Three: who would you rather...

55.9K 1.3K 575
                                    

Isabella's POV

When Lukas turned around and he saw Drew holding my hand, his face was a combination of hurt, anger, disgust and a hint of jealousy. That last one made me smile, because our plan was working. Lukas couldn't stand the fact I picked Drew of all people to bring to the game. After staring at us for a while he shook his head and turned away. Mother Theresa 1, Asshole Lukas 0.

"Of course you can play. Where were you?" Mia asked before winking at me when she gave Drew a once over.

"That would be my fault. I ran into her and we started talking." Drew said while we took a seat on the carpet next to Lukas on my side and Mia at Drew's.

"Drew, you don't even know her..." Lukas rolled his eyes while shooting daggers in Drew's direction.

"What do you know about that? I met her at the diner where she works. You should see her in her uniform. She's smoking." Drew bragged and it made me chuckle, even though he was probably just pretending.

"Why don't you two just get a room so you can fuck her now." Lukas snarled before shaking his head in disgust. Am I really that repulsive?

"I'm not like you." Drew spat. Oh god why do I sit right in the middle of this.

"Yeah, about that... How's your little sister?" Lukas raised his voice and at his words Drew flew over me in Lukas's direction. Before Drew could reach him I pushed him back to take a seat and put my hands on his cheeks.

"He is not worth it." I whispered before placing a gentle kiss on his cheek. His expression was soft and I'm sure he was enjoying this "pretend to like each other" just as much as I was. When my lips touched his skin I heard Lukas hiss in disgust. But all I felt was a warm feeling when I saw the look in Drew's brown eyes.

"You should be thankful I saved your rude ass." I said turning to Lukas. He looked surprise at first but his face quickly turned to a state of anger.

"I should be thankful? Please you couldn't even sa-"

"Quit acting like a child, you're supposed to be the older sibling." Mia cut him off followed by an eyeroll. "Are we going to play or what?"

"Okay Mia truth or dare." Lukas askes his sister.

"Dare."

"I dare you to drink five shots so you can finally shut the fuck up." Lukas raised his voice. What an ass!

"Where's the damn bottle." Mia sighed before taking five shots. I had to give it to her, this girl could drink shot after shot but still look elegant and hot.

"Truth or dare Olivia?" Lukas asked tilting his head to one side.

"Truth!" Olivia replied with a mischievous smirk on her lips.

"What do you think of the new girl?" Oh boy, he wants a war.

"Her?" She said pointing to me followed by Lukas nodding. "She's just another Plain Jane. Noting special really. Just a dull unmemorable face. She's probably a spoiled rich kid who payed her way into college because she doesn't seem very smart either." If only you knew Olivia. She was so far off... I worked my way into college and gained a full scholarship for being top of my class. And my parents, not rich at all nor pleasant. When she was done Lukas and Olivia burst out into laughter while the rest of the circle remained silent at her mean comment. When I looked down at my hands, I didn't even try to defend myself, Drew took my hand and squeezed it.

"Ben, truth or dare?" Olivia asked him.

"Truth!" Ben replied.

"How many girls have you slept with?" That bitch Olivia asked. As Ben went on about how many girls he took home I felt Lukas's eyes pinned on me. So I looked to the side and our eyes met. I don't know why but it caused the hairs on my arms to stand on edge. Was it hate or interest? I had no clue but looking into his grey eyes sure had some effect on me. His eyes shifted from mine to my neck down my arm to the bottle of Corona I was holding and he shook his head and looked away.Why can't I figure you out.

"Lukas, Truth or dare?" Ben asked him.

"Truth."

"Who of the girls would you rather kiss?"

"Okay let's see. One of them is my sister so no, that's disgusting. Olivia is annoying, but the new girl is annoying and not my type." He said before looking at me. "So, Olivia. At least she's hot." He said while still keeping his eyes on me. Lukas let out a laugh after he finished his sentence but I wasn't. He's was being an ass. I know loud and clearly I'm not his type but he doesn't have to rub it in every chance he gets... Asshole

"Jason, truth of dare?" Lukas asked him.

"Dare." While Jason completed his dare Lukas couldn't keep his eyes of me and it was bugging me. Why was he looking anyway? Trying to find things to humiliate me with...

"Isabella, Truth or dare?" Jason asked and I was forced to snap out of my head. I looked at Lukas and I knew for sure he was going to make a hurtful comment if I was going to choose truth.

"Dare!" Oh boy what have I done?

"Kiss one of the guys, your pick." Easy I'll pick the one who has actually been nice to me tonight!I leaned into Drew and he knew what to do. I placed one hand on his cheek to pull him closer and so did he. Before our lips completely touched he waited a second or two. Then I felt his lips softly touch mine and his hand on my neck pulling me deeper into the kiss. His tongue sild over my bottom lip asking for permission which I granted without a doubt. Who is dull and boring now, not me. Our kiss was getting passionate and I couldn't get enough but at that moment a hand grabbed hold of my elbow and pulled me back. When I broke away from my kiss with Drew I saw who prevented me from having another second in heaven. I looked down and it was Lukas who had his hand on my elbow. When I looked up to meet his eyes he let go of my arm. His eyes were dark though and I didn't understand the confusion on his face.

"He said kiss, not have sex." Lukas whispered but I decided to ignore him and I turned my body to Drew. He was grinning from ear to ear licking his lips with amusement written all over his face.

"Ben, truth or dare?" I asked him.

"Dare." He said before looking back and forth between Lukas and I. The reason? The ass was staring at me again.

"I dare you to take a shot?"

"Just a shot?"Okay that was silly, think fast.

"Nope, a shot that's a mix of every drink placed in the circle." Everyone started to oeh and aah the dare while Ben sighed and started mixing all the drinks.

"Alright, hope this doesn't kill me." He said while putting the glass to his lips before putting his head back and drinking it ad fundum. "That's disgusting." He said while squeezing his eyes and sticking out his tongue.

"Lukas, truth or dare?" Ben asked him with a sour face trying to get the bad taste from his mouth.

"Ha! Dare!" Lukas blurted out.

"Whisper something dirty in someone's ear." Ben said with a smirk on his face. What happened next completely caught me off guard.

First oneWhere stories live. Discover now