It has been 2 months since your falling put with Jeff. Siren had been taking care of you and had let you sleep with her instead of having to sleep with Jeff. She made sure that you 2 never crossed paths for long and if you did, she would always play bodyguard. To be honest, you hated the way she was treating you but you knew that it was her way of showing you that she cared. There had been several times when you, Jane, Clockwork, Zero, Judge Angels (who had returned to the mansion a few weeks after the 'incident' with Bloody Painter), Lulu, Ani (from the Creepy Frozen Pasta comic if u dont know what she looks like shes the one in the picture and idc what anyone says i ship her with EJ so they will be a couple in this story!), and Siren would all get together and either go on a hunt or just hung out like normal teenaged girls. You appreciated the company and when you needed some time to yourself, Siren was happy to leave you to your thoughts. But, like always, things only got worse.
One day, you and the girls were hanging out, having a few laughs about a recent hunt, when a female scream echoed throughout the mansion. Siren's ears pricked up and everyone looked at the open door to see Jeff dragging a tied up and crying woman around your age down the hall. The sight of Jeff hurt you but the curiosity for the female clouded that pain. Everyone waited until the last for the female was gone until they started chatting again.
"What the hell was that about?" Siren asked. Judge shrugged.
"He's never brought prey back home." Zero said. "Normally, that goes to EJ." Lulu nodded in agreement.
"I don't know if anyone else noticed, but he looked pissed." Jane said.
"Guess I wasn't the only one then." Ani said. Clock nodded in agreement.
"Same here" she said. You shook your head.
"Does anyone have any idea as to why he brought someone back?" you asked. The other girls looked at each other and frowned.
"This is the first time he's done this." Ani said.
"You know how he is with his kills. He's more of a 'leave them behind' kind of killer unlike EJ who's more of a 'take to hide' kind of guy." Jane said. You nodded at Jane, remembering the hunt you had with Jeff and Siren not long after actually meeting Siren. The memory pained you to think about and Siren must have picked that up. She put a hand on you back and smiled.
"It's ok, (Y/N)." she said. "I'm sure there's a perfectly logical explanation to this." You looked at her with thankful eyes and yawned. Siren noticed and looked at the other girls. She didn't need to say anything for the others to stand and bid everyone good night. You smiled at Siren and moved away from her. She turned into her giant wolf and curled around you, making her body the perfect bed for you. Her thick, fluffy tail lay on top of you like a blanket while her side was like a soft pillow for your head. You liked sleeping like this and she knew it. It made you feel safer and she vowed to protect you for however long you needed her to. She curled her head around so that one eyes was on the door and the other was on you. You smiled and pet her fur for a bit before yawning again and falling asleep...that is, until you heard the noise.
You woke up to the sounds of loud moans. You didn't recognize the voice so you were confused. Siren was already up and staring at the door, her ears straight up and you could tell that her mind was trying to figure out who the moaning belonged to. It didn't take long before she growled darkly and you felt her body tense so you decided to move away from her. Once you did, she bit the door handle and opened it before walking down the hall. You were still confused until you heard a door crack up and Jeff yelling. You were still confused until your head snapped everything together and your eyes filled with tears.
The woman Jeff had brought with him was the one who was moaning and Jeff was the reason for her moaning. The thought of Jeff messing around with another girl hurt you so much, the pain was overwhelming. You heard Jeff yelling at Siren but the words were muffled. You didn't care anymore. You cried until you started looking around. You had to get out. You had to leave. It hurt too much to stay anymore. You saw the window by Siren's bed and quickly rushed to it. You were a story off the ground so you jumped out, rolling when you landed. You didn't wait long before you ran for the woods, tears still streaming down your face as you ran.
You ran as far as you could until your legs started to burn and you had to stop for breath. You knew Siren could easily follow your scent so you grabbed some nearby mud and rubbed it all over your body, masking your scent from the intelligent werewolf who was your bodyguard and friend. After you felt better, you started running again but in a different direction, thinking that Siren would decide to keep going the direction you had been going. And even if she didn't, she wouldn't know which way to go to follow you.
You kept running until a sudden burst of flames stops you in your path, causing you to jump back. You stared at the flames until they died out, revealing no other than Zalgo standing over you, a shit-eating grin on his face.
"We meet again. (Y/N)." he said, bowing playfully. "How are things in Sender's manor?" You tightened your jaw. You didn't have time of him. You needed to run. You needed to get away from the pain, from the suffering, but mainly from Jeff. The thought of Jeff cut like a rusty knife but apparently Zalgo knew that.
"Where is that knight in shining armor of your's, hm?~" he hummed teasingly. "What was his name? Jeff?" You knew you shouldn't have flinched but you couldn't help it. It hurt thinking about him. Zalgo smirked.
"Oh! Have I struck a nerve? A heart string maybe?" Zalgo teased. You glared at him.
"Leave me alone, you damned demon! I want nothing to do with you! I just want things to return to normal!" you said. Zalgo seemed amused.
"But (Y/N), you've killed before. After your first spill of blood, nothing will ever be the same. You know that, don't you?" he asked. You looked down.
"Yea..." you said, your voice quiet. Zalgo was silent until you felt a hand on you shoulder.
"Tell you what. I offer you a place in hell as one of my people and you can kill whoever hurt your precious little heart." he said, holding his other hand out. You looked at his hand, your mind racing. Yes, you were mad at Jeff but was he worth killing? Now that you thought about it, he should have listened! He should have believed you when you told him the truth! But no! He goes around back slapping you like you just shot his dog! But the more you thought about him fucking another strange woman, the more you wanted to cut his dick off from him. You clenched one of your fists while the other flew up to Zalgo's hand.
"Deal!" you said, your eyes showing how serious you were. He smirked.
"Good!" Suddenly, flames erupted around you but it didn't hurt you. When the flames finally disappeared, you fold yourself in a world completely covered in fire. Screams echoed from all over. You looked at Zalgo, who was smiling.
"Welcome to hell, (Y/N)."
YOU ARE READING
An interesting twist in fate(Jeff x reader)
ParanormalYour life probably would've stayed the same if it weren't for the teenaged boy you met in the woods. Read a story of meeting and forming a relationship with this insane, yet sweet boy. And I know it will probably be horribly made.