Guilty As Sin? (Nathan Prescott x reader)

20

Y/n's pov

It was Friday and I was in chemistry and me and Warren had just finished presenting the class with our project. The previous night I was in his room working on it with him and then after that I went to see Nathan.

"You did great!" Warren says to me. "Thank you Warren." I appreciate how kind he is. We aren't close but we've definitely gotten closer over the past few days with this project.

When the bell rings me and Warren walk out to the court yard together and talk for a moment and there are lots of people in the courtyard at this time. Mostly people studying or gossiping.

"I made sure I bought tickets for the play tomorrow, I'm actually really excited even though it's not really...my thing" Warren tells me. I smile and say, "well I'm glad you'll be there Warren. Romeo and Juliet is my favorite". "Yeah it's not too bad, I should get going bye y/n" as Warren leaves I see Nathan walking towards me angrily.

"What the fuck" he says, "you were in his room last night?" His finger points at me aggressively. "Yeah? We were working on our chemistry project." I say confused. "What the fuck ever, you know I don't like him, and yet I see my girlfriend hanging out with him in the courtyard! And going to his dorm with out even telling me! What the fuck y/n?" Nathan's tone is getting louder and people begin to look at us.

"Maybe you wouldn't have to worry about that if you weren't such a pussy and would tell people that you're my boyfriend! But instead you wanna hide it! Why? Because you're embarrassed of me? Because I don't fit into the 'vortex club' with all your pretentious friends! Because then maybe we wouldn't date at all!" I yell back.

"Seriously! That's what you think this is?" Nathan's shouts back.

"Yes! This secret is eating me alive! I can't do it anymore Nathan- I won't..." I say lastly and walk away leaving Nathan alone in the courtyard with everyone staring. Though they didn't know about us before. They sure as hell do now, but it doesn't matter because it's over now. And as the tears in my eyes stream down my face I run back to my dorm.

Nathan's pov

As I watch her walk away I feel tears in my eyes. There too many people watching to cry, so my sadness turns into anger as everyone is looking at me. "What the fuck are you punks looking at!?" I yell at everyone and grab my phone immediately to call Victoria. It rings a couple times until she answers. "What's up Nate" she says cheerfully. "Uh- we need to talk, like now would be good" I say panicking. I begin walking to the girls dorms giving dirty looks to anyone who looks at me. "Sure uh- I'm at my dorm. Is everything-" I cut her off and say "I'll be there in a sec".

I go to her door and open it and see her sitting at her desk and stands up when I walk in. "Jesus Nathan what's wrong? My phones been blowing up like crazy, did something happen?" She says worrisome. Sometimes I forget that deep down Victoria isn't all bad, that's what's different about her and I.

I shut the door behind me and sit on her bed with my head in my hands. "I fucked up vic" I say. "You're scaring me what happened?"

"Y/n" I say quietly. "What about her-?" She asks. "She is- was- ugh we just broke up in front of everyone in the courtyard". I hold back the tears in my eyes.

"What?" She says confused. "You guy- for how long...what? What happened?"

"Almost three months ago...shortly after the vortex club party....i wanted to keep it a secret- she...I don't know. I saw her with Warren and got upset and she said that it wouldn't be an issue if people knew we were together." I explain in a quite but quick manner. Victoria plops on the bed beside and sighs. "I'm sorry Nathan...I wish you would've told me, but I understand why you didn't." She tells me. "I told my dad about her...I wanted him to meet her. Fuck me."

She pats me on the back. "Nathan I've never seen you like this" she thinks for a moment and says, "I'll figure it out" I look at her confused, "there's nothing you can do Victoria...she hates me, just like everyone else at this school." I stand up and leave. As I walk out of her room I see a familiar face about to leave hers. She sees me and gives me a dirty look.

"Wait y/n! It's not what it looks like!" I say loudly as I realize what it looks like. I see her sigh angrily and go back into her room and shut the door. 

I felt the defeated as I walk back to my dorm.