Stranger Things Imagines II

LET YOU DOWN (V)

recap: a frustrated Billy saw everything that happened between you and Mike, now wanting answers.
•••

It was the same afternoon that Mike had managed to get you back. Thoughts were everywhere in your brain, they were scattered and it seemed like nothing was going right in your head.

You knocked on the front door of Max's house.

Billy opened it.

He had a cigarette in his mouth and sweat was clearly running down his toned body. You swallowed thickly, trying to keep it together.

"Can we talk." You said.

He nodded, opening the door wider as you walked inside. Billy shut the door behind you as he leaned against it. "So?"

"So what?" You asked.

"You clearly didn't tell Mike anything that happened." He said, the cigarette bobbing up and down on his soft lips as he spoke.

"No, because he told me the reasons for distance. You were wrong about there being someone else." You told him.

He got closer to you. "What about last night, ____? What does that mean to you? Anything, anything at all?"

You swallowed your spit thickly but your mouth had become dry. "It was nice, Billy. It relaxed me and it calmed me down but I'm still with Mike. I cheated on him!"

Billy shook his head, chuckling slightly. "Come on, _____. I told you that I can treat you so much better than he can. Hell, he distanced himself so far from you that you came to me for help!"

"I didn't come to you for help originally! I came for Max but you insisted! This is your fault, Billy!"

His strong hand was soon on your back as he pulled you towards him. He took out the cigarette, his face close to yours.

"This isn't my fault. You came back to my lips after saying no. If you hadn't been so vulnerable, maybe you wouldn't of been taken advantage of."

"That's your fault." You said, tears springing to your eyes.

"Oh, ____, that's none of my fault. You know you would much rather be with me than that son of a bitch." He said.

You tried to get a soft sigh out but instead some angry tears came out. "Billy, I cheated on my boyfriend. Does that mean nothing to you?"

He shook his head. "Not at all."

After that, he let go of you as Max came out from her room.

"Billy, what the hell are you doing?"

He shook his head, saying nothing to his sister as he stuck the cigarette back in his mouth and began to walk back towards his room.

You had no choice but to tell Max now.

"Max, I cheated on Mike with your brother." You spilled out, trying to stop the continuous flow of tears.

Max just blankly stared back at you.

"When."

"Last night."

"Why."

"Because I felt hurt and he was there."

"You were vulnerable."

"I know."

There was more silence before Max spoke up again. "You have to tell Mike."

"And lose him?"

"You'd have Billy to come get laid with, which by the way: this makes me very uncomfortable. Why, _____." She spoke the beginning in sarcasm and ended in all seriousness.

"I can't risk him, Max. Just don't say anything to Mike and maybe we can work through this."

—
part six on hisnameiscastiel :))

treat people with kindness.

-katherine