Engagement ring
A/N: I know I already put what your kids look like but I meant to put wedding related things before that... Sorry \_('-')_/
Damon-
The ring that Damon bought you was simple but complex at the same time. It had a simple design but all the diamonds around the ring and big diamond made it complex.
Stefan-
Stefan's ring is beautiful, is it not? The twists (the struggles) leading up to the beautiful diamond (the joy of being together). Stefan is a tad sensitive so of course he would've thought of that.
Tyler-
Plain and simple. Tyler's choice was something that he found suited your relationship. It was elegant without anything extra.
Matt-