JOHNS POV
"w-what?" I stammered, not believing my own eyes. But there it was, a pregnant olivia right there in front of me. My first thought was to comfort katy, to let her know that this didn't change anything between us, that I loved her just as much, but I couldn't move. Olivia just stood there, eyebrows raised as she watched me like a hawk.
"katy..." I whispered, grabbing her hips from behind. I couldn't see her face, but I knew she was crying from the way her shoulders were slumped and shaking. "katy talk to me..." I whispered into her ear, holding her against me as tight as I possibly could. I was afraid she was slipping away from me just by how she was acting towards me.
"You've been sleeping with her..." She commented, her body shaking in my grip.
"No! Katy, of course not.. not since-"
"since before you came along." Olivia spat rudely, making katy turn on her heels and she started towards her. Before she got anywhere I held her back, firmly wrapping my arms around her waist as olivia smirked at us, knowing she was untouchable.
"Get out of our fucking house!" Katy yelled, squirming in my grasp. She was losing control as olivia continued to taunt her.
"John, your girlfriend seems upset." She pouted as if talking to a puppy. Katy unraveled right before my eyes as she began to once again shed tears down her cheeks. She stopped struggling in my arms and finally grew weak as she leaned against my chest, feeling tired and defeated. Her anger and sorrow overtaking her body as I held her up.
"Are you 100% sure it's mine?" I asked, through gritted teeth. I had a feeling she was lying. Why would she have waited so long to come to me about this? Right before she was about to have this baby?
"There's a slight possibility that it could be another guys.." she admitted in a small voice, "but I'm pretty sure it's yours."
"So what you're saying is, that it might not even be mine, yet you're here threatening katy and trying to get me to leave my fiancé for you?" I asked in disgust. How dare she waltz in here and put us through all of this.
I felt Katy's breath begin to slow down to its normal pace against my neck after hearing the possibility of it being another mans. Though I knew it didn't comfort us any, if at least gave us a little bit of hope.
"I just miss you. I want you to be the one to raise this baby with me, yours or not." She stated, this time calmly. I knew there was still some of the good, nice, friendly Olivia inside. She just needed to put on a show to push katy away. In a way I don't blame her.. she's scared and wants to be with the possible father of her child.. but this is no way to treat katy who did nothing wrong.
"He's with me!" Katy laughed, a big sarcastic grin present on her face. She was so shocked that olivia would come in here actually thinking she could get away with this. "We're engaged! I'm pretty sure he loves me and doesn't want someone he left for me in the first place!"
That one got everyone to shut up, and quickly. That had hit olivia hard. It was hard enough knowing that she was being humiliated and cheated on almost our whole trip, and now it was just shoved right back into her face...
"Katy..." I whispered against her temple, warning her to stop before she said something she regrets. "No! I've had enough of her! Now pick so she can leave!" She screamed, turning in my arms to look up at me.
"Baby.. you know I pick you, it will always be you, but I can't just abandon her if that's my child.." I said cautiously, not wanting to trigger her anymore. She was on the brink of falling apart.
