🗡Yandere Black Butler Scenarios💕

🩸You find out about their first murder🔪

Phantomhive

Ciel

You panicked and attempted to leave but Sebastian caught you and brought you back to your room were Ciel was waiting. Ciel was just sitting in a chair with a creepy smile saying, "I didn't want you to figure out about that yet but ,alas, you unfortunately did Rabbit"

Sebastian

In all honesty, he most likely showed you on purpose so you could fear what would happen if you attempted to escape from him or if you got angry at him. 

Mey-Rin

You found out by seeing a puddle of blood on the ground that Mey-Rin forgot to clean but you didn't think anything of it since she told you that someone attempted to attack the manor which happened often.

Finny

Again, you weren't surprised due to the manor being under attack a lot.

Bard

You were a bit frightened due to the fact that bard burns attackers not stab them unless absolutely necessary, which doesn't happen often due to most of the attackers having guns.

Trancy

Alois

You were very scared and didn't dare to do anything because of how erratic Alois can get.

Claude

Claude, like Sebastian, would purposely show you just for both amusement and your fear.

Hannah

It probably happened on accident and when you did find out, Hannah just said in a nonchalant voice, "Someone attack his highness". 

The Triplets

Knowing the triplets you probably never found out since there were three killers at the scene.

The Circus

Joker

He would panic and so would you. Joker would try to make up a story but ,due to being in a panic, it didn't work very well. So, he just said that he didn't want them to take you away from him.

Beast

Beast is good at acting so she would say that betty attacked someone.

Dagger

Like Joker, he would be in a panic before just blurting out he killed them.

Snake

Knowing he had snakes, you most likely wouldn't say anything and attempt to be quite due to not wanting to get bit.

Doll

You found ashes of the person and when you asked her about it, she said she was burning old papers that had not use.

The Reapers

Undertaker

He is a mortician so he made the kill look like he was doing work so you paid no mind to it.

Grell

You already knew she was a grim reaper so Grell said that they were on the to-die list.

Ronald

With Ronald, you knew he was a grim reaper as well so ,like Grell, he made the excuse that the were on the to-die list. Both Grell and Ronald got in trouble for it though.

Others

Elizabeth

She didn't kill anyone

Madam Red

She said that they had died due to a sickness that couldn't be cured and her being a doctor, you believed her.