Please Don't Leave Me (Winchesters X Reader)

chapter 9: Pie first

(Y/N)'s POV:

It was morning, and I had woken up in my bed, Sam laying next to me. My eyes were still resting, and I rolled over onto Sam's chest. He immediately noticed I was awake and said, " Goodmorning (Y/N)." He said sleepily. " Morning Sam." I said yawning. We both sat up, and scooted to the edge of the bed. " What happened last night?" I asked. " I think I drank too much?" I said rubbing my head. " So, since I was responsible with my drinking, you laid your head down on the steering wheel of your new car, and Dean sat in the passenger seat. Then after 10 minutes of me and your mom talking about random stuff-" I cut him off. " Wait, is Dean still in my car?!" You said scared. " No, don't worry I got him out. Anyway, your Mom got her new husband to pick her up, and she went home." Sam said taking a deep breath. I stood up, and grabbed my head. It was throbbing like hell, " Sonofabitch, that hurts!" I exclaimed. Sam held me close to him, and guided me back to the bed. He sat me down, and pulled the covers over me. " Your Mom said the case is at 4:45. You should get some rest beforehand, let me make you some tea." I stopped him before he went out. " Sam, I'm a'okay. See?" I said standing up. But then fell, " I just wanted to make some pie." I whined. I loved apple pie, and wanted some for breakfast. " Oh, I can just buy some-" "Sam, you don't understand, I need to make it!" I said using my puppy eyes to try and make him let me. " Okay, fine. But, as long as I can stay and help." He said reaching for my hand. " Okay. That's fair." I said grabbing it and getting off the bed.

-------

He had helped me grab ingredients from high places, and sat me down most of the time to let him do the work, but I never let him. See, you have to be presise when it comes to ingredients. After a while, he pulled the pie out of the oven and set it on the table in the kitchen.

Dean's POV:

I woke up to the smell of pie, and shot up out of my bed. I ran into the kitchen to see (Y/N) relying on a wall to keep her stable, and saw Sam settting the pie on the table. I thought to myself, ' pie, or (Y/N)? PIE OR (Y/N)!?' just then, I ran over to (Y/N) And lead her to the table, I heard her mumble, " Dammit, stupid hangover." I chuckled" I know right?" I looked down at the beautiful apple pie that lay on the table. " Okay, who made this pie for who? And why." She instantly responded. " I love Apple pie, and Sam told me, if I wanted one, he had to help me make it." She loved apple pie, even though she was Sam's, I loved her even more. I grabbed 3 plates and set them down in front of us, I grabbed a knife and cut us each a piece. " Oh yeah, um- (Y/N), I forgot to tell you, Dean loves Apple pie too." Sam said looking at (Y/N). " I thought I was the only one..." She said jokingly. " Well, that's something you were very wrong about." I said forking the pie. I put the bite into my mouth, and it was amazing! I started forking the pie into my mouth and was done before Sam and- I just then realized, (Y/N) was already on her second piece of pie. " Damn, you finished before me. That's new?" I said teasingly.
--------

After we ate the whole pie, we heard the door open, and heard footsteps coming downstairs. It was Cas, " Cas, where the hell have you been." I asked pissed. He had been leaving a lot latley, it made me mad. " Dean, somethings not right." He said worridley. " What, oh yeah, you're not right. You need to tell us when you leave." " Yes, sorry Dean." Cas said with his deep voice as usual. I looked over at (Y/N), her phone had rung. She picked it up and went into the backrooms.

(Y/N)'s POV:

I heard my phone ring, so I left the room. I'm kinda glad it rang, so I could escape the Dean and Cas drama. It was my Mom, " Hey, Baby. I have a question? Can we move the hunt to 3:00?" " Um- what time is it?" I asked looking at my phone lock screen. " It's 2? So, yeah. Okay. We can do that." "Okay, bye." She said then hung up. I walked into the room, and saw Dean and Sam sitting at the table alone talking again. I stood behind a pillar near the hallway listening in. I felt bed for doing this, but I needed to know something. " Dean, I know you feel things for her, and I'm sorry." Sam said looking at Dean. " Sam, you like her, so she's yours, it's not fair for you if I take her from you. Plus, I can- probably get over her soon. Ya'll have so much in common, plus, it's not often the Sam Winchester falls in love." Dean argues back. " Dean, I am just scared that we will loose her while hunting. Haven't you noticed, we are kinda toxic to be around." " That's true." Dean replies. " But what if this girl, is the love of your life, this is your only chance." Sam looked up and around, making sure no one was listening. I backed behind the pillar more, so I couldn't be seen. " But Dean, she's great and all, but I'm not sure about her just yet." Sam said. I felt my heart drop, what did he mean he wasn't sure yet? Did he not love me? I felt dissapointed, but soon after came out of my hiding spot, trying to act cool. " Alright guys, let's get going." I said with inconspicuous sadness in my eyes. Thoughts swirled through my mind, as we walked towards the door. I sighed and walked towards my car, when I thought, mabey, I could ride with the boys? " Hey, guys? Can I ride with ya'll? I'm still kinda hung over." I lied easily. " Oh- um- sure, I guess so?" Sam answered. " Oh, okay." I sat in the back of the impala, and laid down. The seats felt comfy, I pretended to sleep for the first 10 minutes. I overheard the boys speaking, as I fake snored. " (Y/N) is great for you." Dean said. " Dean, I don't know about her. I feel like the love I feel for her is- more of a family love. I don't feel- romantic with her." " Sam, you have to let her off easy, because I don't want to see her heart broken." Dean said back. It made me blush, I had realized that Dean had actually been the one I first met. I started to accidently doze off, after I heard that last sentence, " Dude, if you tell her you like her, she might not get heartbroken after me-"

Dean's POV:

I was happy that they were breaking up, it meant I finnaly had a chance to get with (Y/N). But I didn't want her to get heartbroken, I wonder if she would be with me? I was not going to tell her anytime soon though. Just then, we pulled up to the house, that (Y/N)'s Mom said she'd meet us for a case. I pulled up and saw another camaro, but it was wine red. I stepped out to see (Y/N) still asleep in the back seat. I opened the backdoor, and reached over and slightly shook her shoulders. " (Y/N)?(Y/N)? Wake up." She then suddenly threw herself up in fear, heavily breathing. " No!" I heard her yell. I sat down and put my arm around her, and held her in my arms. " Hey, Hey, shhh, it's okay. It's gonna be okay." I said soothing her. " I-I'm sorry." She said pulling away and getting out of the impala. I followed after her, and watched as Sam talked to her Mom. " Hey, Dean, nice to see you again, how are you feeling?" Bailey asked me. " Um- great actually." I did feel great this morning. I woke up, and ate pie, and learned that the person I love might be available soon. We walked inside the house, and we were not ready for what was going to take place next.