Sweet Poison

Sweet Poison (34 Part. 2)

"Dylan." She whispered, eyes downcast to the floor.

I paused in shock."Um, what?" I asked again.

"Dylan Davis." She said again.

I nodded and got up. "I'm gonna go now." My mind was in a state of shock and disbelief. I didn't want to believe it was true, but I knew it was.

Isabelle stepped up closer, grabbing my arm. "Please, don't tell mom" She pleaded, begging me with her eyes.

"Yeah, yeah we'll talk about this later." I mumbled in a daze and stumbled out of her room. After I shut her door, I rushed into my room and slid on some shoes. Feeling anger slowly begin to surge, I picked up my phone."Sarah it's a S.O.S. I need you to pick me up and drive me over Eli's house fast!" I rapid screamed down the line, once she picked up, before hanging up the phone without even waiting for a reply. I paced anxiously outside as I waited for her car just imagining the different, very violent, scenarios that could happen once I arrived at their house.

Once she pulled up, I quickly hopped in the front and she was off. "What's the big news?"she asked.

"Dylan and my sister sex" I couldn't even get the words in a comprehensible sentence because I was so angry. 

"Really!" Alice screeched coming from out of no where. "I thought your sister was a little angel! You think you know someone eh?"

"This is bad, but oh so entertaining." Trish added.

My heart gave a leap at their voices and I jumped, glanced to the backseat at them, then glared at Sarah. "They're coming?"

She smiled apologetically and shrugged. "Sorry. They were over my house when you called and when you said it was a S.O.S there was no way of telling them they couldn't come."

Running a hand over my face, I relaxed in the seat. "Okay whatever"I sighed, putting my hair into a ponytail.

"So what are you going to do?" Trish asked leaning in. Her voice was more amused than concerned.

I shrugged."I don't know, I'm going to get him though."

She smiled and looked out the window.

We arrived at his house. I rushed out of Sarah's car and slammed the door and hurried up to their front door. I didn't even knock, instead I grabbed the door knob, turned, and the door opened. Eli's friends must be here I thought to myself.

I rushed upstairs and turned the knob on Dylan's door. Once again a door was thankfully unlocked for me. Without a second to lose, I slammed the door shut and locked it. Seconds later there were three consecutive thuds to come from the door like the girls had just ran into it."Sorry you guys, I have to do this alone", I yelled from the other side.

Groans sounded from the other side. "Come on!" Alice said from the other side of the door. I ignored her and looked at Dylan who was starring at me with wide eyes.

"What are you doing here?" He asked.

I ignored his question and instead approached him with my eyes narrowed. "I'm going to give you one shot to tell me the truth, who were you with yesterday?" I asked.

"This girl named Ashlen but why is that-",he paused, realization flashing across his face finally realizing why I was here. "I mean . . ." He didn't know what to say because he had just revealed two things to me. One, he had cheated on my sister and two, he was indeed a womanizing scumbag.

  With strength that came out of thing air, I yanked him off his bed and pulled him up by his collar so we were eye to eye.

His eyes widened even more, alarm flashing across his face. "Wait, wait you-you owe me!" I paused my action, balled hand dropping to my side. "Yeah you owe me! You can't hit me because you owe me because I drove you home that one day." I starred at him  my mind going over all the times he had helped me out.

"You are so lucky you ass. However next time you want."I let go of his collar and he sighed relieved. Giving him one last repulsed glare, I turned around and started to head for the door.

"Wait, Elissa."

I turned towards him, not really wanting to hear any crap that would come out of his mouth. "What?"

"Tell your sister I'm sorry and i'm sorry to you too. I knew this would come bite me in the ass, I just didn't know this soon. I'm really sorry" I ignored him and unlocked the door and walked on. Suddenly, Sarah, Alice, and Trish fell into room and landed near my feet.

My eyes raised, mouth dropping. "Were you guys listening?" I hissed.

"No!" Trish was the first to speak, getting up and nonchalantly brushing herself off as I hadn't caught them red-handed and as if they didn't all just face plant. Shaking my head, too tired to argue with any of them I stepped around them and started to walk out.

Dylan followed. "I'm sorry please don't give me the silent treatment Elissa."He kept saying to me, trying to plead his care and begging me not to be mad at him.

I turned towards him. "Where is Eli?" My tone was sharp and cold.

He winced, but answered anyways pointing to the back of the house. "Outside with his friends."

I started to walk towards the kitchen with Dylan in front of me. I was looking at the ground when Dylan started to push me backwards. "What are you doing?" I asked, stumbling backwards and pushing his hands down.

"Maybe we should go the other way."He smiled.

Looking at him like he was crazy, I pushed him aside. I was still angry at him, but with Dylan it was hard to stay mad at him for too long. I also knew that this was just't his fault. Afterall, Isabelle made the consenting decision to sleep with him. However, I still had to keep up the act of me being furious. So scowling at him, I stepped around him. "No, I want to go this way."

Ignoring Dylan's panicked expression, I walked towards the door and slid it open. I started to walk on the deck and abruptly stopped, heart dropping. Sarah, Alice, and Trish all halted behind me. Alice gasped, Trish snorted, while Sarah stayed silent.

I looked at Dylan, who looked at me with concern, with tears forming in my eyes and then I glanced at Eli who currently lip-locked Shelby. "Pull away, pull away, please pull away"I kept saying to myself under my breath, hoping that this situation was just like me and Wade's and hoping that we could just forget about it. I hoped this was all a misunderstanding, but no he didn't pull away until what felt like a decade later. By that time, my heart was already on the floor and stomped on.

He pulled back and gazed at Shelby with what looked like pure lust in his eyes.

 I glanced at Trish who mouthed with a conceited frown, "told you so".

Hating the piercing pain that erupted from her silents words, I glanced back at the scene feeling like this was all happening in slow motion. I should've walked away a long time ago, but something kept me rooted, paralyzed to the spot.

Eli suddenly broke his stare with a smirking Shelby and glanced up at all of us. His eyes widened looking completely busted. "Fuck," he hissed lowly, running a hand over his face.

I swiped a tear from eye with the back of my hand and turned to my girls refusing to let Eli and that bitch see me break. "Lets go you guys." There was more strength and confidence in my voice then I was feeling at that moment. They all nodded and together we turned towards the patio door while Sarah grabbed my arm and gently ushered me to the front.

Fave. Comment. Feedback