When We Realize (A Sheo Fanfic)

Chapter Eighteen

·WARNING: Explicit Content·

*Theo’s POV*

I called Shailene that night at ten o’clock, hoping she would be awake.

“Aloha!” She answered, and I smiled.

“Would you like to go for a late night swim?”

“But… The pool room closes at ten. And it’s… ten.”

“I don’t care,”

She laughed. “Are there any apartment building rules we aren’t going to break?”

I laughed along with her. “We won’t paint our walls black.”

“Speak for yourself!”

I smiled. “Meet me up there. And be quiet.”

I hung up and grabbed my bathing suit and towel, walking to the pool room. The lights in the pool and the room are out, so it it’s pretty dark. It gives it a cool effect. I dropped my stuff on a chair and hopped into the water immediately. I swam a couple laps until I heard the door open. Shailene walked in, already in her bathing suit, with just a shirt on over her. She took it off. I squinted at her in the dark, not sure whether her new bathing suit is navy blue or black.

She stepped down the ladder into the water, and immediately ducked under. She swam all the way over to me without breathing once, and stood next to me in the shallow end. She wrapped her arms around me and put her head on my chest, shivering.

“It’s colder than usual,”

“I know, the water heater isn’t on.” Her body feels tiny in my arms. She feels warm against the cold water, and I love the way our skin feels against each other when it’s wet.

She pulls away from me and swims to the other side. I follow her to the middle of the deep end. Her eyes look so cool in the dark. She smiles as I stroke her cheek, but when I am about to kiss her, she goes under the water. She swims all the way to the bottom, sitting there for a couple moments before coming back up. I try to kiss her again and she swims back to the shallow end. I roll my eyes, a smile on my face, and follow her.

“Let’s skinny dip,” She says suddenly, reaching to unclip her top. I stop her by taking her hand away.

My heart starts to beat faster. “That’s, uh, not a good idea.”

“I don’t know,” She leers. “I thought it was a good idea. Why don’t you?”

I think of how to say what I am thinking without sounding weird. “Because… I want the first time for me to see you naked to be when I’m taking your clothes off.” I whisper.

Her eyes widen. “You can take off my bathing suit,”

I shake my head. Why is she doing this to me? Does she even know what affect she has on me? “But then I will want to take advantage of your nudity.”

“Good,” She says confidently.

I take a shaky breath. “You aren’t supposed to have sex in a pool.”

“I know, then we won’t. Just stop over thinking everything Theo.” She bit her lip.

I lifted up her head by placing a finger under her chin, and kissed her. I always want to kiss her when she bites her lip. I slowly move my hands to the clasp of her bikini top and undo it. Then I untie the straps around her neck. I fling her top off to the side, still kissing her. My hands slowly move to touch her breasts, and she shivers at my cold hands. I pull back to look at her.

She smiles sheepishly. “So beautiful,” I tell her, shaking my head in disbelief.

She steps back and takes off her bikini bottom, throwing them off to the side. I can’t stop staring at her. I try to step towards her again, and she steps away, laughing and splashing water at me.

“Refrain yourself sista! Come on, take off your trousers, it feels nice.”

She starts to swim to the other side and I laugh, taking off my swim shorts and throw them next to hers. Can we just hope to God that no one walks in? I swam across to the other side slowly. I watch her as she climbs out of the pool and tiptoes over to the diving board, standing up there confidently and looks at me.

“Don’t make too much of a splash,” I say.

“I won’t,”

She dives into the water perfectly, barely making a sound.

I clap my hands quietly when she comes up all the way at the other side. I swim to her, staying under water the whole time. Once I am standing next to her I slowly back her up until her back is against the pool wall and I am pressed up against her. A small moan escapes her mouth and I kiss her quickly. Her lips move equally as fast against my mouth, and I love the way her body feels entirely against mine. I eventually pull back, breathing heavily. I kiss her neck and her collarbone.

“Can,” I say, taking a breath. “we go back?”

“Yes,”