Evan Peters Drabbles

We're Not All Bad (Kyle Spencer [AHS] x Reader)

REQUESTED: Y/N works at the campus coffee shop & despises Kyle's frat house because they make a mess, are rude & obnoxious, & just plain jerks. Kyle was always in love with Y/N because they were a kind & compassionate person. So, he always felt terrible about what his house did. But then, [the reader] meet[s] Kyle (& doesn't know about his scholarship) & all he asks is for one date, one chance to prove them wrong, that not all frat guys are jerks & he does this big grand date?

------------------------------------------------------

"Go long!" One of Kyle's frat brothers roared as they threw a muffin towards another brother, who missed, causing the delicious baked good to fall to the ground & crumble into hundreds of bits of sugar & fruit. They all laughed & teased the brother who couldn't catch the pastry, causing him to get upset.

"Shut up, dick heads! That was a shitty throw!"

"Whatever! Your catching is just shitty!"

You, who had been diligently working in the back, came out & were greeted with the messy scene in front of you, causing your blood to boil. They did this every time they came to your coffee shop & you hated it. You hated every single frat brother that came, you hated their entire fraternity, Hell, you even hated the University, despite the fact that you also attended the same school.

"Hey! Knock it off!" you yelled as you angrily stormed out from behind the counter. The boys immediately stopped rough-housing as soon as they heard your pissed off tone, raising eyebrows at each other as you made your way over to them.

Kyle chose this awful time to walk into the shop & his eyes immediately fell onto his brothers. When he saw the mess they had made, he instantly sighed with disappointment. He pinched the bridge of his nose in anger as he shook his head. After a few moments, he saw & heard you & his shoulders instantly slouched with guilt. He knew you because he saw you yell at his brothers every single time they came to this coffee shop & he always felt so incredibly badly about his brothers' behaviors. He attempted to make up for it by leaving a wealthy tip behind, but either you never got the money or you didn't care because you were still always upset with them. Kyle had also heard you rant about his fraternity one day on campus while he was walking to his Physics class & you were walking to your Sociology class. He was right behind you & he recognized your exasperated tone immediately.

You were ranting to a classmate about your most recent encounter with Kappa Lambda Gamma & Kyle could tell how pissed you are.

"I swear to God those boys are absolute spawns of Satan! They always come in during my shift & cause a shitstorm that I always have to clean up. And, to top it all off, they're loud & rude & bother the other customers. We're losing business because of them! If we lose any more customers, my boss is going to demote me & have my head on a platter."

Kyle listened to you rant the entire way to his class & it just made him feel even more guilty, but it also made him want to prove you wrong & show you that not all frat boys were "spawns of Satan".

He remembered that idea as he watched you scold his brothers & he couldn't help but smile a little bit

"You all need to leave, now. You're disturbing other patrons & causing a mess," you walked over to the brother who initiated the food fight & pointed an accusing finger at him, "And if you & your brothers cause any more trouble, your asses will be kicked out of this joint for good," the brothers sighed & began to get their stuff, packing up to leave. Kyle tried to stay out of yours & his brothers' views as they eventually got everything & left. You sighed & went out back once more to grab a mop & a broom to clean up the mess.