"..." I was speechless. "Y-yes!" I jumped and smiled brightly. Slenderman claps his hands and teleports right next to me- wrapping me in a big hug. "Let's get everyone in here!" He laughs and calls for everyone. Soon the door bursts open and all the creepypastas except Clockwork come in.
"Guess what children, y/n is going to be our newest proxy!" Everyone smiles and gets into a big group hug- but it had to stop once Jeff and BEN started dog piling Masky and Hoodie. "Y-Y/n...y-your a proxy!" Toby took off his mouth guard and kissed me all over my face.
"I-I know!" I stuttered- blushing I kissed him back, our soft lips clashing. We all run out and celebrate, pillows flying everywhere and feathers in the air. "Whoa children! No destroying my things!" Slenderman boomed making everyone in the mansion stop what they were doing and stare at the faceless man. "Yes sir." Everyone said in unison- which was kinda creepy mixed with some funny.
Sally went back to her room, waving at me and eventually all the creepypastas started to move out. "H-hey y/n? Can you follow me?" Toby asked, timidly fiddling with his fingers. I smiled and nodded, walking next to him as we started to travel upstairs- hand in hand. "You have to close your eyes though." He said as he covered my eyes with his hands when we stood in front of his room. To be honest, I haven't seen Toby's room in a while now so I wondered if he did anything with it.
"Ready?" The twitchy teenager said. "Ready." I replied with confidence, thoughts running through my head on what it could be. I heard the door being opened and Toby uncovered my eyes. He had a heart shaped card in his hands and the room was decorated to the max. It was... amazingly spectacular! There were ribbons dangling from the ceiling and little paper hearts hanging by strings. The room also had a lot of reds and pinks in it, candy was laying on the drawer next to his bed.
"W-will you be my valentine?" He asked, tugging on the collar of his sweatshirt to let the hot air out. He looked REALLY adorable though- faint blush spreading across his cheeks as he began to get more flustered. "Y-yeah!" I chuckled. He did a first pump and handed me the candy along with the card. I opened it and felt my heart warm up, it was a really sweet card and the handwriting was pretty neat!
Dear y/n,
When I look at you, your presence makes my heart leap. I do love your voice, eyes, soft hair, and your cute face. You make me worried sometimes (Don't do that anymore!) and you have made my the happiest person in the world- like right now. I do love you so much y/n, and I'm glad your mine.
I laughed and thanked Toby for the generosity and the time to decorate his bedroom for me. "Toby, I love you too." I said as I kissed him on the cheek and grabbed my clothes to change in for the night. I started to walk out his room and towards Jeff's room. "You c-could change in here... w-with me..."
"You're beginning to sound like BEN!" I laughed and kept walking, arriving to Jeff's bathroom and taking a nice short shower.
"Hey Toby." I said when I got back from the little trip. "Oh h-hey y/n." I threw my dirty clothes in his laundry basket. He waved to me as he was getting into bed, I did the same- it was kind of cold in the mansion at the moment. "H-here." Toby whispered as he hugged me from under the covers.
I guess he saw me shivering.
I smiled and hugged him back, stealing all his warmth from him. As I did this, I thought about all the good things that happened today- becoming a proxy, being Toby's valentine, even cuddling Toby right now. I was happy for it all and didn't want this moment to end. "I love you Toby." I whispered before drifting off to sleep. Before I fully fell asleep, I heard a soft, "I-I love you too."
YOU ARE READING
Ticking with Love (Ticci-Toby x reader)
Fanfiction[Completed] [Warning: This is a fan fiction.] Drew this cover but looks like trash rip. This is also my first book! (I'm kind of active) See you! This is a really old book and I wrote it when I was a wee lad so it will probably suck but whatever. R...
