Sixth Secret (Pretty Little Liars)

17. The Jenna Thing

Alison's POV
I need to talk to Olivia immediately because I figured out the perfect plan to make sure Toby realizes to finally stop being a freak and peeping through my window. I have a firecracker but it's not a huge explosive one, it shouldn't do too much damage. Just enough to get Toby in his right mind. I call Olivia right away and I hope she is in for it.

"Hey Livie, I have a plan. You know how Toby keeps watching us get undressed and all that?" I ask her

"Yeah, he makes me want to puke near him. What's the plan?" Olivia asks me

"Well, I need you to get the girls next to Toby's house and we can throw a firecracker in his house. Don't worry it's not explosive just a small one. I promise" I explain to her

"Ooh, I'm in! I just hope the other girls are in and don't get all chickened out." Liv mentions and she's right.

"They would do that but I'm doing it anyways. Just stick on my side please." I tell her

"Don't worry, I got your back. Promise Ali" Love her so much "Thank you so much, see you soon." I tell her and hang up and get everything ready.

The girls finally get here with Olivia and she has a huge grin on her face and I love it. She stands next to me and I show her the stick.

"Woah, you're actually doing this. Hope this gets him have a clue about being a freak." Hanna of course is already scared and confused. The other girls are more chill right now.

"Are we sure he's not in there?" Aria asks me "He's not ok, you got the lighter right Spencer?" I ask and Emily grab my arm.

"Let's wait a second" Emily says in a shaky voice. "What Emily?" I tell her annoyed because of her chickening, she needs thicker skin.

"I don't want to do this." She chickens out "Fine go back you're on your own." Olivia tells her and I smile at her.

"Ok, maybe Emily's right, we'll just call the cops and they'll take him and take care of it." Aria suggests

"Where's the fun in that? Girls Toby Cavanaugh is a freak and we need to teach him a lesson. If he thinks he can just spy on us while we're in your bedroom Emily, he needs to know that his little domain is no longer a safe hideout. I mean who knows what he does all day in there that little freak." I point out

"Are you sure that it was Toby?" Spencer asks and I can see Olivia starting to get annoyed. "Yes and it's a stink bomb for goodness sake, we're not nuking the place. Now c'mon let's do it!" I yell at Spencer

"Give me the lighter" I grab the lighter and throw it in the house and see someone. I close the door fast as possible and turn to the girls while closing the door. "Let's get out of here." I grab Olivia's hand and the house explodes in fire.

"Ali what did you do?" Spencer freaks on her "C'mon let's get out of here." I suggest and we run. The girls are pissed and we go back to my place instead after we've grabbed our stuff from Emily's. Olivia and decide to talk in the bathroom while the girls all shake in Emily's room and we close the bathroom door.

"Ok just to let you know I did not mean for that to happen." I inform Olivia honestly

"I know because I know you but the girls probably don't think that, especially Spencer because she was the most pissed out of everyone. Anyways, so what was it you talked to Toby while I was distracting the girls?" Olivia asks me

"Just warning him not to tell on us or there are going to be consequences. Basically scaring him into taking the blame." I explain "And it worked" Olivia says proudly and we smile. We go back to the girls and they're still shaking and Olivia and I roll our eyes.

"Guys get some strength, just move on from this. We'll pretend it never happened. No one got seriously hurt anyways." Olivia points out

"Except for Jenna and we did that." Emily says scared and we roll our eyes and sit down and talk while the girls get scared.