She was the only thing he couldn't understand.
Caroline Forbes story. Kind of AU.
The Vampire Diaries season 4.
I do not own C. Forbes or any other TVD character. I just own my character and the plot.
Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.
-----------
"THANK YOU FOR COMING," Elena was in her kitchen, pouring herself and Sam, who was seated at her kitchen table, two cups of tea.
"You want me, I'm here," Sam told her calmly as Elena placed down the kettle before taking the two cups into her hands. She turned around to face Sam with a slight glare.
"I hope you didn't cause any bad things while I was in Whitmore," Elena told him accusingly as Sam took one cup with a smirk. Elena found it weird that he wasn't clothed in his usual black suit. He looked normal, his age in a simple bomber jacket and a pair of jeans. "By the way, I didn't call you. You just knew."
Sam took a sip of his tea before swallowing the hot substance. "Hot tea. Very nice though," Sam chatted as Elena sighed before leaning against one cabinet.
"I don't know what I'm doing. Everyone thinks I'm crazy for agreeing to your help," Elena told him as she put down her cup of tea and Sam did the same. "Damon's angry, Bonnie thinks I'm rushing things and Stefan- he's just confused."
Sam knew how she felt, because he knew pretty much everything about her. "Bonnie... I want to meet her. She's a powerful witch," Sam said as Elena glanced at him uneasily.
"And why am I talking to you like you're my best friend again?" Elena asked bitterly causing Sam to stand up. Elena tensed as he walked over to her before standing in front of her. Close. "What are you—"
Sam then opened up the cabinet next to her head before taking out some sugar. "I like my tea sweet," Sam told her as Elena stared at him overwhelmed. Sam grabbed the bag before closing the cabinet and sitting back down as he threw one sugar cube into the cup.
Elena still stood in one spot, feeling electric. "Um... So you're here-"
"Because in Whitmore you lost control. You fed for pleasure with Damon, who's in love with you, who you love too, but you're with Stefan so it's complicated," Sam listed as Elena sighed in annoyance. "I know, Elena. To be honest, I like Stefan more. Because all Damon does is think with only one side of his brain, not caring about other consequences. But isn't that what drives you insane in a good way?"
Sam narrowed his eyes as Elena scoffed before taking her cup of tea and drinking. Sam smirked. "I see... You have a thing for a bad boy. Everyone does. I'm a bad boy myself," Sam nodded as Elena chuckled dryly.
"This is weird. I shouldn't have invited you here," Elena shook her head as Sam leaned back in the chair before looking at her intensively. "You're not even helping."
