Supernatural Imagines: Book Two

Was It A Mistake?

Characters: Dean Winchester x Reader, Sam Winchester, Leviathan!Dean

Warnings: angst

Summary: You and Dean are broken up so why is he at your house saying these things that bring back your true feelings for him?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

When you saw the former love of your life standing at your front door, you were really confused. Yes, you and Dean were still friends after everything that happened, but you agreed to be separated unless one of you needed the other one. Usually, he would call in case you were busy with a hunt or had company over, so that is why you were confused. It's been a while since you last saw him, but he still looks as handsome as ever. It's been almost three years since you last saw him and only one since you last talked to him.

Your relationship with him was a messy one. Before you two became a thing, you were inseparable. There wasn't anything you two didn't do together. Sam thought it was cute how you two depended on each other for literally everything. The emotional attractiveness is what came first before the physical one. Sure, he was handsome as hell, but that wasn't the reason why you loved him so much. It was because of his personality that roped you in.

You two started dating shortly after the first time you two saw each other naked on accident. There was one of those doors that separate your room and his room, and he was the one that came barging in butt naked. Your relationship in the beginning was perfect. You two were at the stage where you couldn't keep your hands off each other no matter what. It got on Sam's nerves a lot, but he was glad his brother was happy.

It was only until six months in the relationship things started going south. You two argued on every little topic, there couldn't seem to be a middle ground with the two of you. Late nights turned into even longer ones because you two couldn't sleep in the same bed as each other. You two never cheated on one another while you were dating, but the relationship had to end if either one of you wanted to be happy.

It puzzled you as to why things started going south so early. When it came to hunts, you argued about what kind of plan to put into action. When you were at the grocery store, it was what kind of pie to buy. When it was organizing the storage room, it was what kind of system to have down there. Nothing seemed to please the two of you until you finally figured out what truly went wrong.

You two were too much alike.

It would explain almost everything that went wrong. You two were natural born leaders, you two didn't play well with others, you both liked being the alpha in the house, etc. Your personalities were so much alike that it was hard to live with someone like you. That's why they say opposites attract because it's nice to get away from yourself once in a while. If anything, you would most likely be compatible with Sam, but you didn't want to go down that road. Dean was still a good friend since you two decided that's what you two were ever going to be.

Since hunting proved to be difficult, you thought going your separate ways would be best and only hunting together if you absolutely needed someone. Since he didn't call before hand, you wondered why he was standing at your doorstep with a flirty smirk on his face. If he thought he could come to your house at night just for a booty call, then he has another thing going for him.

"Dean, what are you doing here?"

"What, I can't see my best friend? Is that a crime?"

"No, it's not. It's not like you to just stop by."

"Well, I was in the area and thought, 'why not'?"

"So, where's Sam?"

"He's not here. He met some nice lady at the bar and decided to go home with her instead," he chuckled. "You know my brother."