Look I'm normally not a fan of this preference but it's my birthday so I'm legally obligated to do this. Enjoy!
Ponyboy: He would get you a camera. You both love photography and memories. But usually you just take pictures of him- but what can you say, he's pretty!
Darry: a Superman necklace. And I couldn't find a picture! But he's your Superman and it's kind of a running joke that the gang calls him super dope. He's learned to accept it.
Soda: Ok. So you steal his clothes all the time. And of course he doesn't mind. BUT it would be nice to have a shirt to wear to work. So he collected sweatshirts and shirts that he outgrew and gave them all to you. 🥰 He felt bad that it didn't cost anything but it meant more to you than some dumb expensive thing.
Dally: He got you a switch blade with roses on it. Being pretty small greaser, you get jumped. A LOT. And he was tired of coming home to broken ribs and bloody lips. Soooo he got you something to ensure it wouldn't happen again. It also came with free lessons (from him of course) on how to use it.
Cherry: uH not to flex but she gets you a car. A pretty sweet one too. You have matching stingrays ❤️❤️
Johnny: Johnny would get you something sweet like a kitten. Sure he found it in the alley behind Bucks, but you LOOOOVE IT. He also gave you some chocolate cause he's sweet. The kitten was a feisty black one that you two named "Winston." You can guess why.
Steve: Similar to Cherry, Steve fixed up a car for you. It was no Stingray, but it was a pretty good car. Soda helped him for weeks, staying after work. It meant so much to you that he'd put all that extra work in for you
Two Bit: Ok sooo this one he saved up for ALL YEAR. You two both love Disney and recently he's been gone all the time. You were just about to say something until your birthday rolled around and he got you both DISNEY LAND TICKETS! Turns out he'd gotten a job with Darry helping roof houses so he could save up. He's very committed.