The Other James ~~ One Tree Hill FanFiction

Chapter Four

A/N: So, I know no one is even reading this story yet... but I am enjoying myself while writing it xD hehe

new chapter time!

Season 3 Episode 4

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Tonight was the night for the costume party, so we all went to go shopping. Haley and I decided to have our "serious talk" later in the day instead in front of Lucas. To be honest, I wasn't sure if I even wanted to go to this party... not that I was a loner or a party-pooper or anything, but I just wasn't sure if I wanted to be there.

"This party is my big shot at getting Brooke to forget this whole non-exclusive thing..." Lucas pouted, not liking any of the costume ideas Haley and I threw at him.

"Yeah, well, I could go naked to this thing and Nathan still wouldn't even notice me..." Haley said, walking away.

Luke and I glanced at one another and in sync said," Okay...ew."

***

Before the party, Haley and I met up at Karen's before hand to have our conversation.

"So, first of all, why are you being so harsh to Brooke? What's gotten into you?" Haley started.

That's when my hands began to get clammy and I started to shake, "I..uhm.. I've just got a lot on my plate, more than usual." I said, pausing to take a drink, "No worries."

"No worries? Toby you were drinking..." she pleaded.

I sighed, "Hales... I'll be okay. It's passed."

I know she still didn't believe me, but she let it go for the time being. I then received a text from Peyton.

Please tell me you're going tonight... I'll need a safe haven. -P.Sawyer

A small grin grew on my face, "Are you asking me on a date, Miss Sawyer?"

Yeah, sure, okay whatever. Just get over here alright?

I laughed and Haley shot a confused look at me, "What's that about?"

"I've gotta go meet up with Peyton... see you tonight?" I said, getting my things together.

"Yeah... I'll be all sexy according to Brooke."

I gave her a smile and a peck on the head and was on my way.

***

"What are you supposed to be? Do I get 3 wishes!?" Peyton mocked, seeing my Aladdin costume.

"Haha, so funny. What about you, huh? Here to take me in!?" I replied, as she was the angel of death.

"Fair enough." She sighed, taking a seat on her bed, "Can I ask you a question?"

I nodded, patiently waiting for her to go ahead. "You're feelings for Brooke... how'd you get over them?" she asked.

I inhaled, not expecting this question at all. "I guess, when you realize they don't feel the same way you just gotta get over it, ya know? Maybe find someone who understands and try to move on with them..." I said, making eye contact.

"I understand..." She said, scooting closer.

To be honest, I had no idea what was happening right now. But at the same time, I wasn't stopping it...in fact, the closer she got then the closer I returned. By now our foreheads were touching and her nose grazed mine.

"Peyton..." I breathed, not knowing if she wanted this or not.

She smiled, "I know." And with that, she pushed her lips to mine and placing a hand on my cheek.

Her father, with perfect timing, shouted from down the hall as we parted. "You two are gunna be late!"

"We should go then...huh, date." she smirked, leaving the room. I laughed in return and followed suit.

***

When we arrived Haley arrived, dressed as Sandy from Grease. Her and Peyton went back and forth, then Haley decided to walk away.

"Can't forgive her yet?" I pleaded.

She just rolled her eyes at me, that's when a guy in a batman costume approached us.

"Nathan? Holy Batman!" She joked, "Hate to admit it but, your wife looks pretty hot tonight."

A grin grew on Nathan's face but quickly vanished, "Haley always looks hot." he said, storming away.

The night went on, and we spotted Lucas dressed really out of the box for him.

"Brooke's gunna flip when she sees... she thinks he's the most disgusting thing ever." Peyton informed.

"Should we tell him?" I asked, but by then he was already making his way to Brooke and engaging in conversation.

I turned to face Peyton, "So...what was that?" I smirked," And do you plan on doing it again?"

She bit her lip and faced me, "I don't know, you tell me. You're the one with 3 wishes."

I breathed out a laugh, made eye contact with her and did it again. I placed my hand on her cheek and pulled her gently to me, into a soft kiss. When we separated I said, "I'm gunna go get a drink." and walked away.

Haley later joined me, "Okay, what the hell was that! I saw you and Peyton?" She asked.

"Non-exclusive I guess," I joked, "I don't know yet Hales, it kinda just happened." I smiled, looking over at Peyton who was talking to Brooke. Brooke also looked at me, then looked away as if I had hurt her in some way other than the bonfire.

"Well, just be careful..."

I gave her a reassuring smile, and took a drink of my soda. Haley went to talk to Karen, and I was approached by Nate. "You and Peyton huh? Wouldn't have guessed."

I shook my head, "Ya know, Nate, things happen. People, relationships, music...," I began and he realized where I was going right away, "Love is love though Nate, Especially you and Haley's." I finished, taking my drink and walking away. 

Not a moment later Haley fell on the ground, breaking glasses and people surrounded her laughing. Before I could step in, Nathan was the one that swooped in to take care of her. It made me smirk and I put my attention to Mouth and Peyton who were now dancing. I took a seat at the bar as they finished, then Karen took the stage in an attempt to introduce the band.

"Can I hear a 'woot woot'" She said, feeling awkward when the crowd went silent.

Then she got over it and Fall Out Boy took the stage, and the crowd went nuts.

"Can we talk?" A voice said, and I turned to see Brooke standing by.

We both left to her apartment to talk.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Skipping this part today! adios mis amigos

xD

till next time!

*kelsey*