Two Murderers (Jeff the Killer x Reader)

Yes!

"(Y/N), I have loved you since I first laid eyes on you. With that cute smile and those magnificent (E/C) eyes, you could make any man's heart melt, psychotic killer or not. I don't want anyone else to have you. You're mine. That's why I'm asking you this: (Y/N) (L/N), will you make me the happiest man in the world? Will you marry me?"

I gasped and covered my mouth. Tears started forming. My heart practically leaped out of my chest.

"What do you say?" Jeff nervously asked. He looked so vulnerable. So insecure. Like I might say no.

But I wouldn't.

"Yes!" I exclaimed, leaping into his arms. "Yes! Yes! Yes! Yes! Yes! Yes! Yes! Yes!"

He heaved a sigh of relief and embraced me.

"I love you," he whispered in my ear.

"I love you more," I grinned.

"Nuh-uh," he smiled and pulled away, grabbing my left hand. He slid the beautiful engagement ring on my finger.

"Yeah-huh," I giggled, looking at it. It was magnificent.

"And who's the one that just proposed?"

"You?"

"Correct. Therefore, I love you more."

You crossed your arms.

"Haha, I win!"

"Hmph."

"Why the pouty face?"

"Because you have a point, and I don't like it," I cracked a smile.

Jeff burst out laughing. I did, too.

"Come here, kitten," he pressed his mouth to mine. I leaned into the kiss, wrapping my arms around his neck. He tasted of alcohol, as usual, but he wasn't drunk.

He scooped me up and carried me to our bed. I could feel his pounding heart through his bleach white hoodie.

He gently set me on the bed and passionately kissed me. His tongue begged for entrance. I parted my lips in response, and our tongues mingled and played.

Every time they met, it felt like it was the first time.

Everywhere Jeff touched me, I felt the shivers.

It felt like a dream.

But it wasn't. This was actually happening.

How long have I been dreaming of the day when Jeff would propose?

"I love you so fucking much. You have no idea what you do to me," he whispered, biting my ear harshly.

"And I love you," I replied, trying not to moan from the sharp but pleasureable pain.

Jeff's hand traveled to my throat and squeezed it, effectively choking me. He wasn't squeezing too hard, so I could still breathe and talk, but hard enough for me to feel the pleasure of it.

And dammit if that didn't make my heart pound and my nether region wet.

"Do as I say, and you'll get rewarded."

"Okay, daddy," I smirked, still being choked.

"Good kitten. Help daddy take off his hoodie."

I did as told and took off his hoodie, pulling his black shirt up with it. I tossed it off the bed, and my hands roamed his bare back, tugging him closer.

Jeff pulled off my shirt and threw it somewhere in the room. He unbuttoned my jean shorts, slid them off, and threw them by my shirt.

That left my lace bra and thong.

"Now, take off daddy's pants," he murmured into my ear as he pinched my buttcheek. I moaned softly as a reply.

I obediently reached for his jeans and began unbuttoning them, with Jeff guiding my hands.

I felt the firmness of his member press against me as I took off his jeans, leaving just his black boxers.

I touched his toned abs. He grinned, biting my ear harshly. He roughly squeezed my breasts, causing me to whimper.

His lips met mine once again, and he shoved his tongue into my mouth.

I tugged him closer, grinding my womanhood against his hard-on. He started breathing heavier.

"I fucking love you," he groaned against my mouth.

"And I fucking love you," I replied.

"Not as much as me."

"Wanna bet?" I challenged.

"Fuck yeah," he accepted, unhooking my bra and tearing off my thong. He hurled them across the room.

I took off his boxers and flung them by his other clothes.

Jeff aggressively rammed his rock-hard manhood into me, causing me to inhale sharply.

"You like that?" he violently choked me while continuing to thrust.

I absolutely freaking loved it. I let out a strangled moan of pleasure.

"Good kitten. Let that Link copycat know that you belong to me!"

I heard BEN grumble, but I was too caught up with Jeff to notice.

He continued to ram into me, choking me in the process. I bucked my hips in time with his.

"Fuck~!" Jeff grunted and moaned. With his free hand, he grabbed my arms and pinned them above me.

I whimpered as he harshly pounded me, screaming "Daddy~!"

There was a knock on the bedroom door. "Keep it down. Sally is in the mansion this time, and we can all clearly hear what you both are doing," Slenderman ordered.

"F-fuckin' Slendy...al-always gotta ruin it," Jeff barely got out through the pleasure. His voice cracked a couple of times. The sound of slapping skin and loud moans could be heard.

"I heard that! Call me Slendy one more time--"

"Or el-else what?" he challenged, still thrusting into me. I smothered my moans into Jeff's neck.

"Then I will bust down this door and haul your ass out of this mansion!"

"Fine, we'll keep it down!" Jeff surrendered.

I assumed that Slenderman teleported away, since I didn't hear him say anything else.

Jeff bit into my neck, causing me to cry out from the pure pleasure. Thankfully, it was muffled. I felt him sucking pretty hard on that one spot, so it was going to leave a big hickey in the morning.

He kept on thrusting, groaning or moaning "Fuck" every few seconds. I felt the knot in the pit of my stomach grow.

"I-I'm gonna--!"

"Not yet! Not unil I'm done with you!" he growled. He pulled out, flipped me onto my stomach, and shoved himself back inside me.

"J-Jeff! Ah~!" I moaned as his memeber hit my G-spot repeatedly.

"That's Daddy to you," he corrected, harshly spanking me. I yelped and loved it.

"Harder, Daddy!" I whimpered.

"You asked for it, kitten," Jeff warned before slapping my ass really hard. I completely loved it.

"So, you're a masochist, too? Fuckin' awesome. Then, you shouldn't mind when I do this!" He spanked me as hard as he could. I moaned so loud that Slenderman shouted at us to keep it down, and my voice was muffled by my pillow!

Finally, I hit an orgasm. My legs involuntarily shook for a minute and I felt like I was in Heaven. Jeff kept spanking and choking me harsher as he was climaxing as well.

"Fuck~!" he groaned and slammed into me harshly.

The next thing we knew, we were both coming down from our high. I noticed that he came inside me again....

...And I haven't been taking my birth control pills...

FUCKING-- FUCK!