Two Murderers (Jeff the Killer x Reader)

Conflicts and a New Mission

Jeff had some pretty severe bruises around his neck.

It's been two days since Slenderman almost killed Jeff. I forgave him, but I still am not totally over it. I still occasionally give him the stink eye. He, of course, glares back at me.

"You okay?" Jeff asked.

"Yeah... my thoughts are just going down a rabbit hole again."

"Damn, that's like, what, the third time today?"

"It's been a long day, okay?"

"Hey, you rhymed!"

"Yeah..."

"What's got you thinking?" Jeff leaned in from behind me. I felt his warm breath on my neck. It smelled of alcohol as usual.

"Just... stuff," my heart fluttered from the close proximity. I swore I was going to have a heart attack someday if he kept on making my heart do this.

"Like what kind of stuff?" his mouth was so close to my neck.

"L-L-Like..." I stammered, unable to think as he pressed his lips to my neck. He sucked on a single spot and bit it gently.

"Like?" his voice was velvety and sensual.

My heart pounded even harder. I could feel myself getting wet down there.

Jeff heard my heartbeat and merely smiled. I placed my hand on his head, signaling for him to keep going.

Before I knew it, there was a giant hickey on my neck. Jeff grinned.

Then, he reached for my womanhood and started rubbing. I stifled a moan. "Jeeeeff."

"Yes, kitten?"

"Wh-Why?" I asked, still trying to not moan.

"Because I love you, and I want you."

"I want you, too, but..."

"C'mon, you know I have no self-control."

"Y-Yes."

Jeff rubbed faster, causing me to moan softly under his touch.

"There you go. Just let it happen."

"J-Jeff~"

"Yes, kitten?"

"I love you."

"And I love you."

"I have a mission for (Y/N) and EJ, so, Jeffery, stop trying to seduce her. Let her get ready," Slenderman teleported in our room, right in front of the bed.

"Ugh, did you have to choose now?"

"Jeffery Woods, I swear your death will be soon and in my hands if you don't stop mouthing off!"

"Damn, okay. No need to get feisty."

Slender only had to glare for Jeff to shut up. He knew when he was overstepping boundaries.

"Fine. Take her. But if she gets a single scratch on her, I'm blaming you and EJ."

"Babe, we're killers. We're gonna get wounds and injuries. It's okay. I'll be fine."

"You know I don't like you with other boys."

"And you know I don't like you with other girls."

"Slendy, why can't we just do the mission together?"

"Like I said when I sent BEN and (Y/N) together: she needs to go on missions with everyone living in this mansion--including me--before she can choose who she goes with," Slenderman replied, ignoring the fact that Jeff had called him Slendy.