging out at a fair you weren't planning on going to. You both became really good friends very quickly!

You two had just gotten off a rollercoaster when you spotted popcorn, and you decided to buy. While in line, Dan's girlfriend said something intresting.

"What's the sweetest thing Phil's said to you?" She asked.

"I lo-" You froze in realization. Phil has never said I love you. "U-Uh, I don't know! Hey look! Our turn!" You changed the subject. She got excited and ordered popcorn.
I guess Phil doesn't love me. You thought. I wonder if Dan has said I love you either?

You looked at Dan's girlfriend's happy smile. You sighed and you looked at the bottle throw. As Dan's girlfriend got the popcorn, you pulled her over to the bottle throw.

As you tried to make the shot, you spoke your mind.

"So, D/G/N," you started, aiming. "Has Dan ever said I love you?"

******************

After the bottle throw, you met up with Dan and Phil. You put on an act and acted happy.

"Phil!" You giggled, choking him in a hug. He was surprised, but hugged back. You kissed him passionately, and it would've been something more if Dan and his girlfriend weren't standing there.

"Shall we split up again?" Phil suggested. Everyone agreed. You and Phil decided to get cotton candy.

"Candy floss! My favorite!" Phil exclaimed, and you fake smiled.

"Lets go in the funhouse!" You suggested, and Phil nodded.

"Maybe then I can see your two faces." You muttered under breath.

***********

"Oh my god, I look horrible!"  Phil laughed. You pretended to laugh as you viewed yourself in another mirror.

Phil sighed. "Y/N, you're upset. I can tell. What's wrong?"

"Well, Phil, I don't think you love me."

Phil gasped. "Y/N, of course I love you! Where did you get that ridiculous idea?"

"Well, you never told me..."

"I love you more than anything else." He said. He grabbed your face and kissed you.

"I love you too, Phil."

Dan and Phil Boyfriend ScenariosWhere stories live. Discover now