a bunch of Teen wolf imagines and preferences...

29- caught- Theo imagine

Request: for lukeybabe26 – you're secretly dating Theo and your sister Malia finds out

You and your sister, Malia, were close. You had stuck together through everything and you protected each other. For years you were all that each other had. But now you had a pack and a family and a boyfriend. You use the term boyfriend loosely; no one except the two of you knew about your relationship, as the pack didn't really trust him.

You and Theo were instantly drawn to each other, much to Malia and stiles' annoyance. After they had found out about your first date, they had forbidden you to see him. It had put a strain on yours and Malia's relationship, pulling you apart.

You explained the situation to Theo, but your feelings were too strong to ignore, so he suggested you date secretly. You hated lying and sneaking around but they left you no other choice.

You were sat in a café, waiting for Theo You had arranged a date amongst the madness in beacon hills. It had been a while since your last one and thought it would be a good idea to spend more time together. What you didn't think about was what the pack would be doing. You heard the door open and looked up, hoping it was Theo However your eyes landed on Scott, Kira, stiles and Malia.

You slid down in your seat, hoping they wouldn't recognise you, but it was hard not to, when the only free table was next to yours.

"Y/n, hey!" stiles greeted as he sat in the seat next to you. Stiles had become like a brother to you, and was now equally as protective as Malia.

"Hi" you said back, unsure whether to just leave and text Theo about what has happened. You didn't have time to do that, as the door opened and he walked in. he froze, looking at the tables and left, indicating for you to follow.

"I've got to go! Talk to you soon." You said to the group as you gathered your belongings together and headed for the door.

"Where are you going?" Scott asked, curiously.

"I've got a lot of homework to do." You replied, hurrying out of the door before they can question you further. You knew it was hopeless lying to werewolves.

You found Theo waiting for you down an alley not far from the café.

"I'm sorry about that, I had no idea they were going to be there." You apologised as you strolled down the path together

"I know y/n, it wasn't your fault. But since Malia is there, we could go to your house." He suggested.

"I like that idea" you smiled, pecking Theo on the cheek and heading to your house.

When you arrived your father was out, so you had the house completely to yourself. You headed up to your room and sat on the bed. You talked for a while, then started kissing. Things got heated quickly and Theo gently pushed you onto the bed, hovering over you with his one hand supporting his weight and the other roaming your body. You moaned into the kiss, running your fingers through his hair. With your consent, he pinned your arms above you head and started kissing your neck.

You were so lost in the moment, you couldn't focus on anything else other than you and Theo that's why you didn't hear Malia entering the house and walking up the stairs. You only acknowledged her presence when she opened your door and ran at Theo, growling.

"What the hell do you think you're doing?!" she yelled, pushing his off you hard, his back slamming into the wall. You felt as if you were stuck to the bed, everything around you happened so quickly.

"You're sick, forcing yourself onto my sister." She spat, tugging him up from the floor and holding him against the wall.

"Do you think its ok to just pin someone down and kiss them? Like they mean nothing? Like some sort of doll or toy to be used?" malia's claws were out, her teeth in a threatening snarl.

"I wasn't forcing myself onto her." Theo tried to explain, but Malia was too angry to listen.

"You can't make excuses for this! I'll tear you apart." She raised her hand about to attack him, but you grabbed onto it at the last minute.

"Malia! Stop" you cried, placing your hands on her shoulders to move her away from Theo

"You can't defend him y/n. not after what he's done." She argued. You turned her around to face you, taking a breath before you spoke.

"He didn't do anything wrong. We're dating..." you admitted, searching her face for a reaction. He claws retracted and her teeth returned to normal.

"What?" she muttered in disbelief.

"Theo's my boyfriend. We've been dating for a while now." You expected her to be mad, but she just looked hurt.

"Why didn't you tell me? I thought we told each other everything." She said sadly.

"We do, but you already tried to stop me from seeing him. I was going to tell you." She sat on your bed, thinking about what you just said.

"I don't want you to be with him." She stated bluntly.

"I know, but I am with him. I want to be"

"He's dangerous. We don't know if we can trust him. He could hurt you."

"And he's right here." Theo interjected, moving off his spot on the wall and walking towards you two. His comment earned a growl and a harsh look from Malia, not helping your case.

"But I trust him, Malia. I really do." You explained.

"That doesn't mean he won't hurt you." She said, looking down. You knew she was just looking out for you, protecting your feelings.

"I know you want to protect me, like I want to protect you. But you've got to let me make my own decisions. If I end up hurt, then it's my fault. Let me make my own mistakes and let me learn from them." You pleaded. She looked up at you, realising how much this meant to you.

"If it helps..." Theo added "I never want to hurt y/n. listen to my heartbeat, I'm telling the truth. I love her." You looked at him, shocked. He had never told you that before.

"I love you too" you confessed, blushing as he smiled down at you. You heard Malia exhale deeply.

"Fine. You can date, but if you make one wrong move, you're dead." She threatened, pointing at Theo

"I won't." He promised, leaning down and kissing you.

"Okay! Okay!" Malia exclaimed. "None of that though." She groaned, making you both laugh.