Two Murderers (Jeff the Killer x Reader)

A Dream

I was floating. Up and up into the clouds. I saw him. My love.

"Hello, (Y/N). I missed you. I figured out how to visit you in your dreams. However, I cannot stay long," he spoke.

"But, how? Why?" I was confused. I grabbed his hand and pulled myself closer to him. There seemed to be no gravity. Nothing keeping us apart.

"You will have me back, don't worry. Whenever you reach the mansion, I need you to bring me back. Nobody else. Can you do that?"

"Yes, babe. Yes, I can," tears started to form.

"Aww, babygirl don't cry. I've been with you this whole trip."

"A-Are you mad that BEN kissed me?"

"Hell yeah, I'm mad. When I come back, I'm gonna beat his ass. But, you are also at fault. However, I forgive you. I appreciate you trying to stay loyal. I know it can be hard. Through it all, I still love you, (Y/N)"

"I love you too, Jeff. And I'm sorry."

"No need to be sorry. I understand that it's difficult with BEN constantly trying to get in your pants. I'm sorry I'm not there to help you."

"It's ok.

"It's time for me to leave. I love you and I'll be back before you know it."

"Okay," I sighed, "just promise me you'll visit me again tomorrow?"

"I swear on my grave."

"Okay. I love you... bye, for now."

"Bye, my love."

I awoke in tears.

"What's wrong?" BEN asked,

"I... I saw Jeff... in my dream... he's... found a way to communicate with me."

"I didn't know that was even possible," Slenderman said, awed.

"Well... apparently.... apparently it is," I managed to get out. I cried even harder. I hadn't realized how much I missed Jeff until now.

"Hey, it's okay. Let it all out," BEN touched my lower back, a little too close to my behind.

But I didn't want to make a scene... more than what I already have, anyway.

Toby, seeing me, came over, "y-you okay? What h-happened?"

"Jeff..." I barely managed.

"She saw him in a dream. He's trying to commune with us."

"O-Oh. That's what sh-she means. O-Okay." Toby ticed more than usual. Probably the stress of the past several days.

"Yes. Just leave her alone and give her some time to calm down. Both of you."

"O-Okay,"

"But-"

"No buts. Leave her alone. She needs some time to herself."

"Thanks, Slender," I sniffled.

"My pleasure."

Everyone left me alone for the next couple of hours. I finally had some time to myself. It was nice.

I felt very cold. It wasn't abnormal, though, as it was in the middle of winter. Although, one hand seemed colder than the other. I wondered if Jeff's spirit was there, trying to hold my hand.

<Jeff's P.O.V>

I saw her wake up crying. My heart hurt for her. 

I missed her so bad. I wanted to touch her, to feel her kiss. I wanted more than anything to kiss her neck, her lips. I wanted more than anything to kiss her where it might make her squeal, moan, or squirm.

But I couldn't.

My soul was out of my body. I was no longer flesh and blood. I could only watch from above. Or have my spirit be walking alongside her.

(Y/N) was my quest. My destiny. She was my everything.

And she had lost me to fucking blood loss. Blood loss! Of all things, it had to be the simplest.

But I was gonna come back. I was determined. I had to.

I wanted to marry her. I wanted to get down on one knee, obsidian ring in hand, and ask, "(Y/N), I have loved you since the moment I met you. Please, accept my ring as a gift of marriage. Please, I beg you, will you marry me?"

I wanted a family with her. A little girl, maybe. I hoped she would name her something like Zoey. Zoey Woods.

 I would teach our little girl how to kill, how to be a silent stalker. I would be there for her first kill. Her second. Maybe even her third. (Y/N) and I would watch our little girl grow into our big girl.

Just one of my many fantasies about us. The life we would have. I wondered if she thought about that, too.

Then, there's my best friend, BEN. He's been hitting on my girlfriend ever since I died. That bitch was gonna pay.

And I knew just how. Although Slendy may kill me, literally, for what I planned on doing.

But it wouldn't be the first time.

I sat next to (Y/N) and placed my hand on hers. I longed to have her see me.

Then, she moved her hand in a way where I could lace my fingers through hers. So I did.

She must've felt it, too, because her hand tightened around mine, but went through it a little. It felt kinda weird, but good at the same time.

"I love you, (Y/N)," I said. I don't think she heard me.

"I love you, Jeff," she whispered. One tear fell down her cheek, then two. She looked at my body and suddenly more came. I hugged her.

"I miss you, Jeff. I don't know if you can hear me, but I miss you so god damn much!" she cried harder.

BEN Drowned came over to my love and hugged her. That was my job! Fuck off, BEN!

Thankfully, (Y/N) shrugged the hug off. But he kept trying. She kept shrugging it off until finally, she said, "BEN! How many times do I gotta tell you, I'm taken by Jeff! Don't hug me again, don't kiss me again, don't do any of that shit again!"

But he just wouldn't stop! Damn, if I were alive right now, I would've punched the asshole to oblivion.

"Aw, c'mon. He won't know."

Like hell, I won't. Of course, I know, I'm right fuckin' here!

"Yes, he will. I have a feeling he's watching over me and knows my every move."

Atta girl. There's my kitten.

"Well, we can't see him,"

"BEN. Do you not understand ghosts. Are you not a ghost yourself?"

"Yes, I am a ghost, but I'm one of the rare visible ones."

"So, if Jeff is a ghost, then why don't you think he would be invisible to the naked eye?"

"Uhh..."

"Exactly."

That's my little kitten! Always outsmarting the tough.

Just think of what our little girl would be like...

Sigh. I love you, (Y/N). I always will.