Two Murderers (Jeff the Killer x Reader)

There's a First Time for Everything

Jeff slid his large member into me. I gripped the sheets in immense pleasure and pain. He drew in and out of me slowly, getting me used to his girth and length.

I moaned his name, "J-Jeff~"

I pulled him as close to me as possible and crushed my mouth against his. I molded myself against his body. He was hard in all the places I was soft.

"(Y/N), oh, fuck, you feel so good." he mumbled against my lips.

His words made me feel all warm and fuzzy inside. 

"Y-You too~" I could hardly think straight. My only thought was Jeff.

He pumped a little faster. I gripped onto him tightly.

"Fuuuck~" he moaned.

I could feel his member pressing against my tight virgin walls. I felt him going deep inside of me.

I pulled him closer to me and kissed him aggressively. His tongue met mine.

He started pounding me. His movements got sloppier with each pump.

It felt amazing.

He moaned my name. I moaned his.

The headboard abused the wall, just as Jeff abused me.

"I love you~"

"I love you more, kitten."

"I-I love you most~"

"Who's dominant here?"

"You?"

"Exactly, baby girl. I'm on top," he growled into my ear, nibbling it. I got even more aroused. Which, by the way, was near impossible.

I rolled over, getting on top of him. I rolled my hips in slow, circular motions. I moaned, "Oh, shit, Jeff~"

"Mmm, kitten~" he groaned.

I smiled. 

I trailed my kisses to his neck. I kissed around until I found his sweet spot.

"Mmm..."

I was now going entirely off of instinct, and I think Jeff was too. I started moving my hips up and down swiftly. This earned me a loud moan from Jeff, followed by a "Shut up!" from BEN.

"Go fuck yourself!" Jeff called back, me still riding him. I could tell he was trying hard to not let his voice crack from the sheer amount of pleasure.

The headboard hit the wall harder, weakening it. But I wasn't paying any attention. I was focused on Jeff and Jeff alone.

Well, as focused as I could be, seeing as my thoughts were clouded by lust and the need for Jeff.

How long have I been dreaming of this day?

Since we first met.

"I love you, (Y/N)~" Jeff groaned as I moved my hips back and forth. I didn't think about what I was doing. In fact, I could hardly think at all.

Before I knew what was going on, Jeff was on top of me again. "You think you can get on top and stay there that easily?" he grinned seductively.

I didn't get a chance to reply. He started thrusting into me harder than before. I turned into a moaning mess.

He hit my g-spot so much that I started to feel that particular feeling in the pit of my stomach.

I moaned loudly. 

Apparently, BEN heard. He shouted, "SHUT THE FUCK UP! IT'S BAD ENOUGH THAT YOU GOT MY GIRL, BUT YOU DON'T HAVE TO RUB IT IN MY FACE!"

But we both ignored him still.