Jealousy: The Full Series - An Andi Mack Fanfic

3x11 - No Control

Buffy's POV:
We all looked at Andi in shock. Well, who wouldn't? The girl just dropped to the floor and stopped moving.

Andi suddenly got up saying super dramatically, "I wooooke up in the hospitaaaal! I looked around, and I had forgotten EVERYONE!!!"

We all jumped back. "What the heck is she doing?" I asked.

Bex was laughing hysterically. "This is her punishment."

"For doing what?"

"You'll see."

(Time Skip To After Andi Explains The Whole Story)

After Andi's little performance, we were all just silent. I only understood like 5 words out of the entire speech.

Jonah said, "Do you want to explain that again?"

Andi looked at Bex. "Bex! Why did you make me explain it in such a dramatic way? Now I have to explain the story again."

Bex nodded. "That's the whole point of your punishment."

(Time Skip Again To After Andi Explains The Story... Again)

Once again, we all looked at Andi, completely silent, but this time, slightly mad. "You FAKED your amnesia?!" I shouted, causing everyone in the cafe to stare.

Amber looked at Iris, then to Jonah, then to Cyrus. "Does this normally happen?" she asked.

"Be lucky this rage isn't directed towards you."

Amber sunk into her seat and stayed quiet. Andi was frowning. "I'm sorry. I just didn't fully get over Jonah, and when I got my memories back, I took advantage of everything."

Cyrus seemed puzzled by something. "How long have you had your memories?"

"Since I kissed Jonah during our first date."

He looked at Jonah. "You kissed her?"

Jonah raised his hands in defense. "I was still under amnesia!"

Cyrus laughed. "Relax. I'm just joking with you." Saying that made Jonah calm down a little bit.

Iris asked, "I can kind of feel empathy for Andi here. If I'm being honest, if I were in her shoes, I'd do the same thing if it were Cyrus."

"You would?" Cyrus asked.

"Not really. Not even amnesia could make you straight."

All eyes were back on Andi. Jonah said, "Andi, can I talk to you alone?"

She nodded and both of them walked out.

—————

Jonah's POV:
I couldn't think of any other way to tell her this, so I just came out and told her. "Andi, how long is it going to take until you get over me?"

"What?"

"I'm sorry, but this crush you have on me has got to go away."

She got defensive. "Jonah, I can't just get over you just like that. Crushes don't work like that."

"It's either you get over me, or you find some way to control your jealousy."

"Control my jealou- this isn't some kind of ghost possessing my body."

"It might as well be." I was starting to get angry. "Just look at what you've been doing lately. You find out I have a crush on Cyrus, you get mad. We start dating, and you avoid us. And then, I get amnesia, and you take advantage of it by dating me."

"I said I was sorry, Jonah. Come on." Her eyes started to water. "Please forgive me."

I shook my head. "Not this time. I can't keep risking my relationship with Cyrus if it means you're going to get all mad and jealous again."

"I won't. I promise."

"That's what you told me last time. And now, look at what's happened."

"Jonah." She was sobbing now.

I couldn't stand it anymore. I just walked away from her. Too mad to look back. Too mad to notice how she felt. Too mad to even care.

—————

Cyrus's POV:
I was so conflicted. Andi's my best friend, but Jonah's my boyfriend. I know Jonah's technically right in this situation, but I can't just leave Andi in the dark like that. I have to be there for my friend.

———

Hey Jonah. I have to tell you something.

Yeah? What is it?

Please don't take this the wrong way, but I'm still going to be there for Andi. I don't want this to put a roadblock in our relationship.

Cyrus it's fine. Maybe with you and Buffy by her side, she might find some sense to control her emotions.

Thanks for understanding, babe. I'll talk to you later.

Night, Cyrus. 😘

—————

Bex's POV:
Andi was lying down, holding Baba in her arms. I sat on her bed. "Andi. Believe me. You have to at least talk to me. I really want to help you."

Still mopey, she said, "I don't think you can. You've never ruined a friendship with your crush."

"That doesn't mean I can't try help you repair that broken friendship."

"What is there to fix?! Jonah was right! I have no control over my emotions, and because of that, I lost Jonah. He hates me now."

"Andi, that's not true." I stood her up and hugged her, hoping something in that hug would make her feel better.

"Bex. Just admit it. I already did. Jonah hates me. And... It's all my fault."