Guilty As Sin? (Nathan Prescott x reader)

35

Y/n's pov

I was almost done getting ready for dinner with the Prescott's. To say I was nervous would be an understatement, but to say I wasn't excited would be a lie. When I finished the final touches I look in the mirror. The dress I was wearing was fancy, and the tag confirmed it when it said 2500 dollars. I was nervous just at the fact I was wearing it. Nathan told me his sister asked him for my measurements and he ended up asking Dana which I thought was funny.

My hair was half up half down and i had a small purse with me.

Nathan: I'm outside whenever ur ready
Me: kk I'm coming

I looked in the mirror one final time and took a deep breath. Then headed out the door, in the hall while I was walking to the exit Dana came out of her room and saw me. "Y/n!!! You look beautiful, per use" she says cheerfully. "Thank you Dana" I say and she can definitely tell I'm nervous. "Dinner with the Prescott's huh? You must be nervous." She says. "Yeah...not something I would've ever thought I'd be doing" I tell her.

"Well good luck y/n let me know how it goes!" She says and walks to the bathroom and I leave the building. I walk to the parking lot where Nathan is smoking a cigarette while leaning against his car. When he sees me he takes one more huff then throws it on the ground and steps in it. He's wearing a white button up with dress pants, a watch, and a nice belt, his hair is the way it usually looks.

When I finally get to the truck he pulls me into a kiss, "you look great" he says. "No need to lie" I tell him. This outfit was definitely not something I'd usually wear and I felt very out of my comfort zone, and the price made me a whole lot more nervous. He opens the door for me and I get in and buckle up. He then goes to the drivers side and gets in and does the same.

"Don't be nervous, my dad's a piece of shit but I doubt he would say or do anything while we have guest. Tho I am worried that he might not know we will be having company..." Nathan says trying to calm me. "Okay... speaking of family dinners, when my parents come to your game this weekend, I was hoping we could all go the the diner together?" I ask. "Of course, it'll be a lot better than this is. It's a pretty long drive tho so get comfortable" he says and he was right.

Of course I've met the prescotts before in the past but not formally like this. The whole car ride Nathan and I talked and I couldn't tell if he was trying to help me calm down or calm himself down.

Eventually we pull into the drive way of a beautiful house, or I would even call it a mansion or a manor. "Woah" I say mesmerized. Nathan chuckles and says, "I assume you like it?"

"Absolutely, this place is beautiful, I can't wait to see the inside." I reply. Nathan's parks the car and gets out then comes around and opens my door and holds my hand. "Uh before we go inside- uh just... be careful of your...wording I guess. My dad isnt very fond of jokes" Nathan says

"Aye aye captain" I tell him and he jokingly rolls his eyes and rings the doorbell of the beautiful house. A maid opens the door and takes my purse. We step into the foyer and Mrs. Prescott comes over to us. "Nathan I'm so glad you're here!" She says and hugs him. When she pulls away she looks at me and shakes my hand, "it's so nice to see you again y/n" "you as well Mrs. Prescott.

She leads us into the dining room and as she's doing such she says to Nathan. "I had the chef make your favorite, Asian grilled salmon with spicy hunan style vegetables!" She's so happy and calm and collected, I'm surprised that someone like her could be married to someone like Sean Prescott.

In the dinning room Kristine is already sitting in her seat, when she sees us she stands up and comes over to us. As she does so Mrs Prescott sits down in her chair.

Kristine goes over to Nathan and hugs him, "It's good to see you again Nate" she then turns to me, "and y/n I'm so glad you agreed to come! This outfit looks beautiful!"

"Thank you" I say.

We all go to our seats and wait for Sean to arrive and when he does you could cut the tension with a knife. He clears his throat when he arrives and sits at the head of the table.

Shortly after the food is served to us. It's quiet, and I know it's best for me to keep it that way. Eventually though Kristine says, "the foods great mom". "Thank you dear. Y/n I forgot to make sure you weren't vegan or anything- I hope it's alright." Mrs. Prescott says. "Oh- I'm not uh vegan...the food is great!" I laugh nervously. Nathan is sitting beside me and I can tell he's tense. "I wasn't expecting any guest, but since she's here I guess we should have the discussion." Sean says and I look at him confused. "Dad let's not do this-" Nathan begins but is interrupted by Sean hitting his fist in the table, not super hard but enough to make the table shake. "Y/n y/l/n, we are an important family in Blackwell, and since my son couldn't listen when I told him to end things with you then I have to take things into my own hands. You are associated with us now, so don't embarrass me" Sean says. "Honey I think it's best we enjoy our dinner, and I don't think you have to worry about y/n embarrassing us. She's a lovely girl" Mrs. Prescott says and I give her a thankful smile.

After a few more minutes of silence dessert comes out. As we're eating Kristine asks , "are the two of you going to be doing the play again this year?" "Yeah- I've been doing theater for...forever" I tell him. "You guys did great last year. I can't wait to see what Mr. Keaton comes up with this year." Mrs Prescott says.

For the rest of dinner Mrs Prescott, Kristine, and I exchanged conversation, but Nathan and Sean did speak anymore.

When dinner was over Sean asked Nathan to go to his office. Then Kristine and Mrs Prescott went to go get something.

I got up and looked around for the bathroom but I walked by a room and heard the 4 of them talking.

"How long is charade gonna last Nathan?" Sean asks. "Why does that matter dad" Nathan replies. "Cmon dad she's a nice girl, she cares about Nathan and Nathan cares about. He's happy that's what matters" I hear Kristine say. "This isn't about happiness this is about the Prescott name." Sean replies. "I think that's enough Sean" Mrs Prescott says. "Whatever we're leaving" Nathan says then I hear a loud smack and a gasp.

Oh my god? Did Sean just hit someone? I quickly walk back to the dining room before anyone comes out and sees I was ease-dropping.

After a few moments Nathan appears in the dining room. Part of his face is red and I knew then he was the one who was hit and my face saddens. "Were leaving" he says sternly. I say ok under my breath and follow him out. As we exit the door the maid gives me my bag back and we quickly go to the truck.

The drive back was somehow even longer than the one there. "I'm sorry" I say. "No...I'm sorry, I should've known it wasn't gonna go right" Nathan says and for the most part the drive it quiet.